Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Do you think they rushed into USB-C


  • Total voters
    95

Count Blah

macrumors 68040
Jan 6, 2004
3,192
2,748
US of A
If they change the ports next year, it will make the iPhone 8 (and presumably all of the 2017 iPads) incompatible with the millions of third-party products sold from 2012 that let you plug Lightning devices into them.

So basically, you're proposing to screw with the tens of millions of people who own Lighting accessories like the ones below (by suggesting that Apple make the next iPhone with a USB-C port instead of a Lightning port), because it's too much of an inconvenience for you to go out and buy a $20 USB-C to Lightning cable for your MacBook Pro/AirPods?!?
Most hotel rooms still have radios/speakers with the 30 pin adapter.

But I do see your point - With Apple, expect less.
 
  • Like
Reactions: protoxx and raqball

raqball

macrumors 68020
Sep 11, 2016
2,323
9,573
But I do see your point - With Apple, expect less.

This is becoming more and more true.. Give it a few years and you will need a dongle for the dongle that connects to a dongle.. This last in line dongle will need an adapter to connect to the MacBook..

Apple cracks me up...
 
  • Like
Reactions: protoxx

protoxx

macrumors 6502a
Oct 10, 2013
599
360
Over promise, under deliver.
Was One More Thing
Now One More ahh....Later....Nevermind
 

UnluckyXIII

macrumors 6502
Feb 20, 2014
298
66
In Apple's thinking:

iDevices: Lightning port
Macs: USB-C

But I agree Apple should be including USB-C to Lightning cables with their devices, or at least a tiny USB-A to C adapter.

To me this is the solution, migrate any and all future releases over to USB-C to Lightning cables and for the first year (or two) include a USB adaptor for anyone who requires it.

I really can't see why Apple are not keeping their product lines in parallel with one another, a company who were know (and built) on the "it just works" motto have now become "it just works... unless you bought a combination of our new 2016 devices.... then you'll need an adapter/new cable (don't worry we've got your back, we make and sell these too $£€¥), and then it just works...."

I realise it's a minor problem in the bigger picture and it's just a case of buying a different cable/adapter but we've started to see more and more of these little annoyances creeping up on us as of recent, I guess this is the bigger picture for the new Apple... the Tim Cook Apple $£€¥$£€¥
 

AdonisSMU

macrumors 604
Oct 23, 2010
7,322
3,079
I can agree with one thing.... for $150 bucks they could've included a charging block with it. People are paying a high premium and Apple is nickel and dimming consumers over a 30 cent USBC to lightening cord.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MathijsBo

shareef777

Suspended
Jul 26, 2005
2,445
3,276
Chicago, IL
I am an apple sheep, I love everything apple makes. But sometimes I need to admit that they are pretty stupid.

Apple wants to go into the future with usb-c, they knew they where doing this when the iPhone 7 came out. Why didn't they make the 7 with an usb-c port?

They didn't do that because they already removed the headphone jack. To then also change the charging port would make there customers even angrier. You could consider that smart, but I think it's stupid. Now you can't charge your phone with your Macbook, you can't use your iPhone earphones with your new MacBook. And that is just straight stupid.

What drew the line for me was the wireless AirPods. Sinds you can't use your new apple EarPods with your macbook I would say the AirPods are the solution.

But what do you get with the AirPods, an USB to Lightning charging cable. You don't get a wall outlet. So out of the box you can't charge them, unless you have a usb to wall outlet port. This makes no sense.

This seems a bit hard to understand so you might think the solutions are difficult too, but no.







My solutions:



Make the iPhone charging cable lightning to USB-c and put a USB-c to wall outlet port with that.

This way you don't make your costumers more angry, you can charge your phone with our macbook. And then they could have given the AirPods the same cable, Making you able to charge your AirPods with your Mac or iPhone wall outlet.



Give the MacBook a Lightning port, on first glance this doesn't do you any good but it works.

