Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Only problem with pro tube is that the UI is kinda ugly and the comments system is totally screwed up. You can't reply to comments and all you can see now is "shared by a user on google plus". Kinda ruins the YouTube experience when you can't see comments

Yep. I agree.
Still no ETA on fix. :(

I just noticed this tweet of ProTube that YouTube updated their API for comments which ProTube uses. They are saying the comments are now resolved.
 
  • Like
Reactions: max2
Ads have nothing to do with it. YouTube offers a subscription service called "YouTube Red" which they charge $10/month for. One of the features it offers is PiP on the iPad. So the YouTube iPad app DOES support PiP, but it is only enabled if you subscribe to YouTube Red.
Is that confirmed? Have you tried?
[doublepost=1456392028][/doublepost]
I'm not convinced by the argument that YouTube will never support PiP because of ads.

Twitch has ads and their app supports Split Screen/Slide Over and PiP.

PiP doesn't stop ads from playing.
It's not the ad, it's the YouTube red.
Like the post below you said, Google charges $10/month, and one feature of red is background playback. If YouTube supports PIP, it will be enabling background playback for everyone.
 
The main draw back is protube doesn't work with youtube's history feature. The 'history' in protube only shows what you watched in protube, not those you watched on other platforms. Without this, protube barely updates 'recommended' section.

Did you already discuss this with the developer of the app Jonas Gessner? Maybe it has to do with the fact that there isn't an API that he can use to get access to those watched history videos on other platforms?
 
Is that confirmed? Have you tried?

No, I haven't subscribed to YouTube Red. But I have the YouTube app installed on my iPad Pro, and there is a section in the app that explains YouTube Red and what features it includes, and PiP on iPad is listed there as one of the features. Another feature is no more ads when you are watching videos, and lastly there is some new YouTube Red exclusive content now being added to their catalog. It sounds like they are going to add exclusive programs kind of like how Netflix has House of Cards.
 
No, I haven't subscribed to YouTube Red. But I have the YouTube app installed on my iPad Pro, and there is a section in the app that explains YouTube Red and what features it includes, and PiP on iPad is listed there as one of the features. Another feature is no more ads when you are watching videos, and lastly there is some new YouTube Red exclusive content now being added to their catalog. It sounds like they are going to add exclusive programs kind of like how Netflix has House of Cards.

Seems like such a mean decision to lock PiP behind a pay wall.

Subscribing should only be for no ads and exclusive content and whatever else. Not blocking a pretty basic feature. :(
 
No, I haven't subscribed to YouTube Red. But I have the YouTube app installed on my iPad Pro, and there is a section in the app that explains YouTube Red and what features it includes, and PiP on iPad is listed there as one of the features. Another feature is no more ads when you are watching videos, and lastly there is some new YouTube Red exclusive content now being added to their catalog. It sounds like they are going to add exclusive programs kind of like how Netflix has House of Cards.
I don't think red will bring PIP. YouTube said red support background playback, which should be just audio playback in the background. To support PIP, the app needs to use apple official video player, which apparently YouTube is not doing.
 
I don't think red will bring PIP. YouTube said red support background playback, which should be just audio playback in the background. To support PIP, the app needs to use apple official video player, which apparently YouTube is not doing.
Why would it then be listed as a feature by YouTube as observed in the previous post?
 
Why would it then be listed as a feature by YouTube as observed in the previous post?
I think he may have made a mistake.... All I see in YouTube red feature list is 'background playback',
And this is google's definition of background playback
Play videos while using other apps or when your screen is off. Background play is available on YouTube, YouTube Music, and YouTube Gaming mobile apps.

Notice that it says when screen is off.
 
No, I haven't subscribed to YouTube Red. But I have the YouTube app installed on my iPad Pro, and there is a section in the app that explains YouTube Red and what features it includes, and PiP on iPad is listed there as one of the features. Another feature is no more ads when you are watching videos, and lastly there is some new YouTube Red exclusive content now being added to their catalog. It sounds like they are going to add exclusive programs kind of like how Netflix has House of Cards.
Any link to that information that you might have come across, or perhaps a screenshot that you can share?
 
Any link to that information that you might have come across, or perhaps a screenshot that you can share?

I think he made a mistake. I also can't find anywhere that PiP is supported in the official YouTube (red) app when you have subscription. All features are mentioned on this YouTube support page and PiP is not one of them. Only background audio is supported but that is something else as garyleecn also described already.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.