It's looking at opposite sides of the same coin. Some enthusiasts want the automotive expertise that comes from decades of experience, and then buy-in to an EV version of that. Others may prefer the ostensibly edge-cutting efficiency of an EV and then building a decent ride with that as the lynchpin. I've owned both and I would say that Model 3/Y are high-end Honda/Acura levels of ride/build satisfaction though miles more efficient, and S/X start to approach the amenities I expect to see for the price point. Tesla definitely has the edge on efficiency and the charging network is vastly superior. However, when I open the trunk or front trunk, the metal feels as thin and easily bendable as an entry-level car, though. Mind you that's not necessarily a knock, if done well. It's par for the course if you want to get as efficient as possible. The Porsche, on the other hand, feels robust and solid. Which also makes sense given it is less efficient. The consumer just needs to pick their preference.