Well, it has been a week. Time for this contest to close. I'll be back with the winners soon.
[doublepost=1463161817][/doublepost]I’ll preface my comments stating that these are merely my observations and, at times, the random thoughts that went through my mind while looking at each photograph. The selection of winners comes more from a visceral reaction than any expert awareness or discernment. I applaud each and every person who entered the contest as it takes courage to expose something so personal to judgment by someone else – even in a forum as encouraging and supportive as this one. Others will undoubtedly have differing opinions than mine, but here we go:
MacRy: My first impulse was to laugh, but then I started to overthink and wondered whether this person was in actual danger. The close framing does a great job of removing it from any context that would confirm one way or the other. In the end, I convinced myself it was not the start of the zombie apocalypse, but rather a well-taken picture of a woman wearing a gas mask for the humor of it. Very nicely done.
Georgeinnj: My eyes are drawn in a few different directions in this picture. There is the dog, captured at the quintessential moment with his tongue licking his nose and then there are the children, two of whom are excited to pet the animal, but the third is apprehensive, preferring the comfort of his own blanket. I’m assuming the man is the dog’s owner and the kids are not his, but I could be wrong about that. I wonder what this photo would have looked like if taken from the children’s height or even from the dog’s height. The harsh mid-day shadows do little to take away from a nicely captured moment.
Alexander.Of.Oz: As my own children have grown, the subjects of my photography have become more diverse, moving from primarily sports to nature and landscapes to, more recently, portraits. In a strange way, this picture reminds me of the senior pictures I’ve taken recently in that it almost seems intentionally composed with the photographer having a meaningful connection with his subject. The fly, to me, appears to be posing for the camera. The depth of focus is consistent with a portrait with the sharpest focus being on the eyes. While I haven’t done much of it, I do enjoy looking at macro photography because of pictures like this. Very well done, indeed.
Glenthompson: One of the aspects of people photography done outside of the studio that I’ve always appreciated is the context, or lack of context, the photographer allows the viewer to see. Without context, the viewer's mind is allowed to imagine it. Was this photo taken while the subject and photographer were sitting at a table for lunch? Does the photographer even know the woman? Was she just walking when the photographer stopped her and asked to take her picture? The shade provides diffused, even lighting on the subject and she is well separated from the background. Her hair appears slightly disheveled as if it were a windy day. Why such a serious face? So many questions made that much more compelling by lack of context.
Needfx: Once again, I’m curious about the context of this photo. If I had to guess, I’d say it was a sporting event like a golf tournament or maybe even a horse race – or, it could be a social event of some kind. In any event, the subject is there to capture something on video but ends up being captured himself. I like the choice of black and white as it gives the shot a more ‘documentary’ or street photography feel. It would have been nice if the right eye of the subject was either totally obscured or not obscured by the camera. Another photo that, in my mind, raises more questions than it answers – but in a good way.
RedOctober: Animal, particularly bird, photography has been an interest of mine for a long time. However; I’ve never really possessed the patience (or the lens) to do it well. I would be tickled beyond belief if I were able to capture a picture of an owl similar to this one. The photo is well framed and tack sharp. Very nicely done.
Pmxperience: Taking a different approach than the pictures by MacRy and Glenthompson, this photo offers the viewer more context with which to draw conclusions. But, as with the other photos, can leave the viewer with more questions than answers. Is this man sad? Is he just in deep thought? His isolation in the picture lends credence to a feeling of loneliness and despair. A very compelling and engaging photo. Well done.
Inkmich: Certainly an unusual subject – at least not one I run into on the streets often. I’ve always found it fascinating to watch people go about their everyday lives, but I’ve rarely had the nerve to break out the camera and capture it. The shot is well composed, but it would have been nice to have the ‘Cat’ looking at the camera. I think that would have been more engaging. The overcast sky helped to diffuse the light, but it also doesn’t allow for the subject to ‘pop.’ Nice take on the theme.
E3BK: Another photo in which the context is provided, but this time the photographer chooses to broaden the depth of field, giving the background the same focus as the child. That choice allows the viewer to clearly see the primary subject (the child) in the proper context (the ruins). Was the destruction part of a natural event like a hurricane or man-made? The juxtaposition of the innocent child with the devastation around him tugs at the heartstrings. A very emotional and well-made photo.
Illuminated: Great timing on your entry as the obvious joy in this photo helped lighten my mood from the previous photo. The overcast sky provides nice, even lighting and the focus on the dog in the upper third creates the right amount of interest. The connection between the man and dog is evident and their friendship shows through loud and clear. Nicely done.
Miltz: Very well done portrait of an older gentleman. I’ve often struggled with the choice between extreme depth of field (to make the buttery smooth background as in this photo) and the desire to have as much of the subject in focus as possible. In this picture, I believe the DOF choice was a good one (even with the ears out of focus) as the viewer is drawn to the well-textured face and the deep blue eyes (complemented well by his blue shirt). Would be interesting to see it in B&W as well.
