Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

pachyderm

macrumors G4
Jan 12, 2008
10,783
5,447
Smyrna, TN
yep.

ya can't ell me. ya simply can't. understood.

and i'm just obnoxious enough to burrow away at ya for a bit. but that is the end.

i respect your privacy.

i could tell by your replies on here that you were pretty smart. and if you weren't a professional writer, you should have been!

it was all done in jest and i hope i haven't offended you. ;)
[doublepost=1465934666][/doublepost]Now, this is what I'm re-reading this week/month. One of my all time favorite histories on the Napoleonic era.

$_35.JPG
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,199
47,583
In a coffee shop.
yep.

ya can't ell me. ya simply can't. understood.

and i'm just obnoxious enough to burrow away at ya for a bit. but that is the end.

i respect your privacy.

i could tell by your replies on here that you were pretty smart. and if you weren't a professional writer, you should have been!

it was all done in jest and i hope i haven't offended you. ;)
[doublepost=1465934666][/doublepost]Now, this is what I'm re-reading this week/month. One of my all time favorite histories on the Napoleonic era.

$_35.JPG

Okay, tell me about George Dallas's book.

Why you like it and rate it so highly: Plusses, minuses. Also, - and yes, this is laziness on my part - when was it published?
 

pachyderm

macrumors G4
Jan 12, 2008
10,783
5,447
Smyrna, TN
It covers the Congress of Vienna, and describes the international intrigues that went along with the congress. Tsar Alexander, Talleyrand, Castlereagh, Wellington, and Metternich, and "even Beethoven makes an appearance, debuting his Seventh Symphony in Vienna that winter." My favorite parts involved Catherine, Grand Duchess of Russia. Factual and accurate, from what I could tell, and his use of personal gossip helps make this an easy read. Napoleon is there as well, in the background, in exile at Elba, and "Dallas spends the final sections of his book describing the general's escape and downfall at Waterloo."*

+Relatively quick read 469 pg. Thorough, at least for me it was.

- May not be thorough enough for true scholars.


Pub. 1997


"..." *Part my review, part online review. Been awhile since I've read it and I didn't want to leave anything out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,199
47,583
In a coffee shop.
It covers the Congress of Vienna, and describes the international intrigues that went along with the congress. Tsar Alexander, Talleyrand, Castlereagh, Wellington, and Metternich, and "even Beethoven makes an appearance, debuting his Seventh Symphony in Vienna that winter." My favorite parts involved Catherine, Grand Duchess of Russia. Factual and accurate, from what I could tell, and his use of personal gossip helps make this an easy read. Napoleon is there as well, in the background, in exile at Elba, and "Dallas spends the final sections of his book describing the general's escape and downfall at Waterloo."*

+Relatively quick read 469 pg. Thorough, at least for me it was.

- May not be thorough enough for true scholars.


Pub. 1997


"..." *Part my review, part online review. Been awhile since I've read it and I didn't want to leave anything out.

The reason I wondered about the date was that, often, with history books, you will get a number of books on a particular topic published simultaneously around the date of a significant anniversary.

Then, it can be difficult to distinguish between them; I usually rely on reviews, or my own knowledge - there are some writers whose work I respect, while others do not much excite me.

Given that the bicentennial of Waterloo occurred in 2015, I assumed that the book may have been a recent publication that sought to cash in on that.

However, sometimes, a recently published work would have been able to take advantage of scholarship - or sources - that had become available since the last works on that topic had been published.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm

AVBeatMan

macrumors 603
Nov 10, 2010
5,968
3,849
Lovely quote, but I'd have a very hard time picking five favourite books. There are just so many to choose from...

I know, very difficult. Off the top of my head and in no particular order;

Rebecca by Daphne de Maurier
Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier
The Stand by Stephen King
David Copperfield by Charles Dickens
The Death and Life of Charlie St. Cloud by Ben Sherwood

All for different reasons but mainly because I couldn't put them down!
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,199
47,583
In a coffee shop.
I know, very difficult. Off the top of my head and in no particular order;

Rebecca by Daphne de Maurier
Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier
The Stand by Stephen King
David Copperfield by Charles Dickens
The Death and Life of Charlie St. Cloud by Ben Sherwood

All for different reasons but mainly because I couldn't put them down!

