Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPod Why the hate on iTunes?
- Thread starter davidmartindale
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Apple should really remove the "Copying music to folder" option off by default. I've always found that feature incredibly annoying because it automatically makes duplicates putting it in the iTunes folder. It's a waste of space and frankly new users probably won't even know how to turn off the feature.
I don't see it as useful at all and in the days of SSD's it's just not practical. Most people will run out of storage and may have no clue what's taking up the space.
I don't see it as useful at all and in the days of SSD's it's just not practical. Most people will run out of storage and may have no clue what's taking up the space.
Explaining what iTunes does when it does copy files to its own directory might really be an advantage, I agree. Personally, though, I very much like the fact that all files are in the same directory, and nicely sorted by artists and albums.
EDIT: Typo
I used to prefer arranging my music by myself with my own folders. That gets old quick once I have a ton of music. Plus, I have a freaking computer. Why should I be the one micro managing files? iTunes copy music to folder feature is great as I keep my archival music on a different drive. Let iTunes do the dirty work. It doesn't matter from my end anyway, as everything is sorted by the ID3 tags.
So that feature IS useful. Most people won't run out of storage because most people have opted for streaming music, be it spotify, Apple music, etc. Lay people that have offline music generally won't have huge library of music. For those that do still manage a private offline library, I'm sure we know a thing or two about storage and simple file management. Just get all the original files to a separate drive.
I don't get the hate either. I manage and listen to music on iTunes. I love the album view.
Been using iTunes since maybe 2006 and have grown to detest it more and more as time passes. I don't care if the program isn't intuitive or too large, but iTunes has bugs written into it that don't get fixed, and if you go to apple support for help they ignore you. That honestly leaves me really gassed sometimes. For example, there is a bug where if you rate an album, it will rate all the songs in that album that album rating. In the current version of iTunes, the ability to rate albums has been removed altogether, however the album ratings and auto assigned song ratings are still there and unchangeable. This ruins my smart playlists that rely on star ratings. This bug has been around for over 2 years and its hard coming to terms that apple has no plans of fixing this issue.(google "iTunes grey stars" and you'll find threads from 2015 complaining about this issue, all without any official solution) It feels like apple doesn't care at all about its users who actually use some of its more advanced features. It just seems unacceptable to have known, feature breaking, faults in a program for years without any attempt and addressing them. I'm no software developer so what do I know though. I would end my apple music subscription but I don't wanna deal with switching my library over to another service
I use iTunes for listening to music, it have always worked fine. No problem with that.
Love all playlists. Love the remote control app on the device.
But I try not to use it to a lot of other things.
I do back up phone and iPad once in a while with it though.
But devices backups to iCloud on schedule.
Like to hade different kinds of backups. So iMaze backups automatically everyday.
Sometimes I have to reset or whatever in iTunes with the devices too.
Not sure it is the best app to the devices in general.
But for music, iTunes is great. It even sync the music on the devices, relatively pain free over WiFi
Love all playlists. Love the remote control app on the device.
But I try not to use it to a lot of other things.
I do back up phone and iPad once in a while with it though.
But devices backups to iCloud on schedule.
Like to hade different kinds of backups. So iMaze backups automatically everyday.
Sometimes I have to reset or whatever in iTunes with the devices too.
Not sure it is the best app to the devices in general.
But for music, iTunes is great. It even sync the music on the devices, relatively pain free over WiFi
Last edited:
I use iTunes on my Windows desktop, since my MacBook Pro has a smaller SSD and my music library is about 100GB. I only use it for my local library, and all Apple Music/iTunes Sync features are disabled.
iTunes is a bloated mess. It wasn’t always like that, but that’s what it is now. Some of my grievances with it include:
* Using the search bar is a pain in the butt, because iTunes lags by several seconds after inputting a letter. So any search that should take no more than 3 seconds ends up taking 30.
* I’ll sync my library to my iPhone and what do you know, several albums end up missing on my phone.
* I use album view. Sometimes, iTunes will split my albums into two listings for no particular reason, and I have to mess with tags, whisper compliments to my computer, and sacrifice a lamb on a full moon to get the album listed as a single entity again.
* WiFi Sync is useless.
* It’s 2018, let me add and sync FLAC files already. iTunes has the ability to encode MP3s into AAC files when syncing, do the same for FLAC files to ALAC if you so badly want me to use ALAC.
Previous versions were just fine, but I think it was around the time iTunes 12 came out that I noticed the overall decline in quality. Also, if someone has any recommendations for a music player/library manager that can sync my library to my iPhone and transcode FLAC to ALAC when syncing, that would be highly appreciated.
iTunes is a bloated mess. It wasn’t always like that, but that’s what it is now. Some of my grievances with it include:
* Using the search bar is a pain in the butt, because iTunes lags by several seconds after inputting a letter. So any search that should take no more than 3 seconds ends up taking 30.
* I’ll sync my library to my iPhone and what do you know, several albums end up missing on my phone.
