Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
No I would not get a macbook air. Too expensive, slow, no cd drive, please dont get me started. Okay you are a senior in high school, look at a mac book or a macbook pro. The Macbook air is going to be painfully slow to even consider to do anything but surf the web. I am dying to see the GPU!
A 1.8 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo is not a bad chip by any means. Of course it won't be as fast as the ones in the MacBook, but it's still far better than even the fastest Pentium/Core Duo chips.
 
No optical drive = the demise of the MBA.

Society just isn't ready to abandon CD's/DVD's...this product was released 10 years too soon.

1998 called. They said, "Hey, you got that statement wrong... it's FLOPPY DRIVE, not OPTICAL DRIVE!"

By the way, when I can fit 8 GB on a $50 flash drive (and it'll be half that in 4-6 months), yeah, I don't need a CD/DVD drive. wtf would I need one for?!?! This is a great computer for anyone that already has a desktop at home and needs a laptop on the road. I'm buying one. If it's not for you.... great. That doesn't mean it's not for a lot of other people. What you need isn't the same as what I need.
 
A 1.8 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo is not a bad chip by any means. Of course it won't be as fast as the ones in the MacBook, but it's still far better than even the fastest Pentium/Core Duo chips.

And the GPU is the same "Intel GMA X3100 graphics processor with 144MB of DDR2 SDRAM shared with main memory" found in the current MacBooks. Which isn't too bad as far as integrated graphics go.

B
 
No optical drive = the demise of the MBA.

Society just isn't ready to abandon CD's/DVD's...this product was released 10 years too soon.
Please take a look at the Windows side. Many laptops without optical drives are available and will continue to be available.

Not everyone wants an optical drive built in.

I NEVER need to burn a DVD on it, that's what the iMac and PC are for.
I would venture to say that most people with desktop models will do the same.

I've had my PB15 for 5 years and have only burnt maybe 4-5 CDs and DVDs over that period of time.
 
Should I purchase the MBA?

I am a senior in high school currently but am going to college next year and would love an ultra portable laptop. To give you background information, I have somehow crashed around two-three laptops including a $2500 one (lol,long stories). I plan on toting this from class to class next year. But at home, all I use my laptop for is browsing the internet, itunes, e-mail capablities, and designing graphics... and obviously just word documents. I only use the cd-drive to burn cds or install programs occasionally... is it worth it for me? I'm not sure if I am better off buying the black regular macbook... but weight is a significant factor.

No - the MacBook is a much more versatile machine. Besides, even white macs are on the way out now (BOO! BRING EM BACK) so it will look even cooler and different than it does now, especially to PC users.

Besides, the money you save (dunno what it is in $) can be put towards PS3, booze or toward college fees for next year.

Don't forget your education rebate whichever you buy!
 
Should I purchase the MBA?

I am a senior in high school currently but am going to college next year and would love an ultra portable laptop.
Liberal arts or hard science? If you're going into one of the sciences, your textbooks will be heavy. If you have plans for medical or law school, they get heavier still. Every pound and every tenth of an inch does count...and I went to school well before 5.5 pound, 1" MacBook Pros. They especially engineer law casebooks so that that last one is just a quarter-inch too big for your bag.

If you're not balking at the price (and I assume you're not, since you're looking at ultraportables generally), then there's no reason not to. Those two and a half pounds do make a difference when they're on your shoulders multiple times a day, every day.

Even a regular MacBook is much thinner and lighter than my school laptop ever was, and it's a lot cheaper. But you really don't gain much, other than some cash...and if you're paying with scholarship or financial aid money, maybe not even that.

These notebooks are faster and more powerful than G4 PowerBooks, which people to this day use for pretty demanding work. You won't be coming close to that; even Photoshop will run fine. It's always remarkable to see people suddenly forget that most people don't have cutting edge specs, and a 2002 PowerMac much slower than this handles just fine. Hell, an 800MHz XP machine works just fine for most people...and look what a 300MHz iPhone can do.
 
This is my first post on the MBA, and I find a lot of points made on it so amusing!

For me it is the perfect notebook, that is it [ok fixed battery is annoying]

I have previously sold my macbook and MBP, due to weight issues alone.

I have a new Imac [bought with the same amount of cash I sold the MBP for:)] so what do I need a high end processor, dvd burner, large screen, all the connections for.........

The MBA is designed for people like me. Out and about, require basic internet / email, pages etc and maybe the odd time need to access something a bit more powerful but not for hours on end. I never really once required the power of the MBP nor used the superdrive once when out.

I can't think of a better, more suited computer.

It is obviously a crap computer for someone who either is cheap, needs lots of power or only can afford one computer. If that is you, get another computer and quit moaning. It is boring..............
 
