Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I know I'll get scoffed at for this but, in a way, that 'magical' tag is justified.

The trick the iPad does, and does incredibly well, is remove a layer of abstraction (in this case keyboard and, more importantly, mouse) from what we commonly think of as a computer. It's the same trick, in many ways, that the iPhone did when compared to the traditional smartphone but it was always (and will always) be compromised by the smaller screen which add another, albeit different, layer of abstraction to proceedings (in this case the need to pan, zoom, and scan through content).

It sounds stupid but that bigger screen REALLY makes all the difference in the world. Whatever your doing is (usually) right there in front of you, no need to zoom in or move around to get to the bit you want beyond a bit of scrolling. The on-screen keyboard is a natural extension of what you're doing to navigate the device and the need to form a link between moving the chunk of plastic in your hand and the movement of an on-screen cursor is removed.

That sounds stupid and trivial to a lot of people here I know but when you see how much people struggle with that using regular PC's (windows, mac, linux, doesn't matter) you start to realise just how big of a step this could potentialy be. That adds on to the incredibly simple OS design (again, seen as a negative by many geeks but Keep It Simple is essential for this sort of device and the mass market) and the ease of finding, installing and using new software to produce something greater than the sum of its parts.

Or that could all be complete bollocks, depends on your point of view really :D

I agree with this in its entirety. It's something I didn't start to grasp until a few weeks after the iPad started selling.

When I picked one up for myself, it was even better than I had imagined it would be.

One interesting side effect of my iPad - both my Macs seem more like tools for work than they ever have. I only want to be at my desk or on my laptop if I have to be.
 
I'll say this:

The iPad is magic because until I actually borrowed one from a friend, I couldn't see the utility of it given that I already own a smartphone, two laptops and a desktop computer. Now I'm saving up for next year's iPad 1.0 instead of purchasing the Beta product currently on the market.

It's also magic because along with the iPhone, it has wiped all traces of being a computer company away from Apple. Remember the good old days when WWDC was actually a professional computing event? Neither the Mac Pro nor the XServe has been touched in over a year, and Apple is charging ridiculous prices for yesteryear's hardware in both. Forget about 10.7 as well - somehow iOS completely usurped Apple's priorities.

Steve may very well be correct that mobile devices are the future, but there's still plenty of people with uses for real Macs and OS X improvements.
 
I'll say this:

The iPad is magic because until I actually borrowed one from a friend, I couldn't see the utility of it given that I already own a smartphone, two laptops and a desktop computer. Now I'm saving up for next year's iPad 1.0 instead of purchasing the Beta product currently on the market.


iPad 1.0 ? This is the 1.0.. I can't imagine what you think is currently lacking in the iPad... A front facing camera ? Like you're going to use that so much that it's a total dealbreaker to buy the current one.. For me.. the iPad is good, it's fast and does a hell of a job for webbrowsing..
 
What I find magic is that it takes normally rational level headed people who given any other device would instantly find shortcomings and not be happy with certain aspects, and turns them into people that will bite your head off and rubbish any comment you may make against their new pride and joy.

Irrespective of any facts, in many people's eyes, the product cannot every be criticized in any way.

I've read many crazy things, right down to people saying how the weight is exactly connect, any heavier and they would not be happy (which seems pretty logical) and that it should not be made (now of in the future) any lighter also.

Everything it's not got, should not be there. everything it has got, should be there, And what you can and can not do with it is exactly right also.

I have given up even trying to work out such people, I can only assume they are under some magical spell. :D

Otherwise known as a cult.

I was reluctant to buy the iPad in the first place because the culture surrounding Apple products was so off putting. To be fair, other products are similar. It used to be Ford versus Chevy. Now it's Android versus iPHone (I have Android), or Xbox versus Playstation (I have both!). And wouldn't you know, I also have a Kindle, the device the iPad is supposedly going to kill.

The problem with Apple is that it's so long running. I think it started with a professor I had--TWENTY YEARS AGO--going on about his Mac, in a way that's all too familiar today.

In reality, the iPad is about the *only* device in which it has no peer. Which is probably why I bought one. Android answered the bell initially rang by iPhone. There are legitimate reasons one might choose Windows 7 over a Mac (though, I must admit, those new iMacs are wicked sleek). I chose a Zune 80gig over the Ipod classic a couple of years ago.

But the iPad? It really kind of stands alone. So it may not be magical. No, it's rather mundane in some ways (mostly OS related). But it is groundbreaking in other ways.

But don't call it magical. Makes me think you have an apple sticker in your Jetta.
 
magic is something to marvel at, to be amazed by, not to sit around and loose the sense of wonder by trying to explain or justify, be thrilled by your magical device and forget about what others think
 
The Ipad may be "Magical" at first glance but as a user who returned the gadget I have something to share. I am sure I belong to the rare group of people who initially fancied the device but later had second thoughts. However, I have my reasons and they are as follows:

a) The Ipad's Wifi signal reception is sub-par especially on the 5 GHz band. I have an Airport Extreme at home and I connect my 2009 Mac Mini, 2008 Macbook and a Acer netbook without any problems. The Ipad kept losing signal. When I was streaming videos using Air Video (a very impressive app), the signal would drop remarkably. I must admit I was not within line of sight of my router but the same was true for the rest of the other machines. In gist, if you have a router in the immediate vicinity, you probably should be okay.

b) As much as we prefer not to use Flash, the reality is that most of the websites are still doing so. E.g. ESPN3 and many others. Ipad of course has a serious limitation in this regard.

c) No IOS4 implementation as yet. Probably in the Fall but not as yet. Therefore, lack of multitasking.

