This morning I found out that I can also buy a book and not carry extra weight by using the Kindle application. So, now I have movies, tv series, songs (I have an Iphone as well), and books, in a small package that is almost the same weight of the Ipad (a pound is not a lot of difference), and if you would throw the book that I am leaving home in the equation I am carrying less weight, and I have a full featured computer to work with.
I guess your point is you are very happy about the addition of Kindle for Mac particularly for the MBA, which is already light and extremely portable?
Anyway, I think I'm one of the few people who actually answered the question you pose in the title of the thread - the addition of Kindle to my MBA really doesn't change my desire for the iPad a bit, I'm still 100% IN. Regarding the weight, of course a pound (actually 1.5 pound) is not much in the grand scheme of things if you are talking travel weight. However, from a *relative* sense the MBA weighs TWICE as much, and that is significant, particularly if you are thinking about sitting in bed or on the couch (or in the bathroom) holding it in one hand while using the other to turn the pages (using the touch screen). So while it's nice that the MBA now has the Kindle eBook capability, it's not going to offer the same reading experience - it's more of an added convenience to an already great device. Whereas on the iPad I anticipate it will simply be a great "must have" app and reading on the iPad will be much closer to reading a real book.
If I absolutely had to choose between the 2 I can't say yet, it would definitely be tough. The convenience and touch interface of the iPad vs. the full featured (and keyboard) MBA - man I'd hate to have to choose