Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mine had a flickering pixel - which pixel fix took care of. A very slight , as in very, very, very slight yellowing in the midddle of the screen - which a calibration tok care of. Very slight backlight bleed at the lower corners - only noticeable with an all black screen.

So I cannot say it was perfect - but gosh darn near and beautiful!!!
 
Mine had a flickering pixel - which pixel fix took care of. A very slight , as in very, very, very slight yellowing in the midddle of the screen - which a calibration tok care of. Very slight backlight bleed at the lower corners - only noticeable with an all black screen.

So I cannot say it was perfect - but gosh darn near and beautiful!!!

Yup, mine is perfect, save for one stuck pixel. If it can't be woken up by jspixel of pixel fix, I've got Applecare so I can start whining at my leisure later, but the rest of this unit is so good, I'm not about to give it up just for 1 red pixel.

Where do I find pixel fix? - Edit, It's a dashboard widget, so every time you walk away from your mac, middle click and it works the magic while you're off.
 
I've had three iMacs with bad screens so far. All of them with the yellow tint, one with a stuck pixel and one with unacceptable backlight bleeding.
I don't consider a stuck pixel a major issue though, especially not when it's not in the middle of the screen. And I think there's some slight backlight bleed on all of these, which is perfectly normal. Some have unacceptable levels though.
 
I sold my 20" Core Duo and bought the new 24" aluminum and let me add my name to the ever growing list of satisfied customers: No dead pixels, no yellowing, excellent viewing angle and I even love the glossy screen. This is the best display I've ever owned.
 
After reading around here, I was terrified -- I found no stuck pixels, anything. Glossy screen is fine -- just very reflective when the screen shows black (in a movie or something) Otherwise, great.
 
I'm looking to buy my first Apple computer but I'm worried about these recent reports of back lighting problems/yellow tint/uneven colors on the 24" model. I don't mind a slight backlight bleed, since these are LCDs, but I don't want to experiance anything more then that. How are your 24" screens?

One thing you must remember is that different people have different demands.

If you are a normal user (not perfectionist) and use your computer for e-mail, games and some websurfing you will most likely think that the iMac has a fabulous screen.

If you are a pro user, you should look at a Mac Pro with Cinema display or maybe the previous iMac series (white). I have now seen 15 alu iMacs (3 from different batches have been on my desk and then sent back), all with the same "problem". I now believe that all alu iMacs are like this and that most people don't see it (I had a hard time to get a sales man to see it although I thought it was very obvious!). Go to the store and have a look at one - if you don't see any gradient on the screen you are safe to buy one because then it will not bother you.

Dead pixels, backlight bleed/uneven backlight is issues all iMacs (and many other LCD screens) have, more or less. The blue-to-yellow gradient however is unique for the 24" alu iMac and this bothers me. It is a step down in quality comparing to older models.

Depending on how critical your eyes are and what kind of work you do, you should read the remarks about the iMac-screen from the right perspective. For me as a photographer, it is not good enough, so I now use an Apple Cinema Display with a Macbook Pro. For most people out there, the screen rocks. And the computer is indeed very slick and a joy to use. In short - you must check it out for yourself. If you really want to see the problem, set the background to a solid gray color and compare left to right.

/ Jacob
 
The blue-to-yellow gradient however is unique for the 24" alu iMac and this bothers me.

If you really want to see the problem, set the background to a solid gray color and compare left to right.

/ Jacob

I am afraid you are right, I can see it on mine and I am not a photographer. It's not enough for me to change it but it would have been nice if it was not there. What causes that on an LCD display?
 

Attachments

  • DSC01194_2.png
    DSC01194_2.png
    493.6 KB · Views: 159
Mine's fine. There's slight backlight unevenness right in the corners (only really noticable when the screen is black), but other than that, if there's any yellowing it's so slight I can't actually see it (after much experimenting, I think it MIGHT be slightly more yellow in the middle, but I'm not actually sure!).

