Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Anyone else prefer the standard AirPods?
- Thread starter chillip
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
HELL NO! Always hated the shallow sound and insecure fit of standard AirPods. With the Pros I get a nice, secure fit, amazing noise-cancelling, and HUGELY improved sound quality -- with all the richness and warmth missing from the originals.
I had the same experience and the left ear never created a perfect seal. I ended up returning mine for a refund today and noticed the same thing in the sound department when comparing the Pro’s to the 2nd gen AirPods.
Yep, well said. The Airpods Pro feel kinda complex compared to v1/2. I guess that makes the them Pro, ha. I'm sure over time you'd get used to some of the new ways of using them but I really don't like them in the first few days. I also have issues with the comfort/fit so I'm about 90% sure I'll be returning them. The only thing I really love about them is the look. I would love v3 of the Airpods to come with a shorter stem and the same battery life. I'm would be ok if they add the squeeze controls if they would keep around the double taps. It would be nice to have the choice, but I'm sure they are limited by space and sensors in those little things.
The "Pro" name is confusing because it sounds like they're better. I think these are different products. Not everyone needs noise cancellation. I can definitely see some people preferring the more simple design of the AirPods. I wouldn't sleep with the Pros in my ears but I have no hesitation doing that with the regular AirPods.
That is very frustrating. To your point, for many of us, that is literally the number one selling point of AirPods
[automerge]1572810570[/automerge]
I agree. I think Pro was the wrong moniker here.
I think they should’ve been called AirPods NC
[automerge]1572810627[/automerge]
I kind of wish they even made an even lower end AirPod model that has no touch or squeeze controls (maybe no Mic either) and it’s literally just wireless headphones to get the entry price down
I’m sadly returning mine, the fit just isn’t perfect enough for me. Plus I miss the tapping function. The gen 1’s fitted me perfectly.
I also find the silicon tips tap the inside of my ear when running and it didn’t go away with bigger buds.
Close but no cigar
I also find the silicon tips tap the inside of my ear when running and it didn’t go away with bigger buds.
Close but no cigar
I’m feeling a bit worried after reading this thread. I love my OG AirPods and my new AirPods Pro arrive tomorrow since I ordered them with engraving (my first name and mobile number). So with the engraving, I am not going to have the chance to return them if I don’t like them as much as my OG AirPods. Fingers crossed.
I passed on engraving because of that and I am glad I did - definitely returning.
I prefer the OG style and will stick with that. If I want NC I will keep my Bose QC’s or upgrade to another over ear at some point.
To be fair - the AirPod pros are very nice, I just don’t like the silicon tips, sound of phone calls, and hearing my footsteps when I walk because of the in ear seal.
Outside of that the overall style/ quality, battery life, and sound are all winners.
So they do still do that?
(not surprised - expected actually - was more surprised to see people claiming that NC "eliminates it", which is hard to believe)
Totally agree Dan. I expected much better sound tbh.
Returned the pros. The airpods 2 do the trick and at half the price. Kinda a nobrainer
I’m still good with my standard Air Pods. Only time I need noise cancellation is when flying and I have older Studio Beats for that. Which I’ll probably upgrade sooner than later.
The Air Pods aren’t a device I need to upgrade right now so I’ll stick with the standards till they become useless.
The Air Pods aren’t a device I need to upgrade right now so I’ll stick with the standards till they become useless.
Last edited:
Returning mine. AirPods Pros are nice but the design is not working for me.
1. they are short and fat. Looks like i have cotton ball sticking out of my ear.
2. white tips will fall of at some point, will get dirty from oils and sweat.
3. transparency mode is making a noticeable white noise buzzing
4. NC is nice but it takes a while to switch off so i can hear a person who is talking to me. might as well take them out.
5. not as simple. 1/2 are put in your ears and go. this one i have to decide which mode to use.
6. touch is much better than squeeze.
7. hard to take out of the case.
8. takes longer to put it in the ear for a good fit.
9. pressure build up in the ear, gets tiring after a while
my few cents
1. they are short and fat. Looks like i have cotton ball sticking out of my ear.
2. white tips will fall of at some point, will get dirty from oils and sweat.
3. transparency mode is making a noticeable white noise buzzing
4. NC is nice but it takes a while to switch off so i can hear a person who is talking to me. might as well take them out.
5. not as simple. 1/2 are put in your ears and go. this one i have to decide which mode to use.
6. touch is much better than squeeze.
7. hard to take out of the case.
8. takes longer to put it in the ear for a good fit.
9. pressure build up in the ear, gets tiring after a while
my few cents
I got my AirPods Pro today and I am impressed. The sound quality is better and they fit much better in my ear. Sound isolation is also great to have and I will be using it in many occasions. I understand though what you are saying. The standard AirPods have a simplicity which is really unbeatable. The pro is for people that want a bit more.
If I’d bought from Apple I might be tempted to return. But I bought from a reseller and they have a no returns policy on worn headphones so it seems I’m going to learn to live with them
they’ve already fallen out twice while walking when the standard ones never did. it’s like it’s being pushed out of my ear. Might need a bigger tip but it already feels noticeable so I didn’t want to increase that. The originals often felt like I wasn’t wearing them
the noise cancelling doesn’t seem to block talking at all - on the train I can easily hear people and the train announcements. But it does seem to let me listen at much lower volumes which should be better for me
and they’re a lot harder to remove from The case - it’s a wide shallow slippery shape rather than the thinner AirPods which you can get a pinch onto easily
they’ve already fallen out twice while walking when the standard ones never did. it’s like it’s being pushed out of my ear. Might need a bigger tip but it already feels noticeable so I didn’t want to increase that. The originals often felt like I wasn’t wearing them
the noise cancelling doesn’t seem to block talking at all - on the train I can easily hear people and the train announcements. But it does seem to let me listen at much lower volumes which should be better for me
and they’re a lot harder to remove from The case - it’s a wide shallow slippery shape rather than the thinner AirPods which you can get a pinch onto easily
Ummmm I like the comfort of the airpods, but the app, there are positives, like the sound is better, the ANC helps you not listen to loud helping to lessen hearing loss.
I am not sure if they openly state it but most retail stores I have seen don’t take engravings back because they are personalized. I assume Apple is the same but could be wrong.
Searched the issue and yes Apple accepts Apple done engraving with the return period. It doesn’t accept third party engraving.
I think you don't have proper expectations of what ANC does. ANC will not take away all outside noise. It will take away MOST of the repetitive, low humming/background noise of the environment (plane engine, air conditioner humming, droning crowd noise, steady traffic noice, etc). It will not take away the sound of someone's voice standing next to you talking. It may reduce it a bit, but not remove it completely. It's not meant to take away ALL outside noise completely.
The silicone ear tips don't suit my ears - I had similar with PowerBeats 3 and no matter what size of tip I was using they would shift affecting sound quality as I rarely had a good seal. In contrast I'm really happy with the AirPods 2 having had the originals since launch and later upgrading. I also have Beats Studio wireless which I use more in winter or when on long journeys. For everyday use, especially in the Summer I love the AirPods 2 and am fine with no ANC. It's more about walking around with a soundtrack than being totally isolated from the world. I think both will have their place in the market.