Totally get what you’re saying, but I’ll add three counter arguments:
- The Mini doesn’t have a perfect comp in the Mac lineup. That said, it’s closer overall to the MacBook Air, which has been panned for the 60hz screen and for throttling due to it being fanless. For lots of people, those are non-issues, just like the gripes about the Mini.
- If MacBooks were only being updated every 3-4 years, those said updates would be more heavily scrutinized, again like the Mini. It’s not that the incremental update is bad, it just doesn’t feel like nearly enough to last in the market until the end of 2027.
- Apple gives only one choice in this size, take it or leave it. Nearly any other Apple product, you can spend to the high heavens to get the latest and greatest if you want to. Referencing back to #1, if Apple only sold the Air lineup and had no Pro models, you better believe those reviews would be ripping Apple apart.
So as you said, for what it is, it’s great for most people. It could just be a lot more in very obvious ways.