Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

UmichAg

macrumors member
Feb 26, 2008
94
19
I suppose you should try for the ones that support the max USB speed of 10 Gbps. Actually, they don't get faster than 5 Gbps. The DL-6000 series of chips seems to be the latest and most capable. They can do up to 5120x2880.
Will any of these docks support dual external monitors?
 

joevt

macrumors 604
Jun 21, 2012
6,967
4,262
SwitchResX works to set resolutions but doesn't provide details. Says "System doesn't provide detailed information about this resolution."

AGDCDiagnose just gives an error message.



From https://www.khronos.org/opengl/wiki/Default_Framebuffer: "The front and back buffers represent a double-buffered framebuffer. The front buffer is, more or less, what you see on the screen. The back buffer is the image that is typically rendered to."
Interesting about SwitchResX. Apple is going in the wrong direction when it comes to giving info about graphics. Knowing refresh rates, framebuffer size, framebuffer color format, output color format, output size is important to ensure that a display is receiving the optimum signal. Hopefully SwitchResX just needs to change the API it uses?

That definition of framebuffer/back buffer is from OpenGL. It might not apply to macOS (which doesn't even do OpenGL in Big Sur on M1 macs). However, how macOS graphics works isn't spelled out anywhere. There must be a buffer for drawing. I don't know if there's another buffer for scaling to the output size. I only know there may be a scaling operation before the signal is sent out on the wire. So for simplicity, I say there's a one framebuffer that may be scaled.
Will any of these docks support dual external monitors?
I haven't used DisplayLink before. The DisplayLink macOS software download page says "DisplayLink Manager is a new way to enable your DisplayLink dock, adapter or monitor on macOS platforms. It's an application that combines our latest driver with features that streamline the setup of mutliple displays up to 4K." So, if you get a dock that supports multiple displays, then it should work. They have product search function where you can choose how many displays you want to support. Most of the docks support more than one display. There are a few that support three.
 

phl92

macrumors 6502
Oct 28, 2020
301
47
That might be a dumb question but I want to be sure:
does a Mac laptop connected to an external screen (Dell 26" monitor) need more performance than when using the normal laptop screen?
I used to use my MBP 13" on my desktop screen connected with a 60FPS HDMI cable... but the question comes up now when considering buying a new one...
 

MK500

macrumors 6502
Aug 28, 2009
434
550
Just sharing my dual 1440p display plan here, in case it is useful to others:

MacBook Air M1 16/512
-> Apple “USB-C Digital AV Multiport Adapter” ($69). It has 3 ports as shown below
-> HDMI -> 27” 2560x1440 monitor @ 60hz
-> USB 5gbit -> Displaylink adapter -> HDMI 27” 2560x1440 monitor @ 60hz
-> USB C Power Port Passthrough -> Apple Power Brick

My Displaylink adapter also has Ethernet, audio, and USB ports for my keyboard/mouse.

- This setup should hypothetically allow me to boot up in clamshell mode (I have successfully tested this with just the apple adapter connected to a single monitor/keyboard/mouse).
- This setup should still leave a Thunderbolt port free for storage arrays and such.
- I used the two-part solution vs. a single dock because it gives me clamshell support and full display bandwidth on the first display.

Although I have never used Displaylink before, we know that it works with the M1. My assumption is that my left monitor will end up being better for video editing, gaming, or watching 4K video (downscaled) because it has a direct path to the GPU. My right display will have the extra overhead of a frame-buffer that is compressed, shoved over 5gbit USB, and then decompressed onto the display. This should be fine for terminal windows, XCode, web browsing, financial charting, etc.

I will receive the Displaylink adapter today, and will report back on how well this all works.

[EDIT] It seems to be working really really well. This is the one I bought for $140: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0823BQ4PK/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
 
Last edited:

nothingtoseehere

macrumors 6502
Jun 3, 2020
455
522
OWC put out a press release saying their docks have compatibility with the M1 macs. Can anyone confirm this? If so, I will order one as a dual monitor setup is important for my workflow.
As mentioned above, I asked OWC about this. I got an answer! :eek:

At first, my question: "Dear OWC, with great interest, I read your post here https://eshop.macsales.com/blog/678...n=cj&cjevent=008527c6299311eb81e900600a180511 There you state that your docks will work with the M1 Macs. But will they still support two 4K displays? Especially the mini dock. As Apple states, that the M1 MBA and MBP only support 1 external display. Not 2 as with the former Intel MBA."

