Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPad How good is the Smart Case for iPad Air 2?
- Thread starter Bromio
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The Air is 7.5mm thick. The Air 2 is 6.1mm thick. A difference of 1.4mm is quite significant. So why produce a case that completely negates this?
Have you worked with leather? It's not really practical to make thickness of leather exact to that degree.
Comparing the Air1 and Air2 in their cases side by side, I'd say you can tell a difference in thickness if you squint. That's exactly what I expected, and that's what we got. Those of you who expected something else, IMO, you are being unrealistic.
1.4 mm is less than the thickness of a US cent coin. Seems to me that's about the difference I see in Zeos' picture above. I don't find the case bulky at all, and have zero problems pressing the home button. It's a very nice and well-fitting case IMO. If the leather was paper-thin it wouldn't provide any protection either.
As I said earlier, I believe it is because Apple wanted more "lip" so the cover would close more securely. It definitely does that.
Can you take an up close shot of the edges in the case specifically the bottom area near the TouchID?
Thanks
The Smart Case is junk in my opinion. It has fitment issues with the big lip which extends past he iPad screen and makes it awkward to use the TouchID. Also the folding cover does not stay closed well when cover is folded back. It also defeats the purpose of the reduced thickness of the Air 2 since it makes it the same as the Original Air. For $80 I expect a lot more then a case which Apple barely redesigned for the Air 2 and probably costs less then $5 to manufacture. Many cheap Amazon and eBay cases will have much better fitment. I returned mine - and my Air 2 but for different reasons.
Thanks for the picture! I've been holding out on getting the case because I wasn't sure if Apple actually adjusted the thickness. I remember when I bought the polyurethane Smart Case for iPad 3, the fit was absolutely horrible. The iPad was too loose inside the case and wouldn't often pop out in the corners. Glad to see Apple actually took into account the reduction in thickness. I was afraid it was going to have the EXACT same dimensions and result in a loose fit.
Me neither. And the depth of the lip is same as it was with the iPad Air 1 and its case. It's not like the lip goes higher on the Air 2 case.
Me neither and I wouldn't want a paper thin leather case. It would feel cheap in comparison. If thinness meant everything to me, I would just go without a case or get a cover.
Honestly for me the smart case for the air 2 feels fantastic. The one for my rMini... The magnets feel looser and I've had it fall within a month of usage. My Air 2s case is extremely sturdy in comparison. The only thing that bothers me is the gap in the headphone jack hole that allows light to pass through. It makes my OCD go a bit crazy.
Me neither. Where is this gap supposed to be? In the iPad's case? I see no light coming out anywere (except the display 
).
).
I'm going to eat some humble pie here. I just bought the midnight blue smart case just to see what it was like. And, you know, it's bloody nice. The lip isn't actually as bad as had been described. I can acknowledge the point that the screen cover fits better and more firmly. As to making it harder to use Touch ID, that's BS unless you use your cats paws to authenticate. Well pleased. So, I was wrong.
I just broke down and bought the Air II black Smart Case at Best Buy ... I should point out that you really need to look at the little label on the back of the box. Do MAKE CERTAIN that the little tag says *iPad Air (Second Generation),* because it’s not marked that way on the main section of the box at all! And BB had them all mixed together with last year’s thicker models! So do be careful, or you might pick up a more chunky version from theAir I. My new black Smart Case is considerably more thin than the first release with the Air I, and my cut-outs are perfect, no problem with the home button, and the lip is not too high for me! It’s pretty sweet overall. A little tip from last year ... I also waterproofed the leather case from last year with Cadillac Leather Shoe Shield spray when I first got it, and there was little to no wear, or color loss, last time around!
I had the Air 1 case and disliked it, partly because the long sides of the case were too easy to flex and bend away from the iPad while holding it. Are the sides of the Air 2 case any stiffer or sturdier, or do they flex as well? I might decide to shell out $80 for the Air 2 case if that problem is fixed. Any info will be appreciated.
So the new cases are in fact thinner for the Air 2? Some people are saying that it's the same thickness which makes it a lot recessed.
Looks like they are 2 different versions.
Looks like they are 2 different versions.
Last edited:
Yes, it is thinner, but not by much, so I can kind of see why someone might think they are the same thickness.
It is indeed thinner. Just make sure to look at the little tag on the back -- confirm that it says: Air (Second Generation)!
How good is the Smart Case for iPad Air 2?
It's on the top side of the headphone jack. I assume it's because the iPad sits so far in.
Me neither. Where is this gap supposed to be? In the iPad's case? I see no light coming out anywere (except the display
It's on the top side of the headphone jack. I assume it's because the iPad sits so far in.
Thanks for the pics. Indeed, I have that too. About the size of a pin prick. Never noticed it before.