Thanks. My Wallet says "Your Card Has Been Ordered. You will be notified when your card has shipped." I did speak with someone via chat after I posted that and they confirmed my address in their system is not a P.O. Box but didn't have an ETA. I guess I'll just have to wait a few days to see what happens.
It's so dumb that I feel like I have to keep on them about this. The other day I was told that my address was corrected and that they requested "expedited handling" only to have it cancelled the next day. And at that time I request a card again. I wonder if this is just some experiment for Apple/GS to see who is the most tenacious.