Here is my impression as I just got mine today as well. I am not going to add pictures as I think
@Hooterville showed the same as I would.
Grip/Feel: 8/10 - I would like a little more grip on the edges - like the dbrand Grip - but it's comfortable
Buttons: 7/10 - While I am not in love with the fabric/glue keeping the button in place, there are no holes or slits. The case is going to keep it all in place and there isn't that much flex where I would need to be concerned. Mind you, I don't change cases all of the time, so this won't come off unless there is some other issue
Camera Protection: 9/10 - Anything larger or deeper is going to be an issue. While the phone will lay flat, it has a little wobble but is better than some other cases I have tried.
Fit: 9/10 - It's tight! But for my everyday case, since I am not swapping cases unless there is a real issue, this is what I want. I like the lip around the front as it has the protection I want without being too big or high.
Mag-Safe: 6/10 - This is based on my Mag-Sage charger and wallet and comparing it to my Pitaka. The Pitaka is strong, and my Gen2 Rebel case was even stronger. I expected this case to be at least as strong as the Gen2, but based on the wallet and in-home charger, the Pitaka is stronger than the Gen3 Rebel. The true test is if it holds the phone in my mobile set up. The Pitaka has never faltered.
Overall: 7/10 - Overall my first impression is it's not a bad case at all. My biggest disappointment would be the Mag-Safe strength. Time will see how the buttons flex-tape holds up and if the grip will become a bit slicker with usage. I will update after I go through Pothole Central (Massachusetts) and see how the magnets hold.