These were some of the aspects that made me return the iPad. I admire the IPS display (although somewhat too glossy) and the rest of the aesthetic aspects. But to plonk down $600-700 for a device with limited utility (atleast as of today) did not make sense. A 13" Macbook is probably a better investment.

Cheers
 
It's magic because it doesn't burn my legs and junk when I use it on the couch or in bed (unlike my MBP which is a suitable form of male birth control).
 
It's magic because it doesn't burn my legs and junk when I use it on the couch or in bed (unlike my MBP which is a suitable form of male birth control).

Now I don't know about magical . . but that part is pretty freaking impressive. No cooling fans (that I know of, or that you can hear), and yet it has this huge display and does some fairly impressive things, both graphically and from a "normal processing" standpoint. And I've yet to detect any heat coming from it.

EVERY impressive when you compare it to a laptop.

Compare to other smart phones? Well . . I guess they do similar things.
 
Hey guys,

I truly think the iPad is magic.. if you take everything in consideration; the IPS display, fast cpu, perfect browsing experience, long battery life, how thin it is etc etc..

I saw this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-BpIc53XBM
which explains it pretty good.. But I'm having a bit trouble defending the 'magicness' to some of my friends who think the iPad is a useless gadget, far from magic.

So.. Why do you think the iPad is magic ?

What's perfect about a browsing experience that excludes Flash games and videos and that also excludes the ability to DOWNLOAD anything to a local storage?

It doesn't even support all relevant video formats (actually, NO Apple device does that out of the box).

It doesn't have a chip card reader or USB port -- if this thing was designed around a "user experience", then I would be able to simple copy MY content to the iPad.

The iPad is probably a great device to play the HD version of Plants vs. Zombies. Or to take it with me to bed for some light surfing/reading/movie watching - unfortunately without Flash and other non-Apple video formats.

With the right software installed on it (RDP, VNC and ssh/telnet clients), I can even imagine it to be of some use in the server room. Unfortunately, it lacks the USB port to connect a serial adapter so that I could hook it up to the Cisco routers and switches - without that, it can never replace a notebook in the server room.

For me, the iPad is an interesting, but expensive toy. But certainly nothing "magical". It's too restricted to be magical.
 
It's magical because Steve spent more time on the ipad than any other Apple device. He didn't release it until he knew the experience would be second to none. The results were a device that changed the way people accessed the internet, media and games. Steve had a brilliant vision and that vision is quickly becoming real, in a few years the ipad will replace most computers. People will be replacing their PC's and laptops with ipads as they become more capable. That is why the ipad is truly a magical device.
 
You know.. What I find really magical as well is that Apple pulled it off again.. They created a third type of mobile device, right there between the modern mobile phone and the laptop.. right there in the sweet spot..

Just like the iPod 'clickwheel' kind of felt magical when we used it for the first time.. we immeadiately knew that this clickwheel only made a huge diference in how we're going to browse trough our music collection.
 
What's perfect about a browsing experience that excludes Flash games and videos and that also excludes the ability to DOWNLOAD anything to a local storage?

It doesn't even support all relevant video formats (actually, NO Apple device does that out of the box).

It doesn't have a chip card reader or USB port -- if this thing was designed around a "user experience", then I would be able to simple copy MY content to the iPad.

The iPad is probably a great device to play the HD version of Plants vs. Zombies. Or to take it with me to bed for some light surfing/reading/movie watching - unfortunately without Flash and other non-Apple video formats.

With the right software installed on it (RDP, VNC and ssh/telnet clients), I can even imagine it to be of some use in the server room. Unfortunately, it lacks the USB port to connect a serial adapter so that I could hook it up to the Cisco routers and switches - without that, it can never replace a notebook in the server room.

For me, the iPad is an interesting, but expensive toy. But certainly nothing "magical". It's too restricted to be magical.

Are you kidding ? iPad supports HTML5 video perfectly.. right outta the box.. Youtube.com works excellent in the browser (if you prefer the browser over the YouTube app) and all the lage websites are showing HTML5 video instead of Flash for iPad users.. I haven't missed flash once on the iPad.. Plus.. Flash sucks your whole battery life and is unstable compared to HTML5.. The #1 reason Mac's crash is because of the Flash plugin being buggy.. And DivX/Xvid/etc is supported with an app called yxplayer..

And the iPad does support USB+SD cards with this thing: http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC531ZM/A?fnode=MTc0MjU4NjE&mco=MTc0Njk4NzU
Maybe you should do your homework before bashing a product that you haven't had yourself.. No offence.. but i'm just saying..
 
I'd rather have a large screen vs a small screen like the iPhone and the I touch.i think it's magical.
 
I think it's magical, I really do. Magical in the fact it's a game changer, not quite Harry Potter magic, but the thing is quite stunning to use.

Two main reasons: amazing battery life, and having a very capable COMPUTER in a MAGAZINE form-factor.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.