It is obviously a crap computer for someone who either is cheap, needs lots of power or only can afford one computer. If that is you, get another computer and quit moaning. It is boring..............

No need for rudeness.

Personally I'm none of those things (cheap, needs power, can only afford one computer etc) but what I do need, and many others legitimately have pointed this out, is a real ultraportable. Even though the 12" powerbook wasn't one it worked out ok for many on that front.

However, to those who are just moaners, I'll let you carry on insulting them. Every 'new product' thread has them and they possibly deserve it :)
 
MacBook Air, with a 2Ghz Mac Mini?

Maybe Apple should do a special offer with a MBA and a decent spec Mini. For everyone other than power users and gamers, I would say thats a match made in heaven.....
 
Whilst it's true that CDs are long overdue a death (though don't count on it especially with PCs, which *still* often have floppies sitting in them), DVD is still a fairly useful capacity. It still takes a long time to transfer 4.7GB over wireless or worse still the internet (and bandwidth doesn't come free, last I checked it was working out at something like £1/GB?!)

Optical drives in general are far from dead. We have BlueRay next which is massive. Optical discs remain the cheapest and most convenient way to store large amounts of data on a long term basis and I can't see that changing any time soon. There's certainly a case for excluding them from ultra-portables, but they have a loooooong life ahead of them on the desktop.

P.S. those who want a *real* ultra-portable and aren't fussed about OS X should check out the Asus Eee. You can buy 6 of them for the price of the MBA, too.
 
the world in 2058

No you are very wrong. CD drives are vital. The indsutry is not going to cahnge any time soon I just spoke with somone at microsoft and they said not a change at least 40-50 years.
Unless you meant 4-5 typed 40-50 by mistake, you're very naive if you think anyone can predict what the the technology will be like in 40 or 50 years.
(and Microsoft... wasn't it the company who said that the iPhone wouldn't sell, and the Zune would?)
Unless microsoft does something like apple it IS IMPOSSIBLE!! (NOTICE THE WORD IMPOSSIBLE!!!)
oh, Microsoft and others have never copied Apple in the past. Never. (oh, and i DID notice the word impossible, it was in big caps.)
Apple does not have the money and marketshare to change how people use theri computers.
Never happened in the past. It's not as if they had invented personal comptuers (i.e a computer with its own screen and keyboard ) or popularised the mouse and the desktop metaphor..oh, but they DID, actually !
Dell and micrsoft do, but apple has no where near the power. And judging from what microsoft said, The CD/DVD drive is here to stay for a very very long time.
repeat, repeat, reapeat. If you can't prove it, repeat it.
Apple is just doing what they said about the G5 "worlds fastest coputer," which in fact it was much slower sometimes twice and four times slower than the AMD. Then when intel came along they are"G5 is very slow, new products 5-10 times faster."
euh, wasn't that months, or even years later? And different chips meant that comparisons were hard to make (more mhz did not always meant more speed), which caused endless disputes about who is faster.
See it is all marketing!!!! When they make a cd drive small enough to fit inside the MacBook Air then Steve Jobs will be like "see unlike other comptetiors ore notebook is .1 inches and has a cd drive for your latest dvd and games"
I doubt they will ever try to market it for games. And they wouldn't "make" a cd drive small enough, they don't make the parts. They just find a way to fit them in the box, with cooling system, etc., which is already an engineering feat;
people grow up,
mmm nice coment from someone mature enough to believe in 50 years predictions.
you mac people are starting to really get in my nerves.
Well, why are you doing here, if mac people get on your nerves?
I mean you guys are living in some fantasy. No wonder this guy is rich!
er, yes of course, Steve Jobs is the richest man (I think it's second nowdays) in the world, not Bill Gates (at this point, you might want to open a dictionary and look up the meaning of "irony"). Have a look at the prices of OS X and Vista in Europe, and tell me who is getting rich with overpriced products. (hint : one of them is 90% more expensive in Europe than in the US).
I think you forget apple only own 6% market share! Mainly due to one thing!!!! IPOD!!!
er, the iPod works with windows PC as well. You might refer to the "halo" effect theory, according to which the iPod boosted Mac sales because it improved Apple's image. I think you overestimate it. Since you're talking hardware, 6% is not so bad (the 2 biggest players are around 33% and 15%), especially since Apple does not compete in the 300$ computer category .
Yes I am aggitated because I see people on this forum with no brains
trying to say that a CD drive is not important because the MAcbook air came out.
are we reading the same thread? I saw people getting agitated because the Macbook air had not CD drive. Then a few people commented that THEY did not use their optical drive that much, and that they could do away with it. Very few people went on saying that the optical drive was doomed. Oh, and those who did had arguments, too, other than repetition, exclamation marks and 50 years prediction from Microsoft - their own experience, or the precedent of the iMac without a floppy, for instance. They might be wrong, but they were using arguments, not just following anything Jobs says.
The only reason why it does not have a cd drive is not because apple does not think it is important, (if they did why not do it to the powermac, macbook pro and everything,) it is because it WILL NOT FIT. You people act stupid you get treated like your stupid!
It will not fit??? Of course, everyone here knows it. The question is: is it worth making a laptop so thin that an optical drive won't fit? (for instance, many believe that a little thicker with an optical drive would have been better) And again, most people here were as agitated as you are about all that Apple had to get rid of in order to make the MBAir.
I really can't see why you should get so agitated and call people names: most people here agree with you-though I don't.
Is it possible you read 2 or 3 comments out of several hundreds and concluded that it represented the whole thread? I suggest you go towards the beginning of the thread, where you shall finds lots of people repeating "THINNER is NOT a FEATURE!!!!" , and listing all the missing feature which make the MBA a piece of crap, with all the things you like: insults, caps, and lots of "!". That should keep you happy.
Oh, and if you have more information about the world in 2058 according to Microsoft, please share it. I love a good laugh.
 
