Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple sleep data has way more accurate than Android, maybe Android is prettier?
Seems like you haven't actually compared and just heard so?
Accuracy of tracking is about the same.
Android has really key features like:
- manual input/edit of sleep times (some devices)
- shows multiple time info in one day rather than just total and tracks less than 4 hour sessions automatically
 
Last edited:
No, the biggest area is in the presentation of data. Apple Watch data collects lots of data, and dumps it somewhere.

Garmin actually does something with it. I use both watches and prefer Garmin. I can see my past 7 days activity, runs, walks, cycles, all totalled in miles.

i forgot to mention, Garmin waits till a GPS lock before you start the run, Apple Watch just starts and misses part of the run (I believe Apple Watch Ultra acts like the Garmin, why though? Surely the normal AW can do this).

Next is the actually watch when doing an activity, The Apple Watch is a mess and useless when running. The Garmin is so much clearer to see when running. Everything I need is displayed in one screen. Again, the Apple Watch has more data collection, but it’s awful to use when running. I really wish it could be updated.

instead, Watch OS 11. Some gimmicks and more pride watch faces.
Yup, Garmin is very good.
Almost went with them instead of Samsung but it would have been double the price and for my first smartwatch figured I should test first.
If Apple watch isn't improved in some ways next year if I switch to iPhone then I will have to get a Garmin instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: honglong1976
YEP!!!!! Only seems to update properly when another metric is achieved.
I changed my goals for 1 day due to injuries and needed to rest. The damn thing says I broke the streak the next day until I completed that day's goals...
It is so annoying that these minor bugs are still plaguing the product this many years after it had been launched.
 
  • Like
Reactions: surfzen21
As an athlete, a lot of the new features look great. The training load metrics and analysis, something I use with Strava (as a subscription mind you), being readily available natively from Apple Watch data seems very promising.

Can't wait to try it!
This was a lot of what I wished for. Still hoped for maps integrated in the workout app for runs in new areas - sounds like the first step has been taken with the hiking feature in maps (Not for us in Europe but still).

Hope this means it will come
 
I changed my goals for 1 day due to injuries and needed to rest. The damn thing says I broke the streak the next day until I completed that day's goals...
It is so annoying that these minor bugs are still plaguing the product this many years after it had been launched.
Whole-heartedly agree.

While I appreciate some of the things added to WatchOS 10. Apple seemed to make more things worse.

Currently I have to reboot both my phone and watch every few days because the watches weather widgets stop working. I have temp and wind speed on the watch face and they will go out every few days until I reboot both devices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B4U
Took a while for the widgets to load or for the weather data to show up or both? My widgets were gone initially but then showed up, but with no data!
 
I really need Apple Watch to be accurate counting steps. I’m a bus driver in the UK and whilst sat, driving my bus, my watch has me walking all over the place - adding hundreds of erroneous steps. Surely Apple can design the watch tracking software to know when you’re driving and not walking!?
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnhackworth
All I want is the ability to broadcast HR directly to my Garmin. I hate you Apple.
 
I’ve injured myself trying to maintain streaks when I was exhausted and didn’t feel like it or was sick. Glad to have rest days. Would be great to be able to tell it when I’m sick on the flu, hope that makes it in. This makes a lot of sense for how actual exercise training works too. I usually go harder on certain days of the week, as it aligns with my schedule and allows for resting certain parts of my body on certain days. Fitness is not a one size fits all approach.
 
Whole-heartedly agree.

While I appreciate some of the things added to WatchOS 10. Apple seemed to make more things worse.

Currently I have to reboot both my phone and watch every few days because the watches weather widgets stop working. I have temp and wind speed on the watch face and they will go out every few days until I reboot both devices.
Same here. The weather goes out once in a while and I have to reboot both devices too.
(I find it funny when reading the very next post after yours and wanted to say it is not a WatchOS 11 only thing.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: surfzen21
Rest day, finally. For a company so focused on health, it was always glaring to me that they don’t consider *over* exercising to be a problem.

Glad this is finally there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: srknpower
Looking forward to trying out the new Photos watch face. Vitals app looks like a nice addition to the watch.
 
I really need Apple Watch to be accurate counting steps. I’m a bus driver in the UK and whilst sat, driving my bus, my watch has me walking all over the place - adding hundreds of erroneous steps. Surely Apple can design the watch tracking software to know when you’re driving and not walking!?
This is a problem for any tracker. It detects steps based on movement. On a bus you are moving, there are vibrations that it will count as steps. I get the same problem when driving. It's less on the Apple Watch than any other tracker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: srknpower
Yup, Garmin is very good.
Almost went with them instead of Samsung but it would have been double the price and for my first smartwatch figured I should test first.
If Apple watch isn't improved in some ways next year if I switch to iPhone then I will have to get a Garmin instead.
The main thing for me is a clear watch face with various complications. I tried to replicate my Garmin (glance) and it's impossible. The Altitude complication has a font so small, I can't even read it. Even worst if you are walking or running anywhere.

Same for running, it's a list of text on the AW.
 
Same here. The weather goes out once in a while and I have to reboot both devices too.
(I find it funny when reading the very next post after yours and wanted to say it is not a WatchOS 11 only thing.)
It somewhat makes me feel better than its not only me. I was getting close to doing a fresh install to see if that helped.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B4U
This is a problem for any tracker. It detects steps based on movement. On a bus you are moving, there are vibrations that it will count as steps. I get the same problem when driving. It's less on the Apple Watch than any other tracker.
I’m sure the algorithm could be better designed to ignore ‘steps’ when GPS is showing the watch moving at 20, 30, 40 even 50mph. It’s effectively useless as a health tracker for me as it counts hundreds of erroneous steps every duty. Especially when active calories and whatnot are also calculated on your activity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnhackworth
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.