With the first solution costumers might get mad that there cable has two port that look the same but aren't. So instead of switching the USB end to USB-c you change it to lightning and put a lightning port on the MacBook Pro.







What is the problem?

If they change the ports next year there is no problem right? Wrong, EarPods only get upgrades ones every 2 years minimum. If they don't upgrade the AirPods next year to have USB-c then they are already out dated. So they have the upgrade the AirPods next year, but some people will have just received there first Pair of AirPods, so the upgrade is to early, or to late. They can't do that upgrade right.







What can they do now?

The only thing they can do is sell USB-C to USB cables. Or give those cables to everyone who had a pare of AirPods.

MOST people that own an iPhone don't own a Mac, let alone one of the 2016 models. And the very few (I'm one of them) that do just need to either buy a lightning to USB-C cable or a USB-C to USB-A adapter and use their existing cable. Not such a crazy proposition for someone spending well over $1k for a laptop. Pretty ludicrous to expect EVERYONE that buys the new iPhone (millions) to start looking around for a USB-C charger/cable when they leave their homes without one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aristobrat

thadoggfather

macrumors P6
Oct 1, 2007
16,144
17,056
I can agree with one thing.... for $150 bucks they could've included a charging block with it. People are paying a high premium and Apple is nickel and dimming consumers over a 30 cent USBC to lightening cord.

this picture has a lot more context when they internally announced $9.99 for 12 more levels,
They get off to this stuff, nickel and diming.
Tim-Cook-Shigeru-Miyamoto.jpeg


the guy on the right by body language is saying "Here gimme that"
 
  • Like
Reactions: MathijsBo

Jaekae

macrumors 6502a
Dec 4, 2012
712
441
Yeah, including a standard USB cable and no charger with AirPods and not being able to charge them with your flagship laptop unless you get an adapter or cable is pretty head scratching.

Most people dont have the flagship laptop. They will probably change to a usb-c charging adapter 1 year after all appe computers gone to usb-c. I the meantime those who het computers now can get a cheap cable for it. Skip 1 or 2 pizzas in a month and you can afford it
 

MathijsBo

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 8, 2016
13
4
Most hotel rooms still have radios/speakers with the 30 pin adapter.

But I do see your point - With Apple, expect less.

Yeah, but the iPhone 7 speakers are good just by themselves. So it's not like you need to blow the roof of your hotel room :p
[doublepost=1482302326][/doublepost]
I think the issue here is that Apple is expecting just a bit out of YOU.

You should get a PC and call it a day.


R
I bought the new MacBook Pro, and its amazing. Its more then I could wish for in any PC. The free software is perfect. And the whole thing looks and feels amazing. The touchbar has sped up my work flow a lot.
[doublepost=1482302410][/doublepost]
This is becoming more and more true.. Give it a few years and you will need a dongle for the dongle that connects to a dongle.. This last in line dongle will need an adapter to connect to the MacBook..

Apple cracks me up...
No, I think they will stop (for now) with USB-C, until a way better port comes along. But I think they should have planned the switch better.
[doublepost=1482302634][/doublepost]
MOST people that own an iPhone don't own a Mac, let alone one of the 2016 models. And the very few (I'm one of them) that do just need to either buy a lightning to USB-C cable or a USB-C to USB-A adapter and use their existing cable. Not such a crazy proposition for someone spending well over $1k for a laptop. Pretty ludicrous to expect EVERYONE that buys the new iPhone (millions) to start looking around for a USB-C charger/cable when they leave their homes without one.
If the iPhone 7 would have been USB-C you actually have more options to charge it. since loads of other phones and products use that too. So you would have been better off.
 

hiddenmarkov

macrumors 6502a
Mar 12, 2014
685
492
Japan
Nagging about new standards and new technologies will never end.


where is USB C standard? let me rephrase...standard in real world implementation. Besides USB-C adapters that is.

