I owned both the 9.7 and the 12.9. For me the 9.7 was too small and the 12.9 too large. I think the 10.5 is the perfect size for me.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
If you have a 9.7" iPad and want a bigger screen... PLEASE try the 10.5 before going 12.9!
- Thread starter karlwig
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
That plus the doubling of RAM is what convinced me to buy one, and I'm not regretting it one bit so far. This iPad is amazing.
Meh I have a Note Pro 12.2 and it is heaver than the Ipad 12.9 so is my SP4 and I carry either one of those every day with me to work with my tank of a laptop. I've seen the 12.9 in person and I own the 10.5. The 10.5 is nice, but I just like large screens for reading magazines and comics. The 10.5 is going back and the 12.9 will be here on Monday.
Heavy is relative.
Heavy is relative.
+1
Further to your point, I think that Apple will significantly alter iPads after iOS 11.
With the new launch bar and multitasking/control center, who needs to go to the home screen ? That topped by keyboard use and Siri always on should eliminate the need for a physical home button (aka iPhone 8/X/edition).
I'm all about the 12.9" iPad but it wasn't a small increase in screen size going to the 10.5" screen. People are too hung up on .8" when they should be concerned about screen area. The 10.5" model added 17% of visual real estate over the 9.7".
I do say the one downside with the 10.5 so far is that I am getting more spurious touches trying to hold the thing than I did with the 9.7". The smaller bezels are not always a plus, unfortunately. It's still fine, but there are some types of grips that work with the 9.7" and 12.9" that don't work with the 10.5" at all.
I think those people who didn't see any difference in screen size between 10.5 and 9.7 absolutely needs Eye glasses. Especially even for the Physical Size. The 10.5" iPad is actually HALF INCH TALLER it's more noticeable than iPhone 4S to iPhone 5. If you are one of them might as well get your eyes checked and is telling you need some grasses
I owned two 9.7” iPads in my life and I never really used them. First it was the 1st generation iPad and even though I was super excited about the idea of ultra portable computing, everything felt too cramped and I ended up jumping either to my iPhone or my 15” MacBook. Then I got the first iPad Air thinking that maybe they fixed up a few things after many generations of iPads and nothing, it stayed in my night stand’s drawer for almost three years until I sold it.
Then I got the new 12.9” iPad Pro and I think I’ve used it in the past weeks as much as I used the iPad Air in half a year. I’m really happy with it and I don’t think 10.5” would have been enough to make a difference. Firstly because I find the 10.5” smart Keyboard cramped while the 12.9” one is just as big as my laptops’s.
Portability? Well, it doesn’t fit in my pocket so if I will be carrying a bag I don’t mind it being slightly bigger. Holding it in your hand is definitely more uncomfortable but I didn’t find holding my 9.7” iPad comfortable either.
Also the price diference is negligible, I traded 4G conectivity for the extra size and I don’t regret it at all. iOS’s easy way to activate the hotspot functionality of your phone from the settings of your iPad makes it a no brainer to give up an extra data plan and saving 100$.
Then I got the new 12.9” iPad Pro and I think I’ve used it in the past weeks as much as I used the iPad Air in half a year. I’m really happy with it and I don’t think 10.5” would have been enough to make a difference. Firstly because I find the 10.5” smart Keyboard cramped while the 12.9” one is just as big as my laptops’s.
Portability? Well, it doesn’t fit in my pocket so if I will be carrying a bag I don’t mind it being slightly bigger. Holding it in your hand is definitely more uncomfortable but I didn’t find holding my 9.7” iPad comfortable either.
Also the price diference is negligible, I traded 4G conectivity for the extra size and I don’t regret it at all. iOS’s easy way to activate the hotspot functionality of your phone from the settings of your iPad makes it a no brainer to give up an extra data plan and saving 100$.
There is no significant size increase between the 9.7 and 10.5. If 1 inch is that noticeable to you, that's great. Otherwise it truly is not significant say like going from the 9.7 to the 12.9. My eyes are just fine
Went from a 9.7 to a 12.9 and I love it. For my work (annotating/pdfs) it's so much better. Tried the 10.5 in the store and it didn't seem that much bigger. Don't regret having the larger iPad at all. But hey, totally get that some people don't like the larger size.
Agreed, it feels a lot bigger. I went with the 12.9" though but do wish it had the split keyboard at times...why did they take it away? Only complaint.
[doublepost=1508859534][/doublepost]Edit, you can use split keyboard on the Pro in zoomed mode:
https://www.cio.com/article/3042242/ios/ipad-pro-how-to-use-the-split-keyboard-in-ios.html
Going to try it later today.
[doublepost=1508859534][/doublepost]Edit, you can use split keyboard on the Pro in zoomed mode:
https://www.cio.com/article/3042242/ios/ipad-pro-how-to-use-the-split-keyboard-in-ios.html
Going to try it later today.
I'd say its halfway between just wanting to be helpful to others facing a similar purchase decision, and seeking affirmation for their own choice.
Based on the replies, its still probably more subjective than anything how much of a difference people will perceive. Simultaneously I can agree I'd have probably gone for the 10.5 if it'd been an option when I got my 9.7, but I've also tried it out in the store, and even after owning a 9.7" tablet since 2012, I can't immediately tell if I'm picking up a 9.7 or 10.5 model until I scroll and see promotion.
Promotion is a bigger display draw than the real estate in my case, but I have no faith in apple to deliver any sustained value on that front, as they've already pushed unoptimized updates that make single generation old hardware struggle to deliver remotely smooth UI. My iPad Pro 9.7" is struggling with responsiveness and performance issues that are reminiscent of the incredibly disappointing iPad 3rd gen. I can only imagine how disappointing it would be to have one of the tentpole features be "smooth ui" and have it undermined when they can't be bothered to maintain it after next year's update.
First of all she does not CARE she is just WORRIED about the future consumer that wants to upgrade their 9.7" iPad to the iPad Pro 12.9 because its Too Big. It is called SUGGESTING a 10.5 " iPad product to avoid Size Adjustment Shock. Again, She don't care she's just WORRIED.
If you have a 9.7" iPad and want a bigger screen... PLEASE try the 12.9 before going 10.5!
I doesn't care I am just WORRIED.
It’s all personal.
I have all four sizes and, from my point-of-view, the 10.5 just is NOT a significant increase and isn’t even noticeable over the 9.7. In fact, if the 10.5 wasn’t a work device, I probably would not have purchased one to replace my 9.7.
[doublepost=1508940159][/doublepost]
I agree. Both are excellent machines, it just comes down to your needs.
I have all four sizes and, from my point-of-view, the 10.5 just is NOT a significant increase and isn’t even noticeable over the 9.7. In fact, if the 10.5 wasn’t a work device, I probably would not have purchased one to replace my 9.7.
[doublepost=1508940159][/doublepost]
I agree. Both are excellent machines, it just comes down to your needs.
i just got my 512gb 12.9 yesterday, my god the sound and screen are great, comics and mags look fantastic, HDR on the video pops I'll be keep my 9.7 2017 ipad for out and about, but i'll be using the 12.9 anytime else its fantastic
Recently I upgraded from Air 2 to the iPad Pro 10.5. As much as I like the big screen of the 12.9, I didn’t like the weight and it wasn’t as easily portable as the 10.5. I wish the next iteration of 10.5 will maintain the overall size and weight, but have a larger screen with slimmer bezels and without a home button (just like iPhone X).