The answer: "Unfortunately, we can’t “officially” confirm whether or not this is possible. But please keep your eye on the blog as we will continue to release information as we can!"

Mmh... ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DenBeke

MK500

macrumors 6502
Aug 28, 2009
434
550
That might be a dumb question but I want to be sure:
does a Mac laptop connected to an external screen (Dell 26" monitor) need more performance than when using the normal laptop screen?
I used to use my MBP 13" on my desktop screen connected with a 60FPS HDMI cable... but the question comes up now when considering buying a new one...

The only Dell 26” displays I’m seeing are 1920x1080 resolution, so change out the numbers below if your external display specs are higher.

Its mostly a factor of the total pixels being rendered and the connection being used. Assuming you are connecting a single monitor with the Apple “USB-C Digital AV Multiport Adapter” over HDMI it would work like this:

Internal display only=
2560x1600 -> approx. 4.1 million pixels

External Dell display only=
1920x1080 -> approx. 2.1 million pixels

So assuming all displays are running at 60hz, the total load on the GPU will vary depending on what you have plugged in. Running the external alone (laptop in clamshell mode) should put about half the load on your processor than the internal alone!

But both internal and external running simultaneously would be pushing 6.2 million pixels, so a bit reduced performance.

If you are using a Displaylink adapter instead of the Apple one there will be a bunch of extra overhead that will reduce performance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: phl92

KPOM

macrumors P6
Oct 23, 2010
18,311
8,324
As mentioned above, I asked OWC about this. I got an answer! :eek:

At first, my question: "Dear OWC, with great interest, I read your post here https://eshop.macsales.com/blog/678...n=cj&cjevent=008527c6299311eb81e900600a180511 There you state that your docks will work with the M1 Macs. But will they still support two 4K displays? Especially the mini dock. As Apple states, that the M1 MBA and MBP only support 1 external display. Not 2 as with the former Intel MBA."

The answer: "Unfortunately, we can’t “officially” confirm whether or not this is possible. But please keep your eye on the blog as we will continue to release information as we can!"

Mmh... ?
If you try to connect 1 external display to each Thunderbolt port directly, only the first one plugged in works. The second display won‘t turn on unless you unplug the first external display.

The best workaround for those who need 2 external displays is to use AirPlay to wirelessly connect to the second display. I confirmed that it works with my LG Ultrafine 5K and a 4K TV that supports AirPlay.
 

Asi24

macrumors newbie
Nov 2, 2020
5
11
Can confirm that M1 Mac Mini (base model, 8GB ram 256GB ssd) can run full res LG 5K display. And that it can do so while also running a 4K display at full res simultaneously through the HDMI port. Don’t have a second Thunderbolt Display to try a dual set up through the second TB/USB 4 port.
 

ginuz

macrumors member
Jul 21, 2011
40
31
Hi, is there any possibility to connect my old, but still glorious, Apple Cinema Display 30'' to my new MacBook Pro M1 (yet to arrive)??
thanks
 

aquaboy

macrumors regular
Feb 17, 2011
164
25
UK
I have a Mac Mini M1 connected to an Apple Thunderbolt Display.
I have a couple of annoying pixels which where not there when my MacBook Pro 2019 was connected but suddenly appeared when I changed machines. I no longer have the MBP so I can't test it...
 

edanuff

macrumors 6502a
Oct 30, 2008
578
259
Can confirm that M1 Mac Mini (base model, 8GB ram 256GB ssd) can run full res LG 5K display. And that it can do so while also running a 4K display at full res simultaneously through the HDMI port. Don’t have a second Thunderbolt Display to try a dual set up through the second TB/USB 4 port.
Super interesting! Is this a relatively new LG 5K and how are you sure it’s not doing 4K upscaled? Also, can you tell if the 4K monitor on the HDMI port is in RGB mode or in YCnCr mode?
 
  • Like
Reactions: strawbale

strangeengine

macrumors regular
Jan 30, 2017
116
81
Super interesting! Is this a relatively new LG 5K and how are you sure it’s not doing 4K upscaled? Also, can you tell if the 4K monitor on the HDMI port is in RGB mode or in YCnCr mode?

Apple still sells the UltraFine 5K. Do you really think they'd fail to mention that it runs degraded with the M1 machines? Especially given that they used it for performance testing and list it in the footnotes?

They have done non-standard support things with this monitor in the past (on-screen controls, etc) - why wouldn't they do the same for the M1?
 

