Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MP 1,1-5,1 Hex 3.2 update from 2010 quad 2.8 photos new! CPU to use!

I applied the firmware update to my Nehalem 2009 and it shows 5,1 now.
Does this mean that I can put the Hex intel 3680 in it? Is the heatsink of my Quad 2,66 the same as the one from the Quad 2,80 (2010)?
:confused:

In the past, I did several processor upgrades with a G3. Once it went wrong, with a Powerlogix that I fried, all others were succesful. But the one mistake gives me the shivers and I won't forget it.
 
Quad Single Processor > Hex Single Processor.
no worries about "lidless" > "lidded" and head spreaders or not? :confused:
 
Last edited:
The processors are exactly the same size. A direct replacement. I (and many others) have done this with no problems whatsoever.
 
Do I understand that the processor w3680, can not be used in a dual processor board?
Thanks.
 
That is CORRECT.. Only the X series can be used in dual-qpi boards, and while an X based processor will work in the single processor board, you CANNOT use a W series in a dual based processor board.


Chumnick said:
Do I understand that the processor w3680, can not be used in a dual processor board?
Thanks.
Click to expand...
 
w3600 vs x5600

PowerPCMacMan said:
That is CORRECT.. Only the X series can be used in dual-qpi boards, and while an X based processor will work in the single processor board, you CANNOT use a W series in a dual based processor board.
Click to expand...

Does that mean that if w3600 processors are discontinued, x5600 processors can be used to upgrade old quad core macs?
 
Yes, but the X series are a tad bit more expensive as they are mainly used for dual QPI based system boards, namely the Mac Pro. While Intel might discontinue the W series, they will always be found on ebay. I got mine there and it works great.

mostafiz28 said:
Does that mean that if w3600 processors are discontinued, x5600 processors can be used to upgrade old quad core macs?
Click to expand...
 
PowerPCMacMan said:
Yes, but the X series are a tad bit more expensive as they are mainly used for dual QPI based system boards, namely the Mac Pro. While Intel might discontinue the W series, they will always be found on ebay. I got mine there and it works great.
Click to expand...

Thanks, PowerPCMacMan, I was a little worried since i have a 2012 quad core mac and planned on upgrading it to a hex core. So now i know that w3680/90 will be available and if not, i can resort to x5600 series.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Before the upgrade, I would like to replace the fan in the Processor Heatsink. Have you tried to do it? Or need to change the entire Processor Heatsink (076-1338)?
Thanks.
 
PowerPCMacMan said:
That is CORRECT.. Only the X series can be used in dual-qpi boards, and while an X based processor will work in the single processor board, you CANNOT use a W series in a dual based processor board.
Click to expand...

Yikes I almost didn't see this clarification and was going to buy 2 W3680s. So can someone advise what I need to purchase to upgrade my 2009 MP dual processor (8 core/16thread)?

I am looking for a simple installation and top speed. Price is not a huge concern.
 
IceMacMac said:
Yikes I almost didn't see this clarification and was going to buy 2 W3680s. So can someone advise what I need to purchase to upgrade my 2009 MP dual processor (8 core/16thread)?

I am looking for a simple installation and top speed. Price is not a huge concern.
Click to expand...

you have a more complicated upgrade. you have lidless cpus the upgrade is harder to do.you need nylon washers to keep the heat sink from crushing the pins in the cpu socket. look around for 2009 dual cpu upgrade on the site. also the cpus are more costly.
 
Add that plus the cost of the heatsinks from the dual 2010 Mac Pro.. I did read somewhere that there are differences in the heatsinks between the 09 and 10, Philipma1957, can you confirm this?

I think the OP should consider trying to find a 2010 Processor Board and applying the 4,1 to 5,1 firmware to the backplane of his 2009 if he hasn't already done so..

The dual upgrade path is so tedious and expensive.. Single-Quad to hexcore is more cost effective and the heatsink of the 09 is the same as the 10.

Of course in Dec 2011 I bought my 2010 boards for a total of 300.00(46 for the single processor board, 250 for the backplane). I gutted out my 09's boards and replaced with 2010's. I am not so sure how I got a good deal on those boards at the time.


philipma1957 said:
you have a more complicated upgrade. you have lidless cpus the upgrade is harder to do.you need nylon washers to keep the heat sink from crushing the pins in the cpu socket. look around for 2009 dual cpu upgrade on the site. also the cpus are more costly.
Click to expand...
 
