Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

CmdrLaForge

macrumors 601
Feb 26, 2003
4,645
3,144
around the world
DSC03830.JPG.jpg

Sydney
 

anotherscotsman

macrumors 68020
Original poster
Aug 2, 2014
2,369
16,735
UK
Right guys and galls, competition closed I'm afraid. Now for the unenviable process of choosing the winners.
[doublepost=1519933637][/doublepost]Right then, time to share my thoughts for what they're worth.

Firstly, thanks to everyone who made the effort to submit an entry - I'm always impressed by the range of takes on these themes and by the quality of the photos.

Secondly, please take my comments and relative rankings for what they are: a reflection of my personal preferences.

Given the quality of the entries I'm afraid I'm going to appear to be harsh (the disciplined Scot in me...) but I need some way to get to the podium places.

MacRy: What an atmospheric film noir photo. Given the low light levels, getting a reflection in the car door was a bit of an achievement. Love the colour tones.

mollyc: A lovely, crisp image showing the flower magnified through the drop. Technically first rate and I'd love to take a shot like this one. But...its not a reflection since the drop is a lens through which the flower is being viewed. Sorry, I did say about being harsh.

AlexanderofOz: I love the subtlety of the feather and even more so the subtlety of the reflection. A beautiful photo that I'd have on my wall any day.

Hughmac: I remember this chess set before - lovely crisp reflections that are so appropriate for the glass pieces. Nice angle on the board.

deep diver: So much to look at in this photo - the golden sax against the black background works so well - wondered where the reflections were until I saw the manuscript. very nice.

Keyrex: Nice clear reflections of the plants in the pond with simple but attractive composition. Again Mr Nasty appears when I say that this looks a bit more than a puddle to me...

AppleFanBoy: The B&W treatment really works well and I love the low-angle you used to get the studs reflected in the puddle. Gritty, industrial, nice one.

BvizioN: Boudoir-esque image with great use of the purple light to give a sort of seedy nightclub sort of look. Nice use of framing. I Like it a lot.

Clix Pix: I wondered if I'd get a Droste effect image and you came up with the goods! Nicely done given the small subject size you were dealing with.

inkmich: Just because it's a Porsche, doesn't mean that you get special treatment :) I Like the combination of the water drops and the tree reflection on the paint job. Nicely done both with the photo and keeping the car so clean!.

someoldguy: I had to look twice at this. Great capture of the reflections of one building in the other. Lovely clear photo which even retains a feeling of distance with the reflected building appearing almost recessed within the granite frontage. Like the fire escapes on the right. Love it.

Janichsan: A different take on building reflections from the previous one. Certainly gets across the high intensity of an Asian (Japanese?) cityscape, Nice one.

Kenoh: I like what you were trying to get with this one, just a little too-much in the way of glare for me. Must be the halo-effect of the Leica...:)

CmdrLaForge: Another building reflection, this time emphasising distortion. Nice simple image with great clarity. Like the composition a lot.

tcphoto1: As you've probably gathered, I don't feature people in my photos so I admire your skills here (surprised the BadGuy didn't put in an appearance). I like the way that you've used the mirror as a window into the world of the model herself- so relaxed and natural. Nice use of B&W and the angles further emphasise the seemingly casual (dare I say slightly voyeuristic?) capture.

rx7Dude: Another attempt at Porsche-based influencing. Nice how the dark glass of the door entry gives a bit of contrast against the light colour of the car.

Now to the podium:

3rd place: tcphoto1

2nd place: deep diver

1st place: AppleFanBoy

Highly worthy mentions go to AlexanderofOz and BvizioN and again thanks to everyone who posted. Over to you AFB.
 

MacRy

macrumors 601
Apr 2, 2004
4,351
6,278
England
Congrats to the winners. My personal favourite was someoldguy's entry. Absolutely loved that one. Great job.
 

Hughmac

macrumors 603
Feb 4, 2012
6,001
32,567
Kent, UK
Thanks for the great critiques, superb entries all round, and congrats to the winners.

Cheers :)

Hugh
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
57,003
56,026
Behind the Lens, UK
Right guys and galls, competition closed I'm afraid. Now for the unenviable process of choosing the winners.
[doublepost=1519933637][/doublepost]Right then, time to share my thoughts for what they're worth.

Firstly, thanks to everyone who made the effort to submit an entry - I'm always impressed by the range of takes on these themes and by the quality of the photos.

Secondly, please take my comments and relative rankings for what they are: a reflection of my personal preferences.

Given the quality of the entries I'm afraid I'm going to appear to be harsh (the disciplined Scot in me...) but I need some way to get to the podium places.

MacRy: What an atmospheric film noir photo. Given the low light levels, getting a reflection in the car door was a bit of an achievement. Love the colour tones.

mollyc: A lovely, crisp image showing the flower magnified through the drop. Technically first rate and I'd love to take a shot like this one. But...its not a reflection since the drop is a lens through which the flower is being viewed. Sorry, I did say about being harsh.

AlexanderofOz: I love the subtlety of the feather and even more so the subtlety of the reflection. A beautiful photo that I'd have on my wall any day.

Hughmac: I remember this chess set before - lovely crisp reflections that are so appropriate for the glass pieces. Nice angle on the board.

deep diver: So much to look at in this photo - the golden sax against the black background works so well - wondered where the reflections were until I saw the manuscript. very nice.

Keyrex: Nice clear reflections of the plants in the pond with simple but attractive composition. Again Mr Nasty appears when I say that this looks a bit more than a puddle to me...

