that is exactly how I would sum up my initial thoughts. i was hoping for a MBP but thinner, and when the Air came out it seemed like a bit of a let down. but after spending some time on one at an Apple store, I realized it had all I was actually looking for...and more.Ok let me tone it down a bit here... I wasn't a hater... but more of a... its not for me mindset.
until I realized that I was never really using my MBP to its fullest... just do random web surfing... lots of media... photos, vids, and music.
really it turned out it was exactly what I needed.