Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AirPods Pro 2nd gen worthy upgrade from 1st gen?
- Thread starter nas2344
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The ANC is also better and you can change the volume on the stems. I haven’t tested the mic quality with anyone yet. And has Find My, battery appears on phone, case make sound when using Find My as well.
If I had to give an answer now, I'd say if your APP Original are still working satisfactorily (no crackling, batteries are okay, ANC hasn't faded beyond what was caused by firmware updates, etc) then it's probably not worth upgrading until a problem occurs.
So far I'm a little underwhelmed, but I haven't used them for very long. I took one call and then spent a few minutes playing with ANC & Transparency Mode. The ANC is noticeably better, but it's a slight improvement, not a huge difference. The tips do seem to fit more securely in my ears, but that could just be because they're fresh out of the package. Transparency Mode is definitely improved and sounds significantly more natural than the original APP.
That said, the increased battery life and swipe volume control will be very nice. I've used the volume control on them and it's quite useful. I'll update this if my opinion changes once I've had more time with them.
So far I'm a little underwhelmed, but I haven't used them for very long. I took one call and then spent a few minutes playing with ANC & Transparency Mode. The ANC is noticeably better, but it's a slight improvement, not a huge difference. The tips do seem to fit more securely in my ears, but that could just be because they're fresh out of the package. Transparency Mode is definitely improved and sounds significantly more natural than the original APP.
That said, the increased battery life and swipe volume control will be very nice. I've used the volume control on them and it's quite useful. I'll update this if my opinion changes once I've had more time with them.
Solid upgrade. Life changing? No. But for all the things we've learned to live with on the gen1, gen2 has addressed them quite well. Sound quality and ANC improvements are immediately noticeable, and not small changes.
I think so. So far, better ANC, better fit, better overall sound quality, and battery.
I reacted to the news of the AirPods Pro 2 with a tremendous "meh" because I was hoping for lossless support along with improved microphone performance. When I saw that they supported Bluetooth 5.3, I decided to jump, because I'm only getting about 2 hours/charge from my OG Pros. They arrived today, and while I'm going to need to live with these (and take them on the NYC subway, which is always the best test of ANC) before I'll have a fully formed opinion, I will say that right out of the box the sound quality on these is a marked improvement. The bass presence isn't just upped, but it has a warmth to it that I wasn't expecting. I'm not sure what double the noise cancellation is supposed to sound like in practice, but for around-the-home sounds, the isolation is decent, but about the same as my old Pros. Transparency is much improved; without changing any settings, I don't feel like my ears are getting blasted with amplification when I turn off ANC, which is something I often felt with the OGs. The ability to turn volume up and down with a swipe is a welcome addition, but I'll have to see how that is when I'm listening to music while lying on a pillow, which seems like something that could be problematic. I'll report later on battery life and other aspects (including the mic), but my initial impression is that the sound quality (particularly the midrange and the bass) across various genres of music is noticeably better, ANC seems about the same, and transparency sounds more natural. Does that make it worth the $250 price tag? I guess it does for me, but I have a feeling some people are going to be underwhelmed.
Currently I would say no as I had first gen AirPods since launch day and had no issues with noise cancelling and passing the NC test but no matter what I’ve tried with the gen 2’s, I cannot get a successful NC test with the right pod so I’m certainly not getting the same noise cancelling that I had with the gen ones.
I may have a faulty set of AirPods and they are being replaced and hopefully then I’ll be able to give a better perspective.
I may have a faulty set of AirPods and they are being replaced and hopefully then I’ll be able to give a better perspective.
I purchased the APP2 today and really tried to compare them to my APP 1st gen. I replayed multiple movie scenes and would switch and would listen to music and test it next to an AC for noise cancellation. To be frank, like someone else said, if you're 1st gen are working fine, keep them and don't worry much. Yeah, the noise function on the small stem is nice, but again, it is a very small stem. The ANC works slightly better and, while not exhaustive, I tested it around the house and neighborhood and didn't really notice a big difference. The sound quality as well. My 0.02 cents
I agree. Solid upgrade.
Improved ANC.
I assume I’ll like the longer battery life.
FindMy actually works. I assume I will no longer get the useless ”left behind” notices from the first gen.
The microphone noise suppression improvements alone are worth it.
Improved ANC.
I assume I’ll like the longer battery life.
FindMy actually works. I assume I will no longer get the useless ”left behind” notices from the first gen.
The microphone noise suppression improvements alone are worth it.
This is how I feel about mine. Solid upgrade and well worth it. Passed my old pros down to my daughter.
Tim
Just picked up my APP gen 2…1 hour ago from Apple.
APP Gen 1 to the left APP Gen 2 to the right. I’ve own gen 1 for 2 years now. I wasn’t planning on upgrading but considering I had a $150 gift card for my MBAM2 back during launch why not. These do sound better. Not a day and night difference but a little better. I like the new features we getting with these. With kids I like the idea of the case now having its own speakers. Easier to find. I use my iPhone and AirPods everyday. During my work day with my iPhone and at home connected to my Samsung TV (less noise for the wife) LoL. I plan to gift the gen 1’s to my 12 year old son BTW. These new ones feel more comfortable too. Better seal.
APP Gen 1 to the left APP Gen 2 to the right. I’ve own gen 1 for 2 years now. I wasn’t planning on upgrading but considering I had a $150 gift card for my MBAM2 back during launch why not. These do sound better. Not a day and night difference but a little better. I like the new features we getting with these. With kids I like the idea of the case now having its own speakers. Easier to find. I use my iPhone and AirPods everyday. During my work day with my iPhone and at home connected to my Samsung TV (less noise for the wife) LoL. I plan to gift the gen 1’s to my 12 year old son BTW. These new ones feel more comfortable too. Better seal.
Last edited:
Just tried out the ANC at a busy festival near a major interstate. I normally wouldn’t do this because I wasn’t listening to anything, but I had a migraine and noise really makes them worse. Worked great!
I often wear my APPs on airplanes with ANC on while not listening to anything just for the noise reduction.
I just got my AirPods Pro 2nd gen. Had the originals since 2019. First off, the thing I noticed immediately was the fit, these actually stay in my ears! The APP 1st always felt like they would fall out my ears no matter which tip I used. The sound although not immediately apparent but there’s definitely more bass and it sounds louder with than the 1st gen. With the 1st gen I feel like I had to almost turn up the volume 80% of the time to hear the bass.
Overall a small improvement but the fit alone makes it worth it for me.
Overall a small improvement but the fit alone makes it worth it for me.
Have noticed better bass too. Also like the smaller details like when you put case to charge on the MagSafe the sounds it makes. Those little details I like to have. Speaker being on the case is a good upgrade.
Have not heard it yet as my old AirPods case from my gen 1 blocks the speaker. 😉
Tim
Launch day AirPods Pro 1 user here - after three years of heavy daily use, I was ready for an upgrade. I have a pair of WF-1000XM4s for their bass, but I've always found the AirPods Pro to have better ANC. Most review state otherwise, but in my experience the AirPods Pros have better ANC, and the gen 2 Pros are even better. The low end is fuller; still a little roll-off once you get into the 50Hz range (I have a bass test playlist full of songs with powerful sub-bass beats or accents, in that range) but still, markedly improved over the gen 1s. Even non-bass-heavy stuff like Tool has a lot more impact in the bass region. Love it!
Dude - stand behind the yellow line lol... if the ANC really is better you'll never hear the crazies coming up behind you to push you on the tracks...
From someone else who spends lots of time on the subway there 🤘