Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple TV vs Playstation 3
- Thread starter Digitalflick
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The PS3 is a slight upgrade from the 360 but it's not much better, it's functional and organizes things by folders, so if you stream from tversity or other software you'll see the folders and can pick the video files, but there is no artwork like in ATV. It's usable but wont win any awards, if you've seen a PSP interface it's similar.
Check out doom9.net for all your encoding guides, great site.
I've used GordianKnot in the past, works well, it's free but initially it's a bit overwhelming.
although i am an apple freak, i think ps3 is waaaaayyyyy better than an apple tv.
lets start with how they are both similar
the ps3 has the ability to connect to ur external usb hard disks or laptops, so that you can have the ability to play music, see photos, and watch movies from the hard disk/laptop.
similar to what the apple tv does
the ps3 also CONNECTS to the internet, so you can have the ability to surf sites, youtube, download stuff.. real fun
i heard that the apple tv can too but im not sure
finally the ps3 is a PLAYSTATION!
its OTHER FEATURES are what compare to the apple tv
lets start with how they are both similar
the ps3 has the ability to connect to ur external usb hard disks or laptops, so that you can have the ability to play music, see photos, and watch movies from the hard disk/laptop.
similar to what the apple tv does
the ps3 also CONNECTS to the internet, so you can have the ability to surf sites, youtube, download stuff.. real fun
i heard that the apple tv can too but im not sure
finally the ps3 is a PLAYSTATION!
its OTHER FEATURES are what compare to the apple tv
although i am an apple freak, i think ps3 is waaaaayyyyy better than an apple tv.
lets start with how they are both similar
the ps3 has the ability to connect to ur external usb hard disks or laptops, so that you can have the ability to play music, see photos, and watch movies from the hard disk/laptop.
similar to what the apple tv does
the ps3 also CONNECTS to the internet, so you can have the ability to surf sites, youtube, download stuff.. real fun
i heard that the apple tv can too but im not sure
finally the ps3 is a PLAYSTATION!
its OTHER FEATURES are what compare to the apple tv
i cant speak for the apple tv but i have a ps3 and a mac mini. I love them both and honestly they almost both do the same thing as far as playing avis and downloading movies off both stores. I love them both. I would consider putting an apple tv in the living room but seriouslly I can't justify the price. that ps3 is sweet for real....
I too have a PS3 and a mini connected to my TV. In my opinion, it is the best setup you could have. A PlayStation 3 for games and Blu-ray and a mini for EVERYTHING else and a desktop computer. I would not recommend an Apple TV. It's way too limited to really take any advantage of.
The question is, could you use JUST the mini or JUST the PS3 as a media center device? I ask because I am on the threshold of deciding between them and am leaning towards the mini. The only downside being Bluray playback. I am planning to use Frontrow or Plex.
I don't really dig the PS3 ui as it seems a bit tedious to me.
-mx
I don't really dig the PS3 ui as it seems a bit tedious to me.
-mx
The interface of the ps3 is very simple. It looks tedious but once you get the hang of it it's nothing. I think either is a great option. Both devices can be controlled wirelessly . you can use either only as media center devices. With the mini you have a bit more flexibility because of itunes content and downloading torrents.
I haven't used my PS3 once for media other than Blu-Ray since getting my Apple TV.
Maybe if someone downloads stuff around the net a lot, then maybe the PS3 is better. But for me, I've done that and it grew tiresome to me. I am happy buying my media from iTunes and getting high-quality, logo-free videos to own. It makes the viewing experience a lot better. Renting movies is a snap.... The PS3 does what it does okay, but Apple TV is just so much better and streaming my iTunes library and anything I want to bother with is in my iTunes library, so it just works out better for me.
But to answer your question, it's really going to come down to how people want their media.
I agree with your last statement the apple tv works better if you download and purchase content from itunes store. I must admit in owning a mini and purchasing media from the itunes store. IT's way easier and better interface then the playstation store. If you can afford it I think the mini and ps3 is a way better option then the apple tv. If you want simplicity and save money then the apple tv is a great value. The apple tv is a cheaper solution. I think it really comes down to budget and preference. but seriously if you have a cable service with dvr the apple tv is really not necessary....
Well, I have a mac mini already that I can use and we do buy music and some movies off of iTunes so, it probably makes sense to go that way. The major downside is mainly the Bluray issue. I may just get a dedicated player for that or get in the habit of buying Blurays and ripping them.
I'm a bit of a sucker for new approaches and the PS3 intrigued me for that reason. I am also interested in the Netflix integration.
-mx
I'm a bit of a sucker for new approaches and the PS3 intrigued me for that reason. I am also interested in the Netflix integration.
-mx
i dont know why there's such a big infatuation with digitizing dvds and bluerays. i dont mind popping one in and playing it and taking it back. I have a ton of dvds and i can't imagine converting all of them. i just purchase a movies i really wanna watch over and over..........
A few of reasons for me:
1) I have children and they tend to scratch DVDs by just looking at them. This makes it much easier to buy a DVD once.
2) Ease of access.
3) Clutter. I can put the DVDs away in storage.
4) Travel. Easy to bring a collection for family vacations involving car travel.
5) Can't play Bluray on a Mac.
So, yes I could live without all of these but these are issues I want to address and the integration of all of it is worth the trouble for me.
-mx
Many probably said the same thing when DVD came out and they had no problem with fast-forwarding or rewinding a VHS tape.