A better caveat would have been to split the 2. Have C devices, have a blast. have older usb A's...have a blast.

Wait a few years, actually see your user base actually have a stronger need in place for C and ween off the legacy.

Coming from photography as an example. When Nikon, Canon, Oly, etc have USB C cables shipping with their gear I'd call this a good move.

When 3rd party UI devices like logitec, razor, etc are shipping wired mice and kb's usb c...good time to maybe pull this trigger.

Now...no. I am all over the place hobby wise. Video, photography, audio interests as an example. XLR I use, I run mini HDMI cables out from DSLR to recorder. Old usb...tons of it. USB-C...not one cable or device in the line up. Point to that being I use a lot of standards...nothing is USB C. Nor will be for quite sometime.

Greater chance of average user plugging in legacy USB really. Vendors still pushing it out too.

Apple is leading the pack here, stroke that apple zealot pride for a second.

Issue: there is no pack to lead here. 3-4 years maybe there may be a pack there. then apple can say told you so. to which most other vendors will go yeah...but we didn't piss off our customers in the process to get here.
 

MathijsBo

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 8, 2016
13
4
If they change the ports next year, it will make the iPhone 8 (and presumably all of the 2017 iPads) incompatible with the millions of third-party products sold from 2012 that let you plug Lightning devices into them.

So basically, you're proposing to screw with the tens of millions of people who own Lighting accessories like the ones below (by suggesting that Apple make the next iPhone with a USB-C port instead of a Lightning port), because it's too much of an inconvenience for you to go out and buy a $20 USB-C to Lightning cable for your MacBook Pro/AirPods?!?


10-speaker-docks-with-Lightning-connector-for-your-iPhone-5-iPad-mini-or-4th-generation-iPad.jpg


iq5-140123.jpg


versio-lightning-usb-charger-cable-for-apple-iphone-6-plus-5-5-4-7-5-5s-5c-ipad-mini-1-2-3-ipad-4th-5th-air-3-mfi_164695.jpg


$_35.JPG



Belkin-Lightning-Charger-iPhone-6-1024x581.jpg


libratone-q-adapt-lightning-earbuds.png

It happened ones before, did you hate it then... Yes. Do you like this port now better because it is nice and small and can fit in both ways?.... Yes! This change to usb needs to happen. There are already loads of phone accessories because android phones have USB-C. The witch is hard but it is needed.
 

Rkuda

macrumors regular
May 23, 2016
249
470
Apple is all over the place right now and is becoming the dongle company...

- You can't connect an iPhone to a MacBook without a dongle
- You can't use the headphones from an iPhone with a MacBook without a dongle
- You can't charge the AirPods with your MacBook without a dongle

Dongle, dongle, dongle.... It's the new Apple I guess....

What's so hard about buying a USB-C to Lightning cable?
 

raqball

macrumors 68020
Sep 11, 2016
2,323
9,573
What's so hard about buying a USB-C to Lightning cable?

Did I say it was hard? Nope............

My response was in relation to the original post which has all but been forgotten based on the latter responses in this thread..
 

Anonymous Freak

macrumors 603
Dec 12, 2002
5,604
1,389
Cascadia
Yup.. So I need to carry 113 dongles or 113 different cables... What's the difference?

No, you'd need to carry 1 cable - USB-C to Lightning. (Or, as I prefer to call it now, "Thunderbolt to Lightning.")

Yes, in a perfect world, Apple would get rid of Lightning and use USB-C on *ALL* devices. But moving forward, you need two cables for future devices - USB-C to Lightning, and USB-C to USB-C. That covers everything moving forward.

The nice thing about USB-C is that it is truly future-proof thanks to the Alternate Mode support. Barring a return to 25-pin parallel ports or SCSI ports (or similar massively-parallel cables,) USB-C should be "the last connector" for at least 20 years.
 

raqball

macrumors 68020
Sep 11, 2016
2,323
9,573
No, you'd need to carry 1 cable - USB-C to Lightning. (Or, as I prefer to call it now, "Thunderbolt to Lightning.")

