Looks like you responded to the thread title and didn't bother to read the OP.... Here it is, just to refresh your memory:
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
what to buy as replacement for my kid's ipad
- Thread starter kevjen888
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Looks like you responded to the thread title and didn't bother to read the OP.... Here it is, just to refresh your memory:
I would get the 2017 iPad. Or maybe during Black Friday, a 9.7 Pro with a Pencil. Just a suggestion.
You make it sound like it's the family's iPad, not hers specifically. if it is hers, why would you want to buy something better as a replacement. particularly when the unit was quite new to begin with. wouldn't it make more sense to go with the cheapest option to get the job done? It doesn't really make sense to essentially reward your kid for breaking their stuff, that can come back to haunt you later. In that situation, i'd expect most people to buy the cheapest Android tablet available in that situation, at least as a temporary replacement just to drive home the point that iPads don't grow on trees and must be cared for. even if it was an accident that she couldn't really do much to prevent you should still not go any higher than you had to.
if you can, you really should wait for Black friday though.
if you can, you really should wait for Black friday though.
Quite frankly, weight difference between Pro 9.7 and 2017 iPad is pretty negligible. Also, while the 2017 iPad does have an inferior display, replacement parts (display) are also cheaper in case the screen breaks again.
- ipad mini 4
- ipad pro 9.7
- ipad 2017
My second grader has an iPad mini 4 that she inherited from me when I got the full size 2017 iPad back in April. But she knows that if it breaks it, I’m replacing it with the same $50 fire tablet that her younger sister has.
Both kids will be getting Chromebooks from school starting in third grade.
Which is fantabulous, unless the school has implemented e-learning that does indeed require the use of a device.
Maybe it can be done on a computer, but a tablet is a more natural experience. He didn’t ask how to parent.
I homeschool, and we have the following mix of iPads.
Air1
9.7 Pro with pencil
12.9 Pro2 with Pencil
(and mini2 that my 21yo is using since her windows tab died)
The ones with the pencils are the most sought after and used. Granted my kids are doing more than reading on them, but honestly the Pencil is an amazing feature for education stuff. My 13yo has fine motor issues (strange since she was a competitive gymnast). She loves to draw on the iPad with the pencil, and edit pictures. She can do this on the Air1 (which is “hers” technically), but the pencil adds to the experience and is easier for her. She has a stylus for the Air, but it just isn’t the same. At this point, my plan is to pick up another 9.7.
And those on the infamous MR parenting advice train, never fear, my kids read dead tree books, we own thousands of them... in fact, the 13yo above hates ebooks.
So my recommendation is the 9.7, with the Pencil eventually.
Air1
9.7 Pro with pencil
12.9 Pro2 with Pencil
(and mini2 that my 21yo is using since her windows tab died)
The ones with the pencils are the most sought after and used. Granted my kids are doing more than reading on them, but honestly the Pencil is an amazing feature for education stuff. My 13yo has fine motor issues (strange since she was a competitive gymnast). She loves to draw on the iPad with the pencil, and edit pictures. She can do this on the Air1 (which is “hers” technically), but the pencil adds to the experience and is easier for her. She has a stylus for the Air, but it just isn’t the same. At this point, my plan is to pick up another 9.7.
And those on the infamous MR parenting advice train, never fear, my kids read dead tree books, we own thousands of them... in fact, the 13yo above hates ebooks.
So my recommendation is the 9.7, with the Pencil eventually.
Honestly, I would just get the iPad 2017 right now. How has your child been doing their assignment while you have been contemplating what iPad to get?
Have you asked your child which one they prefer? While each has its own advantanges what about carrying weight, hand size, portability, etc? How many other things do they have to carry to school each day?
That’s where I would start with it...and not worry so much about future proofing.
The iPad 2017 model isn’t really “future-proof”. It’s slightly faster than an Air 2 and that’s it. It has an inferior display, bigger and heavier compared to the Air 2. If you want more future-proof, go for the 9.7Pro. Coming from an Air 2, the 2017 is probably more of a side-step/downgrade.
The 2017 iPad has a dual-core A9 chip, while the Air 2 has a tri-core A8X chip. The 2017 is faster on single core, but the Air 2 is still faster on multi-core. I think the 2017 iPad will only be supported as long as the Air 2 is, and that device is 3 years older.
The 2017 iPad has a dual-core A9 chip, while the Air 2 has a tri-core A8X chip. The 2017 is faster on single core, but the Air 2 is still faster on multi-core. I think the 2017 iPad will only be supported as long as the Air 2 is, and that device is 3 years older.
Last edited:
Compared to the Mini 4 (dual-core A8, same as iPhone 6/6+), the iPad 2017 is a better option (even if it is a sidegrade from Air 2). Apart from performance, CPU features are also a consideration. I doubt Pro 9.7 (A9X) will last significantly longer than the 2017 iPad.
It really depends on the price point. At $250-300 for the 2017 iPad and if the Pencil isn't a big consideration, I'm more inclined to get that over the Pro 9.7 for battery life and cheaper screen replacement. Besides, one could always use the $100-200 or so saved to buy a new iPad down the line once the 2017 iPad stops performing up to par.
Go for the 2017 iPad. Has all the latest hardware and it will run next years iOS. It’s not a bad device, is cheaper, and will be supported in the long run. Otherwise get your kid a cheap Kindle fire tablet. They’re pretty good and I’ve seen Amazon sell them as low as $50 in some recent sales.
[doublepost=1510154676][/doublepost]
Outside? What is this child abuse?
/siPad mini 4 is out. She said she prefers the bigger screen now. So it’s down to iPad 2017 and iPad Pro 9.7. Not a fan of iPad 2017’s weight and added thickness since she’s coming from an iPad Air 2.
just ordered a rose gold ipad pro 9.7 32GB wifi on bhphoto for $399, no tax for outside of NY. 32GB had me worried a bit but i saw she only used up 7GB so far on her Air 2, so it should not be a problem. now she got her own rose gold ipad next to my rose gold 10.5 pro lol.
Last edited:
Get her the Pencil too down the road. She may enjoy scribbling and colouring etc.
That’s super overkill... a 5 year old kid should not be getting a 700 dollar iPad. Go with the iPad 2017, it’ll be perfect for your needs. And if something happens to it (because they are only 5 years old and 5 year olds can be rather clumsy) it’s no big deal.oh pony up dad, it’s christmas... pro 10.5. do you get him shoes from payless also?
Also I don’t like the Payless analogy, buying a 2017 iPad is not the equivalent of getting shoes from Payless, buying some Acer tablet or something would be more like it.
[doublepost=1510523927][/doublepost]
Yes the Pencil absolutely works with the 9.7 Pro.