So Apple screwed up a lot here. First of all, the problem does not seem to depend on Dolby Atmos or your devide at all. The DA might be the cause but I have this problem with all songs independent of their DA status and over iPhone and iPad - so it's a general problem. (Furthermore, I am not using lossless, so it is not an issue either.) In my case, it appears only when a song is downloaded, is shown as downloaded, but is really "broken" and with internet connection off this song does not play beyond 15 seconds. (An interesting observation: if you turn the internet on and try to play the song beyond 15 seconds, it becomes fully playable even after turning off internet.)
Secondly, the settings are firmly screwed since now two toggles "Download with Dolby Atmos" and "Automatic Download" in Settings/Music are interconnected and turning off one leads to automatic turning off of the other one (which should not really be the case).
Thirdly, I've spent today 1.5 hours on my phone with AppleCare advisors and went up to the Senior who tried different solutions (indulging signing out, deleting the app, restarting the phone, etc. etc.) but nothing worked. The nuclear option of "erase everything and download a backup" was used then with the hope - but nah, it is still stuck, just different songs. Tomorrow evening (Berlin time), I'll have another call with the Senior advisor to clarify the issue. Most probably, the problem is either with the files on the iPhone (outdated certificates? errors with the new functions?) or with the servers (overloaded? just not working - maybe because of the recent outrage that turn off half of the internet?)
So just stay calm and I'll try to keep this thread updated. Peace ??
Ok now i'm frustrated just as you now. It's been 2 days since i've been trying to fix my apple music library.
Here's a little bit of my background, I was a soldier a while back that was used to back to back year long deployments that meant I had no way back to access songs, movies or videos just as easily as it was to connect an pc to the internet stateside or europe, We did but it was satellite kps bandwidth speeds, downloading a 700mb took like 18 hours overseas. Back in those days we had ipod's, external hard drives for all our media, I personally had an Archos media player that was famous at the time for playing all kinds of media formats and using upgradable SSD internal memory my first being an 30gb, 80gb, at their peak they sold upto 500gb media players which was unheard of in the mid 2000's-2010's.
Anyways I always had this mentality that I always need to have my media in some sort of physical form, be in back up or at the time on cd's/dvd's
My biggest qualm with apple has always been it's backwards outlook towards memory and this lossless/hi res release proved it.
with the archos I could manage the internal memory just as easy as plugging it in the hard drive to a PC and transfer it, I had control of my content.
With Apple I let them take control and once again this release just shows they had no idea to plan for the long term because their competition got the best of them IMHO.
I adapt and over come easily so I always had just high quality versions of my songs of on my idevices because of their storage size and i've purchased close to 2,300 songs through itunes over 11 years since i've gotten used the apple ecosystem but I always kept hi res back ups on my PC as usual, anyways the ease of use of Apple Music over the years helped me expand my Apple music library close to 8,880 songs, for this reason I always got a 256gb iphone, because the total size was always close from 60-80gb, before the lossless release it was close to 89gb.
Apple states that close to 20 million songs are hi res but i am having an extremely hard time narrowing down which songs or artists they managed to do, nearly 55% is lossless, I could handle the lossless songs since every 10gb is a 1,000 songs somewhat but I wish I could sort out if I could only download lossless and still have the ability to choose hi res just in case because as of this writing the 89 gb that was of music before is now close to 185gb, i always like to keep close to 60gb free for pictures but as my music catalog is massively eating up this, I feel Apple should dramatically increase their storage sizes for their next iphones IMHO. I have 1,200 songs left to download by the way.
I of course trimmed my music library down a lot by getting rid of unnecessary songs, I listen to a lot of music, have the high res gear for it, but now i'm contemplating deleting my library again because i have no idea how much my entire music library size really is thanks to apple.
Can't really complain for not paying an upgraded service but this was a massive curveball for the regular routines I had in regards to my music since now I have no idea what songs or artists or albums are hi res/lossless, I wish there was an icon on the library menu to see but still, sorry if i'm venting but the obvious answer would be to upgrade to the next model but thankfully I have 1tb ipad with tons of space to test this out and probably back up my music that way. It's frustrating because apple tier 1 support really has no idea how to help me out with the previous issue, I went from songs being brokenly downloaded and not playing after 15 seconds, to now running out of storage.
My main concern now if a song that features dolby atmos/lossless is taking more space because of the dolby atmos track.