Yes, in a perfect world, Apple would get rid of Lightning and use USB-C on *ALL* devices. But moving forward, you need two cables for future devices - USB-C to Lightning, and USB-C to USB-C. That covers everything moving forward.

The nice thing about USB-C is that it is truly future-proof thanks to the Alternate Mode support. Barring a return to 25-pin parallel ports or SCSI ports (or similar massively-parallel cables,) USB-C should be "the last connector" for at least 20 years.

Again.... Point of the original post MISSED! I was not the OP and was responding to his / her thread.. Do I honestly care if I need a dongle? Nope but that's not the point nor the topic of the OP's discussion...

I give up...
 

MathijsBo

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 8, 2016
13
4
What's so hard about buying a USB-C to Lightning cable?
Nothing, but it wouldn't be hard for apple to make the charging cable lightning to USB-C.
[doublepost=1482304995][/doublepost]
Again.... Point of the original post MISSED! I was not the OP and was responding to his / her thread.. Do I honestly care if I need a dongle? Nope but that's not the point nor the topic of the OP's discussion...

I give up...
Some people just don't get it don't they.
 

laudern

macrumors 6502a
Jan 5, 2011
887
734
Lightning cables were stronger ... more flexible where the cable meets the connector (from less wires).

This made me laugh. No way are lightning cables more durable than the 30pin cable. I've had so many lightning cables fray and break around the lightening head that i now buy 30pin cables and use a 30pin to lightning adapter.
 

shareef777

Suspended
Jul 26, 2005
2,445
3,276
Chicago, IL
Yeah, but the iPhone 7 speakers are good just by themselves. So it's not like you need to blow the roof of your hotel room :p
[doublepost=1482302326][/doublepost]
I bought the new MacBook Pro, and its amazing. Its more then I could wish for in any PC. The free software is perfect. And the whole thing looks and feels amazing. The touchbar has sped up my work flow a lot.
[doublepost=1482302410][/doublepost]
No, I think they will stop (for now) with USB-C, until a way better port comes along. But I think they should have planned the switch better.
[doublepost=1482302634][/doublepost]
If the iPhone 7 would have been USB-C you actually have more options to charge it. since loads of other phones and products use that too. So you would have been better off.

WHAT!? Where do you live/work that USB-C is more ubiquitous then USB-A/Lightning. Don't get me wrong, I'm in tech so I'd of preferred USB-C as I want to be future proof and I know USB-C will be everywhere in a year. But 3mo, that'd of scared off A LOT of non-tech customers.
 

MathijsBo

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 8, 2016
13
4
WHAT!? Where do you live/work that USB-C is more ubiquitous then USB-A/Lightning. Don't get me wrong, I'm in tech so I'd of preferred USB-C as I want to be future proof and I know USB-C will be everywhere in a year. But 3mo, that'd of scared off A LOT of non-tech customers.
I don't have all usb-c products. But to get there we need to be forced there. But doing that with still having the iPhone lightning... That's not logical.
 

aristobrat

macrumors G5
Oct 14, 2005
12,292
1,403
Again.... Point of the original post MISSED! I was not the OP and was responding to his / her thread.. Do I honestly care if I need a dongle? Nope but that's not the point nor the topic of the OP's discussion...
You were literally the first person in this thread to reply using dongles to make a point.

So unless you missed the OP's point, folks asking for clarification about the point you made aren't missing anything, IMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MathijsBo

raqball

macrumors 68020
Sep 11, 2016
2,323
9,573
Part of the reason I like coming here is for the comic relief... Thanks! :)

But for what it's worth, I was not making a point I was responding with humor to the OP point..... Do they still teach reading comprehension in schools? I graduated like 30 years ago so maybe they've stopped?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.