Rebecca and David Copperfield, I have read (and agree, both are excellent), the others I haven't and must add to my 'to-read/must-read' list.

A book which I would class in the 'I couldn't put it down' category - though I am not sure whether I would class it as a 'top five' - was Emily Bronte's "Wuthering Heights".

I came to it rather late, and, having heard so much about it, was rather wary of it, for fear that it wouldn't live up to its stellar reputation. So many books don't.

It was on the bookshelves of an exceptionally well stocked private and personal library in a lovely nineteenth century apartment - parquet floors, modern art on the walls, high ceilings - belonging to an academic that I rented in the Old Town of Vilnius for a few months in the early 1990s - not long after the collapse of the old USSR - that contained many, many books in at least four languages.

Anyway, I picked it up one night, as I thought to make its acquaintance. (That same library contained almost all of the early works of Saul Bellow, which I read, needless to say, plus the superb 'Herzog'). I thought that now was the time to read this book, and see if it lived up to its reputation.

I am rarely breathless with suppressed tension - but that was one book I sat up reading through the night, and finished after dawn had broken over Vilnius. Extraordinary - and gripping - visceral in fact, - and powerful. I had to take a break every few hours to make a coffee and pace and prowl. Ooooof.

Well, perhaps, reading what I have just written, it may well merit a place in a 'top five'.

George Orwell's 'Animal Farm' would be in there, too. A terrifying political fairy tale, a masterful insight into questions of political philosophy and matters of power, a searing and centred moral compass, and a spare prose that is flawless in its deceptive simplicity.

Now, as to the others.......I must put some further thought into this....
 
Last edited:

AVBeatMan

macrumors 603
Nov 10, 2010
5,968
3,849
Rebecca and David Copperfield, I have read (and agree, both are excellent), the others I haven't and must add to my 'to-read/must-read' list.

A book which I would class in the 'I couldn't put it down' category - though I am not sure whether I would class it as a 'top five' - was Emily Bronte's "Withering Heights".

I came to it rather late, and, having heard so much about it, was rather wary of it, for fear that it wouldn't live up to its stellar reputation. It was on the bookshelves of an exceptionally well stocked private and personal library in a lovely nineteenth century apartment belonging to an academic that I rented in the Old Town of Vilnius for a few months in the early 1990s that contained books in at least four languages. Anyway, I picked it up one night, as I thought to make its acquaintance.

I am rarely breathless with suppressed tension - but that was one book I sat up reading through the night, and finished after dawn had broken over Vilnius. Extraordinary - and gripping - visceral in fact, - and powerful. I had t take a break every few hours to make a coffee and pace.

Well, perhaps, reading what I have just written, it may well merit a place in a 'top five'.

George Orwell's 'Animal Farm' would be in there, too. A terrifying fair tale, a masterful insight into questions of political philosophy and matters of power, a searing and centred moral compass, and a spare prose that is flawless in its deceptive simplicity.

Now, as to the others.......I must put some further thought into this....

Ha! As I say, off the top of my head. It's a wonderful thing that any "top five books" will change and evolve over time. Withering Heights" was my late wife's favorite and she told me of an occasion, when living in Toronto, on a bus, she burst out crying! Lovely memories. The Death and Life of Charlie St Cloud was the last book she ever read. That's not the reason it's in my (current) top five, but because I just remember it giving me comfort. I read it then passed it on to her. It's since been made into a film although I've not seen it. I suppose there's the rub, it's how a book makes you feel, or think, be it a classic or "any old trash". That's what makes any book great.

Ps, loved Animal Farm. Simple, complex, imaginative, original, thought provoking. And nice and short. Very good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

pachyderm

macrumors G4
Jan 12, 2008
10,783
5,447
Smyrna, TN
...David Copperfield, I have read (and agree, both are excellent), the others I haven't and must add to my 'to-read/must-read' list.



George Orwell's 'Animal Farm' would be in there, too. A terrifying political fairy tale, a masterful insight into questions of political philosophy and matters of power, a searing and centred moral compass, and a spare prose that is flawless in its deceptive simplicity.

Now, as to the others.......I must put some further thought into this....

DC/Dickens - Never read it. Now I must.

