My only complaint is no back protection... I slip the entire thing into my incase sleeve when its in the backpack.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Any reviews on the new "Smart covers"?
- Thread starter Clint1583
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You should always have 2 cases for your ipad. I have a protective thin case (or smartcover for my new ipad) that rests within a case logic, padded, zip case since I'm running around in grad school and rotations at the VA. I can upload pics but basically I've found a way that protects the ipad from dropping even a few feet onto the ground.
I got the tan leather one and I do like it. I ordered a BestSkinsEver for the back. The cover opening is cool but when I leave iBooks open, I manage to open the cover and turn pages on the screen with the instant unlock feature. Might need to get used to it or just disable it.
Question.
Has anyone experienced scratching were the hinge joins to the iPad? I need to know this before i buy one
Has anyone experienced scratching were the hinge joins to the iPad? I need to know this before i buy one
I haven't had any scratching from the hinges. I like mine. I like the fact that it turns the iPad on when it's opened and doesn't add weight or bulk to the iPad. I've already ordered a gelaskin for the back. I bought mine in red leather and love it.
Every image I have seen of the stand shows the the polyurethane or leather on the outside of the stand. Wouldn't you just try to wrap it the opposite way if the microfiber ended up on the outside?
I thought Apple people were supposed to be smarter than everyone else.
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_0 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/532.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0.5 Mobile/8A293 Safari/6531.22.7)
Obviously I've only had the cover for a few hours (and haven't been able to use my actual iPad2 bc I learned the hard way that I need to upgrade to Snow Leopard and iTunes10 from Tiger, d'oh!)... but I'm honestly in love with my lime-green smartcover! I'm a huge fan of naked products and this is about as non-bulky as one will get for screen protection. The fact it works as a stand too is great, and the magnetic hinge really does "just know where to go". I understand the case offers no back protection, but I don't plan on dropping the iPad2 since it's not a phone and I've never once dropped my MacBook. As far as protection for the back from scratches, I'll probably get an InvisibleShield. So, in short, after a few hours, I'm loving this smartcover! Depending on your needs/concerns, YMMV.
Obviously I've only had the cover for a few hours (and haven't been able to use my actual iPad2 bc I learned the hard way that I need to upgrade to Snow Leopard and iTunes10 from Tiger, d'oh!)... but I'm honestly in love with my lime-green smartcover! I'm a huge fan of naked products and this is about as non-bulky as one will get for screen protection. The fact it works as a stand too is great, and the magnetic hinge really does "just know where to go". I understand the case offers no back protection, but I don't plan on dropping the iPad2 since it's not a phone and I've never once dropped my MacBook. As far as protection for the back from scratches, I'll probably get an InvisibleShield. So, in short, after a few hours, I'm loving this smartcover! Depending on your needs/concerns, YMMV.
Question - when you open the Smart Cover does it swing back, and cover the back side of the iPad (offering protection when using?) - if so - does it connect on the back and stick with magnets on the back to protect it?
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_0 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/532.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0.5 Mobile/8A293 Safari/6531.22.7)
It will swing back to protect the back, but magnets don't hold it back, you have to hold the iPad with two hands if you want the full back covered while holding. However, it does this cool "half-fold" thing that I feel is more comfortable to hold -- so it covers half of the back, and feels like a more organic grip in portrait mode.
9OOYO said:
It will swing back to protect the back, but magnets don't hold it back, you have to hold the iPad with two hands if you want the full back covered while holding. However, it does this cool "half-fold" thing that I feel is more comfortable to hold -- so it covers half of the back, and feels like a more organic grip in portrait mode.
Really? Thank you for pointing that out then! When I went into the store a few days ago to get an Incase MBA 11" sleeve to put my iPad 2 in while waiting for better cases, the guy said 30 days (but that's a MBA product). I'll have to check back this weekend to see. Thank you again!
Sort of...
The way the hinge is made there's quite a bit of variation in where the cover sits against the back of the device. In some positions the magnets don't have good contact and that first section of the cover just flops down. In other positions it does a fair job but even at its best the magnetism isn't great.
Overall I like it(went with black leather), but I was accepting of the fact that it was only front protection and I'll probably use a film on the back. I'll also probably have a second, more hardened case for use on trips.
In agree. I just ordered a back only screen protector from Zagg. I had one on my gen 1 iPad, and itnworks great. I never have to worry about just setting it down anywhere. I'm super anal about scratches and it keeps it pristine.
That smell will go away, thats how things made out of poly smell when first opened.
I'm not obsessed with keeping the back scratch free, so the smart cover is fine for me. I really like it, in fact.
Love my leather smart cover but it's going to have to go back today...to be exchanged for another color. I got the tan and I just know that in a couple weeks it's gonna get dirty. I think I'm going to exchange it for a navy or black one.
What do you mean an honest review? Spend 5 minutes on here and you'll find 30 people who are with you. It does what it advertises. If you dont want it than don't get it. If you got it and don't like it than don't complain, because obviously you weren't paying attention to what it actually does.
does it look like it covers the back? No? then it probably doesn't cover the back.
I have been very pleasantly surprised at the quality of the poly cover. For some reason I had it in my head that it was going to have a very fabric-like feel, but it is actually a lot like suede. Other than color preferences, I see no reason why I'd spend $70 for the leather version. Just my 2 cents.
how does the poly cover compare to the original apple ipad case (front).. is it the same material/feel/strength?
Agreed. I was just going to post the same point when I saw your comment.
It's sufficient on it's own or it's not. End of.
The only smell I notice is if I hold right up to my nose. Even then it is not that strong. Not something I would have noticed if I hadn't seen it mentioned. I think it is a YMMV thing.
I'm still in the 'if I close the refrigerator door, will the light still be on' phase with the cover.
I'm still in the 'if I close the refrigerator door, will the light still be on' phase with the cover.
I bought the red one and i dont like it... here is why:
1- my kids take off when they use it and drop the cover on the floor (ipad will be next) need better protection. is there a sticker i can buy for the back of it to protect the aluminum? if so that would help
2- The red one has scratches in the leather already and the aluminum on the back has a scratch from not being protected.
3- i fold it the wrong way for the stand feature half the time and it doesnt sit right. but not sure what other cases or option to buy so i will keep it most likely.
just my 2 cents
1- my kids take off when they use it and drop the cover on the floor (ipad will be next) need better protection. is there a sticker i can buy for the back of it to protect the aluminum? if so that would help
2- The red one has scratches in the leather already and the aluminum on the back has a scratch from not being protected.
3- i fold it the wrong way for the stand feature half the time and it doesnt sit right. but not sure what other cases or option to buy so i will keep it most likely.
just my 2 cents
Sorry, but I still feel the smart cover is like a "look what we can make isn't it cool" designer item, rather than an actual practical in REAL use item.
I can see someone grabbing the smart-cover without full having hold of the iPad, the iPad then slips, the magnets are not strong enough and you are left holding the smart cover and the iPad is on the floor.
By all means, Apple, make this, but also make a version of your original case also.
Hopefully, Someone CAN copy the original Apple design for a iPad2 case, if Apple has not make one then they can't say someone else has copied it, can they?
I can see someone grabbing the smart-cover without full having hold of the iPad, the iPad then slips, the magnets are not strong enough and you are left holding the smart cover and the iPad is on the floor.
By all means, Apple, make this, but also make a version of your original case also.
Hopefully, Someone CAN copy the original Apple design for a iPad2 case, if Apple has not make one then they can't say someone else has copied it, can they?