I got my AirPods a little over a week ago thanks to refreshing istocknow at the right time. I wanted them because I like toys. I also consistently had issues with my other wireless headphones (inexpensive MPOW Swift) not connecting smoothly. The first 4 minutes at the gym would be spent unpairing and pairing until Spotify recognized them. Obviously I haven't had the AirPods long, but there have been no pairing issues whatsoever. It was practically daily with my others.
I know that I should be used to wireless by now. I've used clunky over-ear Beats, and even the wire on the MPOW pair was not connected to my actual device, but the AirPods somehow feel different. I realize it's ridiculous, but I feel like I'm using a cordless phone for the first time. Like I can put them in and walk anywhere, and they will still be with me and working. I realize that it's semi-sad.
My biggest concern was that one would fall out while running. I'm glad to say they don't even seem like that's an option, but I did absentmindedly scratch near my ear today at the gym, and then I freaked out. I was so afraid that I could have knocked the AirPod out and then treadmillized it to smithereens.
TL;DR: Totally love mine more than I expected, but still afraid one will fall out and be brutally stepped on.