Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Cabbit

macrumors 68020
Jan 30, 2006
2,128
1
Scotland
Where I work we had an old Performa 250, and that thing ran like a horse. It was very basic, but ran faithfully day in and day out until they finally upgraded to new machines (Windows) that we've had trouble with. I take good care of my computers, so I can't say from experience that Windows stuff fall apart faster, but I find the Windows OS does 'fall apart' (or at least begin degenerating) within the first year or so.

I think here that both sides there are well built and poorly build computers though due to the abundance of PC manufacturers all aiming to tick every box at a set price point does let down the industry as a hole.
But this is what we demand, we demand every feature possible and it to run everything fast wile being able to make our own upgrades and for it to cost as close to nothing as possible. What you get is a compromise, and this comes in many shapes and forms including: poor design or lack of any design at all, ineffective cooling, bundled software and stickers to subsidise the cost, cheep error prone memory, and often poor battery performance.

What consumers should demand is that we'll pay a little extra to get that bit extra quality, but then you get to the arguments about Mac's being expensive because people want all the boxes ticked and can't understand that costs more money.
 

yellow

Moderator emeritus
Oct 21, 2003
16,018
6
Portland, OR
Thurott makes me laugh. Windows 7 is nice and sleek, as well it should be, considering it took Microsoft 9 years and one failed major release to grind it out. I look forward to the features for Windows 8 due in 2018!
 

thejadedmonkey

macrumors G3
May 28, 2005
9,240
3,499
Pennsylvania
Where the hell does he back up his "superior and more efficient" claims?:confused:

Let me back that up. Windows 7 runs faster then any other Windows OS, it's easier to install then any other OS, and uses RAM better then any other OS.

LOL he talks about how great the super bar is and how the Dock is a "UI disaster" but just lines before was talking about future windows adding the recycle bin to the super bar. Uh, wouldnt that make it almost exactly like the Dock??

Then goes on to say the super bar isn't a complete disaster??? wtf?

Well... First, read this. It's not 100% accurate as it's dated, but it gets the point across. First of all, there's no easy way to figure out which icon you're clicking on if you have 5 word documents minimized to the dock. Windows 7 fixes this by giving you previews of each icon, so you can better tell. Plus, it's labeled. Then there's fits law, etc etc etc...

<snip>If Win7 looks anything like Vista, and from what I have seen it looks totally like it, it's fugly in my opinion. Instead of making me forget about the OS, Microsoft slams that GUI in your face like it's a big blue pie. Everything is just SO BIG. It looks like one of the accessibility modes in previous Windows versions, but that's the default! Huge icons, tons of wasted space, big ol' buttons to close and minimize windows. Ack!

First off, XP was the big blue pie. Vista was sleek and black, Windows 7 is is sleek and blue. Besides, I much prefer Windows GUI to OS X's, always did, probably always will. To each their own, simply because you don't like something is no reason to belittle it.
 

PhillStew

macrumors regular
Sep 23, 2005
108
13
Alabama
Came across this thread in a search for an unrelated topic and felt that I must comment.

I have been running a final version of Windows 7 on my brand-spanking-new Macbook Pro for at least two weeks and just from personal experiences, let me say to all of those who may be on the fence about which operating system is more stable, snappier, and less buggy in general...choose OSX. In my experiences...there is almost always a work around or trick to get something to work in OSX. DISCLAMER: This is just my two cents. Keep in mind, we are discussing a Microsoft product on a Mac forum.
 

chocolateboy

macrumors newbie
Sep 19, 2009
1
0
I must admit being quite impressed with Windows 7, it seems lightyears ahead of Vista, but still nowhere near good enough to make me want to change from OS X.
 

cjmillsnun

macrumors 68020
Aug 28, 2009
2,399
48
Stability wise, I'm very impressed with Windows 7 RC. I'm also impressed with Mac OS X Snow Leopard 10.6.1.

Other people have slated both, however I like them both. I prefer the UNIX underpinnings of OS X but as with any opinion, YMMV.
 

cjmillsnun

macrumors 68020
Aug 28, 2009
2,399
48
Seriously, I have 7 year old Apple laptops still working and in pretty good shape. I have PC's that are literally falling apart after 7 months.

To get comparable hardware that will last in a PC, you'll pay comparable dollars. That $ myth has been busted.

Agreed, my last Toshiba Laptop was £800. Funnily enough, the Santa Rosa MacBook had just come out and was a similar price. Within a year, the Toshiba was completely worn out. This MB looks like new still, despite the heavy use I give it.
 

After G

macrumors 68000
Aug 27, 2003
1,583
1
California
Agreed, my last Toshiba Laptop was £800. Funnily enough, the Santa Rosa MacBook had just come out and was a similar price. Within a year, the Toshiba was completely worn out. This MB looks like new still, despite the heavy use I give it.
I agree too - the palm rest on my 2008 non-Apple laptop looks like hell. My iBook looks pretty much like it did the day I bought it.
 

0098386

Suspended
Jan 18, 2005
21,574
2,908
No it hasn't. White Macbook - on it's second keyboard already, and THAt is actually shedding plastic.

Two PSU's on every mac laptop I've owned, they just don't last.

DL-DVI cable for UB-MB - doesn't work.

20+ Dell's, IBM's, HP's at work. No such problems. No such price-tag either.

That's a bit unlucky.
On the other hand the only machine (out of 5 personal ones, 12 in the family) that has ever crapped out was a Gericom laptop. £999 for a super beast of a machine - battery went, HDD went, bits fell off. But a month after that I bought a 12" Powerbook (this is about 5 years ago now) and there has never been a problem with it.

But that said all our PC's are home builds so we control the quality of the hardware.

Also Windows 7 sexy? Oh dear. I know a lot of people like it (personally I don't, but I adore XP still) but I don't think "sexy" is the word here. Maybe I'm just not a fan of that Aero style look.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.