Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Just tried it now and it has a problem, MacRumors and MacRumors forums have to be their own…
It’s mentioned in the post.

In terms of navigation, the scope of the web app is dictated by the host of the webpage – in this case www.macrumors.com – so you can navigate anywhere within the MacRumors website, but if you click a link outside of the host page, such as the MacRumors Forums, which is separately hosted at forums.macrumors.com, this will open the linked webpage in Safari. Therefore, if you are a frequenter of both the MacRumors website and the MacRumors Forums, you should create separate web apps for each.
 
What about browser extensions, in particular adblockers, I'd be curious to know if they can somehow be enabled. But not only adblockers, other extensions have become very useful and I'd hate to lose them by using a web app. Honestly it seems kind of redundant, having a web app when you can just open up a web page.
Extensions are not supported (at least in Beta 1).

This sucks as it means I can't use extensions like Noir for dark mode websites.
 
How is this useful?. What is its value as user over a browser?. I don’t see it. I have to have a web app for every website I visit instead of having tabs in the browser?.
 
1) Is local storage permanent??
Safari (last time I checked) purges local storage for any site not visited for more than 7 days.

As a PWA developer, this is exactly what I was wondering as well. One of the primary reasons for creating a PWA is persistent storage, which is supported in Safari in iOS but has never been supported in MacOS Safari. As you say, Safari is very aggressive about deleting localStorage data after 7 days. Other major browsers don't do that (AFAIK).

What this article is describing sounds more like a "bookmark" in a special kind of window and not a "real" web app. But perhaps there's more we don't know yet.
 
Are they as useless as iOS web apps, where they can't be manually refreshed and don't retain your login to the site in question?
 
Just tried it now and it has a problem, MacRumors and MacRumors forums have to be their own seperate web apps.
As stated in the article? lol

In terms of navigation, the scope of the web app is dictated by the host of the webpage – in this case www.macrumors.com – so you can navigate anywhere within the MacRumors website, but if you click a link outside of the host page, such as the MacRumors Forums, which is separately hosted at forums.macrumors.com, this will open the linked webpage in Safari. Therefore, if you are a frequenter of both the MacRumors website and the MacRumors Forums, you should create separate web apps for each.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Apple Fan 2008
Extensions are not supported (at least in Beta 1).

This sucks as it means I can't use extensions like Noir for dark mode websites.

Hmm that just reinforces my bafflement as to why bother with a web app. Oh I'm sure there will be some increased functionality for some, but for most webpages why bother?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Populus
More clutter. Maybe just trying to incentive people to move away from Chrome because Safari on Mac is not as good.
Yeah, now instead of one icon in the dock, Safari, I'm going to have an icon for every site I usually visit? (Which is currently six that I have in one Favorite/Bookmark thing that I pull down multiple times a day and select Open in New Tabs.)
 
you can also drag the applications from the user application folder and put them in the regular application folder or another folder and they can be moved off of the dock
 
  • Like
Reactions: atonaldenim
Yeah, now instead of one icon in the dock, Safari, I'm going to have an icon for every site I usually visit? (Which is currently six that I have in one Favorite/Bookmark thing that I pull down multiple times a day and select Open in New Tabs.)
haha, experiment a little bit, you can move them off of the dock and have them act like any other application. I had the same thought, so I experimented, about 30 seconds later, I had my answer
 
  • Like
Reactions: NMBob
What about browser extensions, in particular adblockers, I'd be curious to know if they can somehow be enabled. But not only adblockers, other extensions have become very useful and I'd hate to lose them by using a web app. Honestly it seems kind of redundant, having a web app when you can just open up a web page.
Addblockers don't seem to be working in the Web Apps. :(
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't Steve Jobs against web apps which is why we have the App Store yet now web apps on Safari is introduced in WWDC 2023?

Windows and other browsers aside from Safari are able to use web apps for years now right?
 
The fact that subdomains (forums.maxrumors.com) need their own web app is not ideal. It could definitely break web apps for some sites that use subdomains for load balancing or other purposes such as login.
If your site uses login.<site_name> instead of <site_name>/login, you're doing something very wrong.
 


If a website already supports web push notifications – as MacRumors does – and you have signed up to them, you will receive web app push notifications that display the corresponding MacRumors icon, giving you more context than a standard Safari notification and icon would.
Are MacRumors push notifications available on iPadOS?
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't Steve Jobs against web apps

Sorry, you're wrong - in fact, you have it backwards!

"The full Safari engine is inside of iPhone. And so, you can write amazing Web 2.0 and Ajax apps that look exactly and behave exactly like apps on the iPhone. And these apps can integrate perfectly with iPhone services. They can make a call, they can send an email, they can look up a location on Google Maps. And guess what? There’s no SDK that you need! You’ve got everything you need if you know how to write apps using the most modern web standards to write amazing apps for the iPhone today. So developers, we think we’ve got a very sweet story for you. You can begin building your iPhone apps today."


 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.