AF/Orwell - Is there a more perfect work? And if you are a student and have to read it for class you jump for joy when you see how short it is! ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamesMike

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,199
47,583
In a coffee shop.
DC/Dickens - Never read it. Now I must.

AF/Orwell - Is there a more perfect work? And if you are a student and have to read it for class you jump for joy when you see how short it is! ;)

Well, I used it when I taught politics, - and used to tell the students to read it and think about it.

For a student of politics (both in life and academia) I do not think here is a more perfect book. To be honest, it is the one book I would have considered selling my soul to have been able to say that I wrote it.

The prose - spare, sure, exquisitely elegant and perfectly placed - is like a Mozart symphony, not a single word is out of place. It reads deceptively easily, and with a disturbing, and flawless fluency. And then, there is the savagely insightful understanding of politics and power and the betrayal of ideals.

It is so rare to have a work on political philosophy that is both intellectually brilliant and a work of artistic and literary genius.

Mind you, if you want to offer 'brilliant and short' works on politics to students, Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince (which I also taught, when I taught Renaissance history) must rank up there, too.

Great book, thought provoking, very readable, and absolutely guaranteed to start bitter intellectual fights in the classroom once the students begin to realise what it is actually all about.
 
Last edited:

AVBeatMan

macrumors 603
Nov 10, 2010
5,968
3,849
Hello folks. This is "Medz1" Always hated the name so had to create another. Anyway, it's me!
 

AVBeatMan

macrumors 603
Nov 10, 2010
5,968
3,849
You could ask the mods to change it, and they will, which will leave all of your posts under your new (or preferred) name.

I didn't think of that. Will request now. Thanks.

While "I'm" here, I've just bought a copy of Animal Farm from the Folio Society. Used but "like new" for £10. Thought it was needed in my "Folio Society" collection. Not bought one for a while.
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,199
47,583
In a coffee shop.
I didn't think of that. Will request now. Thanks.

While "I'm" here, I've just bought a copy of Animal Farm from the Folio Society. Used but "like new" for £10. Thought it was needed in my "Folio Society" collection. Not bought one for a while.

Enjoy Animal Farm - it is brilliant, but I have already set out my view of this masterpiece.

Use the 'contact us' option on the drop down folder under 'support' at the top of this (and every) page.

Explain who you are, and what you would like to do, namely, that you would like to change the name under which @Medz1 posts to that of Dave Meadows; also point out that you have just opened another account - I'm not sure that you are supposed to have two - and ask for it to be cancelled.

What should happen is that the name under which all of your posts appear should then be changed, but it may take them a day or two to get around to doing that. Then, you can re-introduce yourself, in this thread, and some of the others which you tend to frequent.

Good luck.
 

AVBeatMan

macrumors 603
Nov 10, 2010
5,968
3,849
Enjoy Animal Farm - it is brilliant, but I have already set out my view of this masterpiece.

Use the 'contact us' option on the drop down folder under 'support' at the top of this (and every) page.

Explain who you are, and what you would like to do, namely, that you would like to change the name under which @Medz1 posts to that of Dave Meadows; also point out that you have just opened another account - I'm not sure that you are supposed to have two - and ask for it to be cancelled.

What should happen is that the name under which all of your posts appear should then be changed, but it may take them a day or two to get around to doing that. Then, you can re-introduce yourself, in this thread, and some of the others which you tend to frequent.

Good luck.

Yes, I have already done as you say. Thank you.

I've already read Animal Farm, many years ago. At the time I was desperate to read as many books as I possibly could and as a result "missed" some of the "brilliance" of some. I think that's why I love Dickens so much; you have to take your time and appreciate the page to get the full benefit (at least I do)...
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,199
47,583
In a coffee shop.
Yes, I have already done as you say. Thank you.

I've already read Animal Farm, many years ago. At the time I was desperate to read as many books as I possibly could and as a result "missed" some of the "brilliance" of some. I think that's why I love Dickens so much; you have to take your time and appreciate the page to get the full benefit (at least I do)...

Let them know that there is a second account with the name you wish to use; otherwise, their records will show that this name is, in fact already in use, even though the account (in the name of Dave Meadows) was only set up earlier today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AVBeatMan
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.