ill try and explain it
first of all I like the Home Screen. its something totally different. I find it useful.
secondly, to me, no matter how distracted I am, I tend to know when im In the first page of apps, out of 3 or 4 pages.
so I rarely swipe left by mistake.
when im looking for an app its a common thing to swipe too far to the right. that lands me in the App Library, which instead of being something completely different, is actually just my apps rearranged in a different way. this jars and annoys me.
what makes it worse is that often when I swipe too far right, its when im one handed and distracted, and its amazing how many times I try to swipe back and it must be at an angle and I end up in the alphabetical list at which stage, im ****ed off.
plus, and this is solely personal, I can see apple being so close to what id consider nirvana. let me hide apps like you have, but switch off the App Library, and im happy as a bug in a rug.