MK500

macrumors 6502
Aug 28, 2009
434
550

dima237

macrumors newbie
Nov 18, 2020
4
0
Just plugged in my new mbp with m1 in my lg 49wl95c-w with usb c. Max resolution I can get is 3840x1080...!

I have also the latest intel mbp here and it works just fine in 5120x1440!

Anyone with the same problem? I know there is "always" a problem with apple and ultrawide. The old MacBook (2017) by my girlfriend also only works in 3840x1080. But I really thought the new mbp m1 which I able to run 6k 60hz should be able to run 5120x1440 (which is less than 4k!)
I have exact same issue with Samsung CRG9. Was working find with 13 inch MBP (intel card not deducted GPU). Same 8k cable from Cable Matters, same display no go now. I can not even get it to connect at all with USB-C to DisplayPort cable. Tried with USB-C to HDMI, max I get is 3840x1080 but that could be the cable limitation. But the DisplayPort cable definitely should work. Something is messed with the drivers probably? I had a similar issue when my MBP was on Catalina. Could only manage full 5120x1440 via two cables and picture-in-picture mode (so two virtual displays). But after Big Sur (even on beta) was woking perfectly with one cable.
 

dima237

macrumors newbie
Nov 18, 2020
4
0
Quick follow up. Tinkering with SwitchResX I managed to get 5120x1440 going. Not sure if it actually had anything to do with SwitchResX per se, because I was messing about with monitor settings as well, but basically the only way I managed to get it working is:

1. Plug in the monitor first. NO POWER plugged in, lid open.
2. External monitor starts working. Set the SwitchResX resolution to 5120x1440
3. Connect power and close the lid.

This way I can use my USB-C to DisplayPort cable with 5120x1440 @ 119Hz

Will keep testing for consistency, but now it looks like a software bug for sure.

Oh, BTW, went ahead and updated to 11.1 Beta as well. So, again, not a very scientific approach as I am not sure exactly what worked at the end
 

Asi24

macrumors newbie
Nov 2, 2020
5
11
Super interesting! Is this a relatively new LG 5K and how are you sure it’s not doing 4K upscaled? Also, can you tell if the 4K monitor on the HDMI port is in RGB mode or in YCnCr mode?
Image 11-18-20 at 4.16 PM.JPG
The HDMI 4K monitor looks the same color-wise as it did running off my MBP 15 i9 from 2019. No idea how to tell different but it looks good when doing Lightroom edits off that screen. Take a look at the Mac Mini tear down article from this morning—shows that there in fact seems to be an Intel thunderbolt controller in there that would support this display. So previous speculation seemed mistaken.
 

ryanbates

macrumors regular
May 30, 2010
244
60
San Diego, CA
Curious how the M1’s will run with the display open and connected to a single 27” Dell 4K monitor.

My 16” sounds like a jet engine half the time with the fans on
 
  • Like
Reactions: babatunde22

briancis

macrumors newbie
Mar 14, 2013
2
0
If you try to connect 1 external display to each Thunderbolt port directly, only the first one plugged in works. The second display won‘t turn on unless you unplug the first external display.

The best workaround for those who need 2 external displays is to use AirPlay to wirelessly connect to the second display. I confirmed that it works with my LG Ultrafine 5K and a 4K TV that supports AirPlay.
Confirmed also on the pro deck. 10gbe networking doesn't work yet either although it is connecting at 1gb. Hopefully the networking issue can be resolved with a driver update.
 

KPOM

macrumors P6
Oct 23, 2010
18,311
8,324
Curious how the M1’s will run with the display open and connected to a single 27” Dell 4K monitor.

My 16” sounds like a jet engine half the time with the fans on
Well, sound won't be a problem with the Air! The M1 handles my 5K monitor like a champ, so I'm sure it would be even better with a 4K monitor.
 

PowerMac G4 MDD

macrumors 68000
Jul 13, 2014
1,900
277
The classic Apple Thunderbolt Display allows for daisy-chaining. Has anyone tried plugging one into the M1 Mac and the other into the first display? I know it probably won't yield anything, but might as well exhaust all options.

I suggested my father buy an M1 MacBook Air to replace his original rMBP - but, it seems he may have to wait for a later revision: he uses 2x Apple Thunderbolt Displays and wants to continue using both those displays with whatever new Mac he gets. Currently, it seems that that's not possible to do, with an M1 Mac. (As an aside, he wants a laptop — not a Mac Mini — and absolutely doesn't want any old HDMI display in place of the second Tb display.)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.