* I use album view. Sometimes, iTunes will split my albums into two listings for no particular reason, and I have to mess with tags, whisper compliments to my computer, and sacrifice a lamb on a full moon to get the album listed as a single entity again.
* WiFi Sync is useless.
* It’s 2018, let me add and sync FLAC files already. iTunes has the ability to encode MP3s into AAC files when syncing, do the same for FLAC files to ALAC if you so badly want me to use ALAC.
Previous versions were just fine, but I think it was around the time iTunes 12 came out that I noticed the overall decline in quality. Also, if someone has any recommendations for a music player/library manager that can sync my library to my iPhone and transcode FLAC to ALAC when syncing, that would be highly appreciated.
While I've only ever used iTunes on OS X, I do experience this all the time. Simultaneously edit the metadata for both, remove a letter or so from the album title, and it should put them back together, leaving you to do the same thing again, but this time fixing the title. That works every time for me and while it sounds like a pita, it's at least quick and consistent.
Always has been.
If you want to know why iTunes sucks, check the user review on microsoft store: https://www.microsoft.com/en-ca/p/i...=appledotcom&rtc=1&activetab=pivot:reviewstab
If you wan to find an iTunes alternative, check this https://twitgoo.com/best-itunes-alternatives/
If you wan to find an iTunes alternative, check this https://twitgoo.com/best-itunes-alternatives/
If you're going to trash the iTunes UI, I think it's only fair that you list some competing interface and way of managing music that you consider superior. Just so we see where you're coming from...
[I used itunes for many years and finally gave up on it. I've hated it every time I've used it, but I realized that sharing my past experiences here is not going to fix anything. Since I no longer know the current product I am removing my comments.]
Last edited:
Used iTunes on the Mac, it worked well. Never fell in love with the redesign with 11.
On Windows, iTunes is frankly not great. It doesn't run well, and in my experience never really has.
It has also never adhered to Apple's user interface guidelines, so even though it runs well on the Mac it's not a good Mac citizen if you care about UI continuity.
Much like iPhoto was ruined when they rewrote it as Photos, iTunes was ruined with v.11 in my opinion.
Now that I no longer use a Mac or iPhone, I was so glad to uninstall iTunes from my PC.
On Windows, iTunes is frankly not great. It doesn't run well, and in my experience never really has.
It has also never adhered to Apple's user interface guidelines, so even though it runs well on the Mac it's not a good Mac citizen if you care about UI continuity.
Much like iPhoto was ruined when they rewrote it as Photos, iTunes was ruined with v.11 in my opinion.
Now that I no longer use a Mac or iPhone, I was so glad to uninstall iTunes from my PC.
Purchased songs from the iTunes store are exactly the same - you can play them anywhere and on any device as they are also your files and don't have copy protection. You can upload them to Google play or whatever.
Regarding the play anywhere feature, that's not what happened the last time I built up a music library on iTunes. Their account recovery feature was defective, and I lost all access to the music. Making things worse, it would not play on other devices due to DRM issues. But this was... 2013?
Since I no longer know the current product I am removing my earlier comments.
Since I no longer know the current product I am removing my earlier comments.
Last edited:
Everything after iTunes 9 is garbage IMO. iTunes 9 even wasn't that great but still usable. 8 was the last great version. Only ever used iTunes 11 on Windows, so can't speak for older versions on Windows. I cannot stand the current iTunes UI, and it's bloated with Apple music among other things. Also, minor nitpick, but the iTunes 10+ icons are stupid.
One thing I cannot figure out about iTunes 12, but I know is there, is how to make the player show how many seconds are left in the song instead of the total length, as in older versions.
One thing I cannot figure out about iTunes 12, but I know is there, is how to make the player show how many seconds are left in the song instead of the total length, as in older versions.
Just click on the number in the status bar (to the right of the progress indicator), it will cycle through the two options.
Do you need to sync with iOS devices? If so, then no there are no alternatives.
If you don't need to sync, look at MusicBee. It's a much better Windows app than iTunes in my opinion.
I know there's alternatives but iTunes still looks better than most music players on Windows.
I enjoy iTunes on Windows as well. I love the album view since I started to use iTunes 11. Never had a problem keeping my music organized or syncing my iPhone. Then again I don't use any of Apple Music or Store features. I rip my CDs and manage the local files.
It looks nothing like other Windows apps. It is subjectively a nice looking app but it's not a good Windows citizen.
itunes needs to go back to 2011(snow leopard) formatting were that version recognizes one composer maned Jean Sibelius instead of the 5 on 2015 itunes. itunes sounds horrible and flat. compared to Foobar and Quod Libet which can run in el cap and foobar in any iosx, even my ipod touch. These music platforms are far more superior and catalogue albums much better!
[doublepost=1550926643][/doublepost]
[doublepost=1550926643][/doublepost]
what alternatives for music do we use? im happy there are other better sources available!