I thought the commercial was great. We all get dropped calls and Blackberry users can have their laugh. I'll stick with better user experience and get my work email and calendar synched just like them.
As with most carriers it depends where you live. AT&T is at a disadvantage in the northeast vs verizon, but not so much elsewhere. My experience only.
But yes, I thought this was very funny and well done. Even as an iPhone user. It's my phone not my religion.