When talking about how apple cannot influence the future of computers, you also forgot to mention that the internet was created on a network of macs to start with. Thats why every online PeeCee has a MAC code. Even my PSP needs a MAC code to get online....
 
When talking about how apple cannot influence the future of computers, you also forgot to mention that the internet was created on a network of macs to start with. Thats why every online PeeCee has a MAC code. Even my PSP needs a MAC code to get online....

LOL. Do you know how wrong you are?

Humour is often hard to figure out on the internet.
 
The level of stupidity here is amazing...

The MBA will be a HIT, yes, I attended the Keynote, and I had my 5 minutes with the MBA at the Sales meeting later in the evening yesterday, the thing is simply perfect for those of us who travel a lot and need a computer with decent features for working.
Its very light and the LCD is gorgeous, quite speedy BTW..!

You need more features? buy a MB or a MBP, as it is the MBA is just about perfect, and Apple will sell a ton of them, despite the complaining by the clueless that spell doom for Apple everytime they take out a new product...

Which one did you try? If both, how would you rate the difference in user experience?
 
When talking about how apple cannot influence the future of computers, you also forgot to mention that the internet was created on a network of macs to start with. Thats why every online PeeCee has a MAC code. Even my PSP needs a MAC code to get online....

:D I apologise, I know it is rude to laugh like this… but this is a keeper! :D :D
 
Have I made a booboo? Just what I was led to believe, but sounds like I was sorely misinformed....

I was under the impression that the original country-wide network was created by CERN. (A European nuclear research organisation), and the network was created on applemacs.

I was however taking the piss with a MAC code, which I am well aware is a Migration Access code....
 
Have I made a booboo? Just what I was led to believe, but sounds like I was sorely misinformed....

I was under the impression that the original country-wide network was created by CERN. (A European nuclear research organisation), and the network was created on applemacs.

I was however taking the piss with a MAC code, which I am well aware is a Migration Access code....

too late for redemption newbie.
 
Have I made a booboo? Just what I was led to believe, but sounds like I was sorely misinformed....

I was under the impression that the original country-wide network was created by CERN. (A European nuclear research organisation), and the network was created on applemacs.

I was however taking the piss with a MAC code, which I am well aware is a Migration Access code....

Phew! :)

For internet history try here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet

The internet doesn't equal the web btw. The web sits on the internet.
 
And the GPU is the same "Intel GMA X3100 graphics processor with 144MB of DDR2 SDRAM shared with main memory" found in the current MacBooks. Which isn't too bad as far as integrated graphics go.

B

If that is so, then if it had a built in optical drive, (supuerdrive,) Aluminum keypads, more usb, dual link dvi, then maybe would I consider it. I bet the next revesion will include an optical drive.
 
If that is so, then if it had a built in optical drive, (supuerdrive,) Aluminum keypads, more usb, dual link dvi, then maybe would I consider it. I bet the next revesion will include an optical drive.

There won't be dual-link DVI in any MacBook (non-Pro) anytime soon.

As for the other stuff you want, it is called a MacBook. There will never be an Air with integrated optical drive. Wake up.
 
If that is so, then if it had a built in optical drive, (supuerdrive,) Aluminum keypads, more usb, dual link dvi, then maybe would I consider it. I bet the next revesion will include an optical drive.

What you are describing is the next MBP. Wait 6 months. Waiting for Apple hardware is what we all do. Why do you think we're all obsessed with rumours?

:)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.