Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I have very fond memories of playing Minotaur with friends. (Also a nod to Bolo, which probably dates me terribly).
 
When I think 'best Mac game', I think it is only fair to immediately rule out any game that wasn't released either the same day or before any other platform.

For example, Knights of the Old Republic is not a Mac game, nor a PC game ... it is a console game ported to those platforms.

So the only two I can really think of in terms of big releases are Myst and Marathon.

Oh, and the Avernum / Geneforge games ...

... and DEFINITELY the upcoming Avadon!
 
Marathon II

Sure the original Marathon is good, but, the second one is just so much better than the first in every way.
 
When I think 'best Mac game', I think it is only fair to immediately rule out any game that wasn't released either the same day or before any other platform.

I think that is completely unfair. :) If it runs natively on the Mac it is worthy of jugement pro or con. My example: World of Warcraft.
 
Marathon II

Sure the original Marathon is good, but, the second one is just so much better than the first in every way.

Absolutely. Marathon II: Durandal is not only the best Mac game ever; it's hands down the best computer game of all time.

Honors to the Avernum series as well - an absolutely addictive old-school RPG.
 
The answer is . . .

The correct answer is Deus Ex.

But I'm a lenient grader, so you get half credit for Marathon.
 
Sadly, the correct answer is, unless the game is MAC exclusive it shouldn't be mentioned here, so Dues ex, Monkey island, etc are all better on PC .

IF a game is available Mac and PC, the PC version seems to always be superior (even when written properly, such as Starcraft 2, or World Of Warcraft, the Mac version runs noticeably slower than the Windows 7 Bootcamped version on the same hardware) probably down to better vendor and OS support for Graphics drivers ETC, and coders focus on learning Direct X under windows.

And don't get me started on the "Wrappered" games like Dragon Age Origins, i wasted money on that P.O.S Mac port and ended up having to buy it again for windows when i found out the addons support was broken and it ran like a DOG under OSX.

I am hoping the MAC appstore will not allow "wrappered" games, to encourage native porting so that hopefully we will get a good native game.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.