My Thursday morning AT&T order arrived about two hours ago. I haven't used them yet, but they look perfect — none of the separation that others have complained about. The button on the back of the case is so small and unobtrusive that I had to look for it (and I bet more than a few people don't realize it's there at all).
For a guy, the case seems awesome. Instead of having earbuds tangled up in a front pocket, the case seems small enough to easily have in a front pocket for easy AirPods storage and charging.