Mine is the same way, far from noticable under normal use though, only notice it really when I'm loading a game or something and the screen goes all black. My 17" Samsung LCD was the same way.

I'm pretty sure there isn't any yellow either, just the backlight unevenness in the lower corners.

Other than that this screen is beautiful.

Gorgeous. Huge, but not as huge as when I first bought it somehow!

Same way for me haha. When i first opened the box and put it on my desk I was like ARE YOU KIDDING ME hahaha.

While it still seems big it doesn't have that feeling anymore.
 
Mine's fine. There's slight backlight unevenness right in the corners (only really noticable when the screen is black), but other than that, if there's any yellowing it's so slight I can't actually see it (after much experimenting, I think it MIGHT be slightly more yellow in the middle, but I'm not actually sure!).
What's "fine" for some, might be considered totally unacceptable by others. For example:

"I used a mid-grey background, it looked fine, opened the pic in aperture, and it looks terrible."

https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=4249652#post4249652


Would some of the folks reporting "perfect" 24" displays please post screen photos? I'm trying to determine whether there's any possibility of exchanging my iMac for one with a display that's "fine" by me.

Suggest: "Solid Gray Medium" and/or "Solid Aqua Blue" background, and brightness set to minimum (F1 & F2 keys) -- with "Shades" or similar apps (if installed) disabled. Here's what my 24" looks like under those conditions:

https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/4251236/


...thanks in advance,

LK
 
What's "fine" for some, might be considered totally unacceptable by others. For example:

https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=4249652#post4249652

Would some of the folks reporting "perfect" 24" displays please post screen photos? I'm trying to determine whether there's any possibility of exchanging my iMac for one with a display that's "fine" by me.

Suggest: "Solid Gray Medium" and/or "Solid Aqua Blue" background, and brightness set to minimum (F1 & F2 keys) -- with "Shades" or similar apps (if installed) disabled. Here's what my 24" looks like under those conditions:

https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=4249652#post4251236


...thanks in advance,

LK

I would post a picture but my DSLR is in it's bag in my closet and this is a Sunday, a day for relaxation before going back to work on Monday.

As a photograher, I am highly pleased with my 24". if anyone else has a problem with it they shouldn't have bought an iMac, there is no where on it that Apple it says PROFESSIONAL CAD/PHOTO GRADE LCD, if you have a problem with it sell the iMac, buy a Mac Pro and a $1400 Eizo Flexscan S2411W pro panel.. Otherwise live with it I say. I'm loving mine, no blue or yellow or whatever, just a little backlight bleeding in the lower corners, not even noticeable.

Now on the other hand, the small percentage of people that I guess have a problem with it, I think should return it, but I don't think the percentage is very high. Everything can have problems.

I'm sorry for sounding rude but it's just facts.
 
there is no where on it that Apple it says PROFESSIONAL CAD/PHOTO GRADE LCD
I checked the box, and it also does not say: "Luminance uniformity two to three times worse than minimum acceptable requirements of basic ergonomic standards (TCO'99, TCO'03) -- and five to ten times worse than the typical performance of garden-variety, mass-market LCD monitors."

OTOH, here's what Apple DOES say -- specifically regarding the new 24" iMacs (MA876, MA877):

8.0 Ergonomics

Visual ergonomics is an important concern to computer users.
It affects user comfort and performance. Apple designs, tests
and certifies our displays to meet stringent visual ergonomics
(front of screen) criteria.


http://images.apple.com/environment/resources/pdf/APES_20-in_iMac_8-07-07.pdf


...and thanks for the helpful feedback,

LK
 
check it

I have a 24" aluminum and this is my take.

I read these forums and got freaked out. I picked up a 24" at the apple store in new hampshire and overall the display is beautiful....BUT it is definitely affected by backlighting issues. On a good day there is a light dimming on the left and right edges. On a bad day there is a slight yellowing vertical tint along those corners that shows up on web pages and whites. I considered returning but this seems to be the general construction. Looking at photos and mixed colors the screen is amazing however. It honestly varies from day to day and some people just do not notice this, but if you notice details (I'm a pharmacist) you will surely see that all the 24" imacs do NOT have a uniform screen (check your local apple store in the flesh). Still, it's a great machine and suits me 1000% better than a mac pro. It's sad but still ok with me.