AppleFanBoy: The B&W treatment really works well and I love the low-angle you used to get the studs reflected in the puddle. Gritty, industrial, nice one.

BvizioN: Boudoir-esque image with great use of the purple light to give a sort of seedy nightclub sort of look. Nice use of framing. I Like it a lot.

Clix Pix: I wondered if I'd get a Droste effect image and you came up with the goods! Nicely done given the small subject size you were dealing with.

inkmich: Just because it's a Porsche, doesn't mean that you get special treatment :) I Like the combination of the water drops and the tree reflection on the paint job. Nicely done both with the photo and keeping the car so clean!.

someoldguy: I had to look twice at this. Great capture of the reflections of one building in the other. Lovely clear photo which even retains a feeling of distance with the reflected building appearing almost recessed within the granite frontage. Like the fire escapes on the right. Love it.

Janichsan: A different take on building reflections from the previous one. Certainly gets across the high intensity of an Asian (Japanese?) cityscape, Nice one.

Kenoh: I like what you were trying to get with this one, just a little too-much in the way of glare for me. Must be the halo-effect of the Leica...:)

CmdrLaForge: Another building reflection, this time emphasising distortion. Nice simple image with great clarity. Like the composition a lot.

tcphoto1: As you've probably gathered, I don't feature people in my photos so I admire your skills here (surprised the BadGuy didn't put in an appearance). I like the way that you've used the mirror as a window into the world of the model herself- so relaxed and natural. Nice use of B&W and the angles further emphasise the seemingly casual (dare I say slightly voyeuristic?) capture.

rx7Dude: Another attempt at Porsche-based influencing. Nice how the dark glass of the door entry gives a bit of contrast against the light colour of the car.

Now to the podium:

3rd place: tcphoto1

2nd place: deep diver

1st place: AppleFanBoy

Highly worthy mentions go to AlexanderofOz and BvizioN and again thanks to everyone who posted. Over to you AFB.
Wow I'm shocked after all those cracking entries. Thank you for the win.

Let me have a think about the next one.
[doublepost=1519939877][/doublepost]
Might swap this out later if I find a better subject, but pullling this from my archives.

View attachment 752061
I'd be interested to know your set up for this Molly. I think it's a wonderful image.
 

mollyc

macrumors G3
Aug 18, 2016
8,065
50,762
I'd be interested to know your set up for this Molly. I think it's a wonderful image.

I honestly don’t recall. I took this years ago when I was teaching myself photography. At the time we lived in a house that had a sink in an island, so I think I was putting objects to one side of the faucet and I stood on the other and set the tap to a really slow drip. Then I used a flash for lighting (you can see some of the trails from that). And then just focused like mad to capture the drips. I seem to remember that the drips were not overly regular (nothing about that house was) so focusing was overly difficult.

I didn’t really think about this technically being refraction rather than reflection.
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
57,003
56,026
Behind the Lens, UK
I honestly don’t recall. I took this years ago when I was teaching myself photography. At the time we lived in a house that had a sink in an island, so I think I was putting objects to one side of the faucet and I stood on the other and set the tap to a really slow drip. Then I used a flash for lighting (you can see some of the trails from that). And then just focused like mad to capture the drips. I seem to remember that the drips were not overly regular (nothing about that house was) so focusing was overly difficult.

I didn’t really think about this technically being refraction rather than reflection.
What's two letters between friends!

I was just curios. The faucet (or tap to the rest of the world!) is a good idea. I've tried shots like this using a syringe, but the drips keep moving. Our sink is in the wrong place to use.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mollyc

Clix Pix

macrumors Core
Congratulations, Apple Fanboy, Deep Diver and TCPhoto1! All of the entries here were amazing, and it's neat to see people's creativity and how they approach a topic. Now I've got to go run a Google search on "Droste Effect," since I've no idea what that is..... LOL!
 

deep diver

macrumors 68030
Jan 17, 2008
2,711
4,521
Philadelphia.
Great. Thanks. Second is just what I wanted. All of the glory with none of the pain.
Congrats (and condolences) to AFB for an outstanding and worthy image. Looking forward to the next theme.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacRy

someoldguy

macrumors 68030
Aug 2, 2009
2,806
13,993
usa
Congrats to the winners. My personal favourite was someoldguy's entry. Absolutely loved that one. Great job.
Thanks , It's the spectacular view from my hotel window on a trip to San Francisco to annoy relatives . I'd gotten in around 1:30AM , dropped on the bed and , upon awakening , pulled back the blinds and there it was . Taken with a 17-40 IIRC . I remember having to spend a lot of time getting all the lines straight horizontally and vertically.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacRy

Alexander.Of.Oz

macrumors 68040
Oct 29, 2013
3,200
12,501
Thanks @anotherscotsman for the feedback/observations and a stellar job with the judging too! A tough one to be sure, with so many fine examples to choose from. Apologies for mixing up who did the adjudicating this week... Too many balls in the air!

Looking forward to what @Apple fanboy comes up with for the next round. Hmmm, obscure... is that a hint that it will maybe involve the use of a camera obscura somehow? AFB's possibly from that sort of vintage... ;)
 
Last edited:

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
57,003
56,026
Behind the Lens, UK
Thanks @kenoh for the feedback/observations and a stellar job with the judging too! A tough one to be sure, with so many fine examples to choose from.

Looking forward to what @Apple fanboy comes up with for the next round. Hmmm, obscure... is that a hint that it will maybe involve the use of a camera obscura somehow? AFB's possibly from that sort of vintage... ;)
Anymore of that talk and I'll make you the winner! Then you'll have to judge!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alexander.Of.Oz
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.