I somewhat agree with you, but I also think that when Apple sells a pro product that a degree of upgrade ability should exist. I think particularly in RAM and storage. I think thinnest and lightest form factor possible is great for their standard consumer line, but I’m wondering why the MacBook Pro can’t be the thinnest and lightest “pro” form factor in its category. Why does a pro portable need to compete with thin and light for non-pro form factors?
There is a MBP with 32GB of RAM and 4TB storage. It's just as thin and light as the base model.
It's not user upgradeable, but you can't argue with the fact that those aren't pro laptop specs for storage and memory.
I'm not saying I'm a fan of not being able to add ram or whatever.
But the argument that you can't get a true "pro" MBP because it isn't upgradeable, is not correct.
I know the question might end up being rhetorical because maybe only Apple knows why they are obsessed with this. But if Alienware announced a new gaming portable as the thinnest and lightest gaming portable but they released a portable with no fan, no dGPU, but it’s incredibly thin, it wouldn’t sell well to gamers. Likewise a thinnest pro portable with no port diversity, no robust cooling, and no Ethernet support have seemed weird to me. I have the MBP in 15” and I need the power. But I already have a variety of dongles and docking products that take up space in my carryon and don’t look slim or sleek when my MBP is wired up like a Christmas tree.
Buying Apple hardware has always been partly about design as well. Apple are absolutely obsessed with it. In all their products, even software.
I love great design and even though I mainly use Macs for their OS and ecosystem, I can't say design was never a factor in me buying a Mac.
90% of non-apple laptops are still plastic appliances...
Alienware is famous for making true gaming capable systems in the form factor of a laptop.
It's perfectly functional and those systems do what they promise.
But it's not a MBP and neither is a MBP an Alienware.
I agree, dongles are ****. From an aesthetic standpoint and from a user friendliness standpoint.
But you can hook up pretty much anything over Thunderbolt.
The 4 thunderbolt ports on my MBP offer a lot more flexibility than a laptop with a HDMI, ethernet, 2 USB ports and maybe an SD card slot.
The downside is a small dongle...
People were outraged when disc drives were omitted
People hated it when smartphones dropped SD card expansion.
Apple was stupid to drop the headphone jack.
etc.