But if you want to feel better about your purchase just take a peak at the awesome looking old white imac screens (there's two at my job) and they have a shiny pixely look to their displays and i think wash pictures out horribly. Prediction-->the 24" display has fluorescent display problems but will be addressed in the next refresh in january or next summer. Until then the new 24" monitor is still AMAZING in a lot of situations... My desktop is this exploding fire nebula and it just sucks you in!:)
 
I have a 24" aluminum and this is my take.

I read these forums and got freaked out. I picked up a 24" at the apple store in new hampshire and overall the display is beautiful....BUT it is definitely affected by backlighting issues. On a good day there is a light dimming on the left and right edges. On a bad day there is a slight yellowing vertical tint along those corners that shows up on web pages and whites. I considered returning but this seems to be the general construction. Looking at photos and mixed colors the screen is amazing however. It honestly varies from day to day and some people just do not notice this, but if you notice details (I'm a pharmacist) you will surely see that all the 24" imacs do NOT have a uniform screen (check your local apple store in the flesh). Still, it's a great machine and suits me 1000% better than a mac pro. It's sad but still ok with me.

But if you want to feel better about your purchase just take a peak at the awesome looking old white imac screens (there's two at my job) and they have a shiny pixely look to their displays and i think wash pictures out horribly. Prediction-->the 24" display has fluorescent display problems but will be addressed in the next refresh in january or next summer. Until then the new 24" monitor is still AMAZING in a lot of situations... My desktop is this exploding fire nebula and it just sucks you in!:)

I share the same opinion, and I am a pharmacist too BTW ;)
 
One thing you must remember is that different people have different demands.

If you are a normal user (not perfectionist) and use your computer for e-mail, games and some websurfing you will most likely think that the iMac has a fabulous screen.

If you are a pro user, you should look at a Mac Pro with Cinema display or maybe the previous iMac series (white). I have now seen 15 alu iMacs (3 from different batches have been on my desk and then sent back), all with the same "problem". I now believe that all alu iMacs are like this and that most people don't see it (I had a hard time to get a sales man to see it although I thought it was very obvious!). Go to the store and have a look at one - if you don't see any gradient on the screen you are safe to buy one because then it will not bother you.

Dead pixels, backlight bleed/uneven backlight is issues all iMacs (and many other LCD screens) have, more or less. The blue-to-yellow gradient however is unique for the 24" alu iMac and this bothers me. It is a step down in quality comparing to older models.

Depending on how critical your eyes are and what kind of work you do, you should read the remarks about the iMac-screen from the right perspective. For me as a photographer, it is not good enough, so I now use an Apple Cinema Display with a Macbook Pro. For most people out there, the screen rocks. And the computer is indeed very slick and a joy to use. In short - you must check it out for yourself. If you really want to see the problem, set the background to a solid gray color and compare left to right.

/ Jacob

This is so very true. It's totally about your use and perspective-> you will see numerous people who bought these at different stores and returned them multiple times and either gave up or settled. There are also people who think this display is amazing. The variability in machines seems less than the variability in people using the machine and their needs.

@ imacan-> Wa ha! That's interesting that we both do the same type of work and have similar findings:)
 
I thought the title of this thread is who has an iMac with a good screen? Why is everyone with a bad screen posting?
:confused:
 
dito

I thought the title of this thread is who has an iMac with a good screen? Why is everyone with a bad screen posting?
:confused:

Good question... there are sufficient threads with the issues postings.

I did the gray and blue solid color test and I am still very, very happy with my iMac. 100% of the time I generally do not have a solid color taking up the entire screen.

Count me very, very happy. :apple: :D
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.