Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is very good information. In my research it is often mentioned to have a USB 3.0 or higher connected DIRECTLY to the iMac. So, I'll do as I'm told ;)

Now to find a respectable drive, within reason.
 
Those who clone and perform backups of their iMac, what hard drive are you backing up or cloning to?

3TB AirPort Time Capsule for OS backups, a 4-drive enclosure to store and backup data, google drive for relevant documents and files, and google photo unlimited to have one more online clone of iCloud photo library.
 
Nothing really wrong with that drive, but you are paying a HUGE price premium with that drive since it has Thunderbolt... and that is really not needed just for backup. If you search Best Buy there are a bunch of USB3 portable 1TB drives for $60. I can't think of any reason to pay over $100 more for Thunderbolt or a backup drive.

IMO something like this WD model for $59.99 would be a much better deal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: circatee
I use a Synology NAS with 2 x 3tb WD Reds set up in RAID 1 (technically SHR).

Works beautifully! Never even experienced as much as a hick up. I've restored plenty of files from my Time Machine but never done a full restore, I don't see why it wouldn't work though.

image.jpeg
 
Every time I read your post, on my threads or others users threads, you're ALWAYS so knowledgeable and helpful. THANKS!

And thanks for this reply, along with the link.

Nothing really wrong with that drive, but you are paying a HUGE price premium with that drive since it has Thunderbolt... and that is really not needed just for backup. If you search Best Buy there are a bunch of USB3 portable 1TB drives for $60. I can't think of any reason to pay over $100 more for Thunderbolt or a backup drive.

IMO something like this WD model for $59.99 would be a much better deal.
 
Ha, I have a Seagate 500GB 3.0 USB drive. I just found it in my 'IT box'! That'll do :)
I also have a Samsung SSD, 256GB. Maybe I'll use that to clone the OS every so often...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Weaselboy
Well, well. Between my data and my missus data, we have almost 350GB's. I was under the impression that we had much less than 256GB. It would have been much easier to clone the drive and run the OS from the SSD. Then use the SATA USB drive, for Time Machine backups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Weaselboy
Just to add to and reinforce a couple of the comments above:

1. If you are backing up to just a single disk there's no point in the extra expense of lightning. You will be limited by the speed of the disk. Running Blackmagic tests on a couple of my disks showed 42.8 MB/s write, 42.9 read on a FreeAgent drive and 75.6/82.5 on a backup plus drive. So for the first disk even USB2 might work (60 MB/s theoretical). For the faster disk USB3 would be overkill - 640 MB/s - almost 7.8 times faster than the drive (theoretical).

2. For How long do your want to keep your Time Machine backups? The larger the drive the longer that you can keep your backups until Time Machine starts deleting old ones. One of my two TM backups goes back to October. 3.17 TB is backed up, and 1.29 TB is still available on that 6 TB disk. For my largest directories (Pictures, Music, Video) there isn't much churn so I don't have lots of versions of very large files which would fill the disk very quickly.

My personal experience is, however, that the longer the TM disk has been used the greater the chance of an error. I have had to rebuild this disk with Disk Warrior multiple times. But this is likely due to my setup.

Again I have had the unfortunate experience of trying to restore from a TM disk and the restore failed as the TM image was corrupted. I haven't found any reliable way of verifying that a TM image is good.

3. Somewhere I remember reading (think it was Larry Jordan's website) that if you have something critical that you absolutely do not want to lose you need to keep it on 3 different devices on 3 different media types. For example backup to disk, tape, and online. If you are just using disks then they should all be different models, ideally from different manufacturers. His perspective is for a professional video production site, but I think the advice is valid.

4. Don't backup to a disk and expect that disk to be useable in 5 years, for a number of reasons.

a. If file formats or drivers change you might not be able to read the drive.

b. Connectors change. I forgot that I had the BlackMagic numbers above in Evernote so I was going to hook the drives up to get the numbers. One of the drives is FireWire. I had cleaned up my cables and can't find the Firewire cable. And even if I did find it I would have to use an OWC dock that gives me a Firewire port since my computer doesn't have one. At some point OWC and other vendors will no longer make lightning to Firewire docks and these disk will just be paperweights.

b. Drives have a half life. The magnetic information on the disk fades over time if it is not used. This is done automatically if you are using the drive, but it doesn't happen if it is in storage. A recommended procedure is to read all of the files on the disk every 6 months. You can do this using the unix command at the terminal

sudo cat /dev/rdisk0> /dev/null

Here are links to the original articles:

https://larryjordan.com/articles/hard-disk-warning/
https://larryjordan.com/articles/technique-refreshing-hard-disk-storage/

Again, this is advice for a professional video shop but it's something to keep in mind. If you ever need online video training for FCP or Premiere Larry is the guy you want.

5. You can get unlimited online storage for $60 a year. This is Crashplan's price, but there are at least two other vendors with pricing ~$100. I backup about 8.2 TB (unlimited) for $60 a year. Dropbox charges $99 a year for just 1 TB.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: circatee
I am not a power user, I just have a simple USB3 WD My Passport set for Time Machine to backup automatically. (It is a nice metal edition silver one that matches the iMac!) It has proved its worth several times already. I doubt that speed would be an issue as it just does its thing quietly in the background, and apart from having a look every week or so to check that it is working okay, I never think about it until I want to reverse some changes I have made.
 
Based on the current hardware I have. This might be my method over the next day or so...

- Running the Mac OS from an external SSD (256GB)
- Time Machine backups to either my internal 1TB Fusion drive, or another USB 3.0 2TB Western Digital drive
- Clone copy of the OS, etc. on 500GB SATA USB 3.0 drive

Seriously people, the 1TB Fusion drive isn't as fast as it could be. Well, I guess it would be if I upped it to having a 128GB or 256GB SSD. But the cost. UGH!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.