Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Did a heads up comparison with GS5 and iPhone 6 and Plus at work
- Thread starter skratch77
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I've owned both Android and iPhone, and the experience in terms of OS and functionality is more similar than not. There are differences, but both were pretty fluid.
For my dad, I am looking at Sony Experia Z3, iPhone 6 and Nokia Icon. I'm looking at the Experia because of the amazing battery life, and the iPhone 6 and Icon because my dad can't screw up charging the phone with a microUSB.
All three phones have OSes that are fluid enough, have the apps my dad needs (Skype or Facetime), and large enough screen for him to interact with.
Basically, smartphones are becoming commodities now. It is boiling down to a matter of preference for most people.
For my dad, I am looking at Sony Experia Z3, iPhone 6 and Nokia Icon. I'm looking at the Experia because of the amazing battery life, and the iPhone 6 and Icon because my dad can't screw up charging the phone with a microUSB.
All three phones have OSes that are fluid enough, have the apps my dad needs (Skype or Facetime), and large enough screen for him to interact with.
Basically, smartphones are becoming commodities now. It is boiling down to a matter of preference for most people.
I've been hearing that for the last 2-3 years. I owned an S3 so I speak from experience. Every Samsung phone I've demoed has lag. I think it's appalling that Samsung sells the S5 with such a laggy skin on top of Android.
Mine doesn't lag either. I'm not sure I'd compare a 2 1/2 year old phone to our more recent ones.
Like I said, I can notice the same behavior in a Galaxy S5 and Note 3 in a 5 minute demo in a store. I'm not some iphone fanboy who has never owned an Android phone.
No offense, but using a demo phone is one of the worst ways to gage UI lag. You realize how much those phones get messed with?
As for the S3, I owned that phone as well. Comparing a dual-core cpu that was designed to run on 4.0-4.1 is hardly a comparison to an S5 running 4.4.4. Not even in the same ballpark. Why not compare an iPhone 4S to a 6 and make the same claims?
P.S. I hate Touch wiz as a UI. But the nice thing about Samsung S series phones, you have the option to get a Google Edition. I'm guessing you have never played with stock Android on a powerful phone?
I've been hearing these excuses for years. The first thing you hear is just denial "my phone doesn't lag." Then you hear about these magical tweaks...that don't fix the issue. The final thing is the mythical software update that...wait for it...doesn't fix the lag. I experienced the lag on my S3 for 2 years. I experienced the same type of lag on other Samsung phones in the store. The M8 I demoed did not have this type of lag. All signs point to Touchwiz being the culprit.
I use Verizon so the Google Play Edition is/was not an option for me.
I agree here, its funny because I always find the store/demo units have less lag then after I buy the phone and get all my apps running on it.
The note 3 and s5 almost have zero lag, but there is the occasional lag/stutter. (in my experience on verizon)
Will this lag be fixed? Kind of annoying having to deal with an issue like this on a "premium" smartphone.
There is NO denial. Give me 2 apps that lag, I'll video my Note 3 next to an iPhone 5 and upload it. I call BS on all these cries of "lag", at least lag that realistically affects someone's use of the phone. If an app is a couple of milliseconds slow to open that's just nitpicking, but in terms of using the app there will be no difference.
The S3 example is stupid, it's a 2 1/2 old phone which is eons in technology years.
Never owned an S3 but given it's a couple generations old, it's likely no more laggy by todays standards than my iPhone 4s is. If you've actually used an S5 or a Note 3 (which I own) when set up properly, there's zero lag.
If you're basing your decision on a 5 minute in-store play sessoin with a phone that you're not familiar with, then you're selling yourself short.
The problem is you're running touchwiz. Not knocking it, I've just chosen to use Nova Launcher Pro which IMO is far better. On the S5 and Note 3, you can turn off all 3 animation settings for instant everything. You can also replace the dialer app.
All of the above are "options" that the phone was designed to have in the hands of the owner should the few milliseconds of animations and delays that are there out of the box both you. Most of which are not offered on the iPhone. Don't like their music EQ System, dialer or iMessage App then you're SOL.
Again, that's the first thing you should do on Android too...IMO.
The options I mentioned 100% remove the objections you've mentioned.
OS update? Again, see my updates and there's zero lag.
You know my car bogs and lags when I have traction control on during spirited driving too.
Pro Tip: turn it off----------
The lag being discussed isn't really "lag". Unless you're completely annoyed at any type of animation/transition. I equate what is being discussed to the same type of delay on many cable boxes. When I push channel up it "lags" but if I use the menu button scroll through the stations and click ok, it jumps to the station immediately.
I also think many of the issues are from people who constantly close their apps vs letting the OS manage them. I have hundreds of photos on my Note 3 and if I shut everything down and reboot then open the photo app it will take a brief second to begin loading the images. Not even lag, just a brief millisecond. However I never close my photo app as there's zero need. The phone will reassign RAM if and when needed thus no matter when I pull it up, that brief millisecond of "lag" is gone.
You don't stop your car and turn it off at red lights while driving do you? Of course not. Even hybrids control such things automatically. Then don't start and stop apps on a smartphone when you're using it throughout the day.
Last edited:
Switched out silver for gold 64gb, black leather case was replaced black silicone.
Updated memory with.99 cent per month iCloud 20gb bump.
Running SwiftKey for keyboard.
And really really liking it so far. My S5 is getting pretty dusty at the moment.
iOS 8 is far more versatile that I expected, and the phone design itself is the best Apple has done. The size and shape and weight are just pleasing to handle.
You guys are just proving my point. Same things I've been hearing for at least 2+ years about Samsung phones not lagging. I know from personal experience that they do.
I know from personal experience that in your case it's user error
----------
Only those that don't understand how to configure the phone correctly.
My S4 was a laggy mess. Sold after 2 months and got a 5S.
My S5 was not laggy in the slightest. Not smoothest, because there was plenty of chunky UI moments, but not laggy by any means.
My S5 was not laggy in the slightest. Not smoothest, because there was plenty of chunky UI moments, but not laggy by any means.
Yes, my S4 was very laggy in the beginning. Even home screens. Updates have helped. By, running good roms esp non TW ones has it smooth now. Today I played with 6+ and Note 4 in BB. The 6+ ran a lot better in BB than the ATT demo did. The Note 4 speaker didn't sound that good, didn't try 6+ one. The 4's screen seemed a little slow to touches. Both screens were great. Really would like to hear call quality from speaker phone on both. My years of flashing Android roms may be over and want just a smooth phone with good sound and camera. N4 may have too many features for me that I won't use. Just my initial take with a lot hands on still needed.