PowerPCMacMan said:
Add that plus the cost of the heatsinks from the dual 2010 Mac Pro.. I did read somewhere that there are differences in the heatsinks between the 09 and 10, Philipma1957, can you confirm this?

I think the OP should consider trying to find a 2010 Processor Board and applying the 4,1 to 5,1 firmware to the backplane of his 2009 if he hasn't already done so..

The dual upgrade path is so tedious and expensive.. Single-Quad to hexcore is more cost effective and the heatsink of the 09 is the same as the 10.

Of course in Dec 2011 I bought my 2010 boards for a total of 300.00(46 for the single processor board, 250 for the backplane). I gutted out my 09's boards and replaced with 2010's. I am not so sure how I got a good deal on those boards at the time.
Click to expand...

been a while but anandtech has a long post on his website on how he killed a 2009 dual cpu.


the whole article

http://www.anandtech.com/show/2800/upgrading-and-analyzing-apple-s-nehalem-mac-pro

the page on what he did wrong

http://www.anandtech.com/show/2800/upgrading-and-analyzing-apple-s-nehalem-mac-pro/11


macrumors has a thread on the washers needed to prevent crushing the cpu .

I do not recall if the washers need to be 1 or 2 or 1.8 mm in height that makes up for the missing lids.


please research research research if you do a dual 2009 mac pro.
 
Yeah, I saw and read that article many times. It really does not apply to me though as I gutted my 2009 and the boards and got for 300.00 both the 2010 processor board(cost: 46.00) and the backplane board(around 250.00) - this was done at a time when suppliers did not really know how to price the boards, so it was a steal.

Installed a hex core w3680 last year and its been purring right along.. Mountain Lion flies on this thing.

But yeah, to those with Duals 2009 boards, I am thinking 1.8 mm in height, or maybe it was 1 mm. I am not certain, but if it were me I wouldn't use "LIDLESS" processors.

philipma1957 said:
been a while but anandtech has a long post on his website on how he killed a 2009 dual cpu.


the whole article

http://www.anandtech.com/show/2800/upgrading-and-analyzing-apple-s-nehalem-mac-pro

the page on what he did wrong

http://www.anandtech.com/show/2800/upgrading-and-analyzing-apple-s-nehalem-mac-pro/11


macrumors has a thread on the washers needed to prevent crushing the cpu .

I do not recall if the washers need to be 1 or 2 or 1.8 mm in height that makes up for the missing lids.


please research research research if you do a dual 2009 mac pro.
Click to expand...
 
I am still confused about the W3680 Intel Westmere 3,33 6 cores upgrade for my Mac Pro 2009 Quad-Core Nehalem which I have flashed to a 5,1.
I read that some users at the Apple Forums report much higher temperatures of the upgraded processor. (70°C = 158°F) Can someone confirm or deny this?
Perhaps it's because they applied to less thermal paste, or to many, or another reason
TIA
 
Last edited:
Mac Hammer Fan said:
I am still confused about the W3680 Intel Westmere 3,33 6 cores upgrade for my Mac Pro 2009 Quad-Core Nehalem which I have flashed to a 5,1.
I read that some users at the Apple Forums report much higher temperatures of the upgraded processor. Can someone confirm or deny this?
Click to expand...

I've seen no abnormal temperatures related to my upgrade.

Perhaps it's because they applied to less thermal paste, or to many, or another reason
TIA
Click to expand...

Poorly applied thermal paste is the most likely explanation.
 
I didn't want to double post, but by recommendation if another member I just wanted to see if anyone following this thread has experience/ideas around diagnosing an issue that I'm having:

Upgraded my 2009 2.66 quad to a w3690. The firmware upgrade went smoothly. But, I can't boot. Tried a bunch of random things, but in the current state, it hangs at the apple logo screen...forever. In verbose mode, it hangs consistently after it loads the kernel cache (the final printed line being "root device uuid is '.....' ". I can't get into single user mode for the same reason.

Thread is here: https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=17072227

Any thoughts? Would like to determine for sure that it is not software/firmware (the behavior did change when I changed OSes; with snow leopard, it would kernel panic on boot screen. With mountain lion, it simply hangs on boot screen)

EDIT 4/5/2013: PROBLEM SOLVED! It was just a faulty processor. Got a replacement and put that one in...no issues. I think the fact that I could not get a Win7 install to fully boot without getting a BSOD with the same machine check error codes I was getting on the mac side was a dead giveaway that it was the hardware.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back