Kenoh: This photo reminds me of a newborn shot with the blanket wrapped baby lying in a basket. The focus is spot on, providing a sharp view of the dog with both the foreground and background melting away. Nicely done.
Gasworks: Very interesting. Very interesting, indeed. A creative use of bokeh to craft the glow behind the skull. The rich colors in the background help enhance the mood, but the white line on the left hand side is a slight distraction. Perhaps it would be an even stronger composition if the left side was symmetrical in tone with the right. The focus on the skull is perfect – not an easy thing to do with something that dangles. Overall, it was very well conceived and implemented.
Deep Diver: There is a reason why people say cats own the internet – they can be cute, they aren’t afraid to be themselves, and have more attitude than almost all other animals combined. This picture certainly displays plenty of attitude, as if she is saying “who dares to tread on my property?” The look on her face is very intense and her focused locked on something in the distance. As with other photos in this thread, there is a story outside the frame. This one leaves me wondering if she ever ‘captured’ her prey – but to a cat, the stalking is the objective, not the capture.
Hughmac: I like the choice of black and white even though the contrast between the dog and the blanket is not dramatic. If cats are the kings of the internet, dogs are their unwilling jesters. It is hard not to find the unconditional love of dog endearing. In this photo, Sam seems to be both tired and curious, wondering why its master is making the clicking noise with box in hand. We done getting such a steady shot with the slow shutter speed. I like the lighting and the depth of field. The ears being up in an inquisitive manner is the icing on the cake.
Robotti: Nicely composed portrait. Lighting is well-managed, the pose holds interest, the red covering complements the model’s hair while at the same time providing contrast with the model’s skin tone. The eyes draw the viewer in and don’t let go. More separation from the background would have been nice, but a very well executed portrait overall. Lovely model as well.
AlexH: It is interesting that there are as many animal photo entries as there are people. Here we have another dog and another interesting story – at least with regard to the one I created in my mind. The window sill in the bottom of the frame helps set the scene perfectly. The owner is away from home (or just arriving back?) and the dog is anxiously awaiting his or her arrival. The longing in the dog’s eyes is captured beautifully and the black and white adds to that sense of desperation. Wonderfully composed.
Compasiune11: Nice, vibrant colors make for a very pleasing portrait – and a pretty subject always helps. Good job on filling in the light from the front, producing a natural looking result. If it were my picture, I would tone down the oils on her face just a little and remove the white (a reflection?) in her hair just above the eye on the right. Even with those, the portrait was very well done – especially if it is straight out of the camera with no editing. Great job.
Someoldguy: Interesting take on the theme. Beyond the Native American mural, the colors definitely promote a southwestern setting. As appropriate, my attention is consistently drawn to the picture of the man in the middle of the frame. Curious to know whom the man is – or whether he actually exists. Is he just part of someone’s vivid imagination? Love the vibrant colors.
Apple fanboy: Another interesting take – good job being creative everyone! Again, the lack of context generates a ton of questions. Is this an art project? Is this in an art gallery somewhere? What does the entire piece look like? I envision the aftermath of bombing or some other man-made destruction. I like the tight crop as it preserves so much of the mystery, such as to whom does the hand belong? A child next to a fallen parent? Nice placement of the facts, as well, respecting the rule of thirds. A compelling, but disturbing image.
Anotherscotsman: I had to do a little research to dissect your title, but it made complete sense once I did. I may be wrong, but it looks like you used a long exposure, capturing the movement of the clouds while allowing the trees and sculpture to remain sharp. I went back and forth between whether more exposure on the sculpture itself would add to the photo, but I ultimately agreed with your choice. A brighter subject in the foreground would have detracted from the dreaminess of the overall picture. Nicely done.
Mdeprospo: This looks like it was taken a world away from New Hampshire – more like in the Middle East. If you hadn’t provided the location, I would have assumed someplace entirely different. The contrast and saturation seem a bit high, but the sweater and scarf are full of wonderful colors that help the subject stand out from the hazy background. The direct eye contact and serious expressing are engaging.
Pol0001: I really like the composition of this photo as it helps to create a little tension. From the vantage point (looking up at the subject) to the slight skew of the frame, everything is complementing the subject well. The choice of black and white also helps enhance the perceived tension I feel. She could be the nicest person in the world, but her expression coupled with the aspects of the photo listed above would give me pause in engaging her. Very nice example of street photography.
Dwfaust: Who doesn’t love a picture of a baby? Nice job recognizing a photo opportunity and then taking it! The car seat is a bit of a distraction, but the pose is adorable and the lighting is great. I didn’t learn to appreciate photography until after my children were older, so I truly regret not being able to capture moments like this with them. I guess grandchildren can present another chance, but that will be several years out for me. Nice picture.
And the winner is…
I was keeping track of this thread throughout the week, jotting down notes and moving the pictures in and out of the top three. All told, I probably had about two dozen different combinations with a mixture of ten or so photos involved. It wasn’t easy picking a ‘winner’ as there were so many that could justifiably replace the ones I selected. Here they are:
Third Place: gasworks
Second Place: pmxperience
First Place: Alexander.of.Oz
Thanks to everyone for entering.