Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Did Apple go far enough with $29 battery replacements?


  • Total voters
    134
Status
Not open for further replies.
I had decided about 2 weeks ago to purchase a quality 3rd party battery for my iPhone 6. But since I'm a procrastinator, I hadn't actually ordered it. Until yesterday morning. Of course, Amazon and the vendor were all over that and shipped it this morning.

It'll be more trouble to try to cancel or send it back.

So I'll probably go to the Apple Store to get an official replacement for $30. And I'll have an extra battery sitting on a shelf for when the battery needs to be replaced again.

Man, if only I had procrastinated a few days longer.

Maybe apple can make an update to check to see if the power resource can consistently draw a specific amount of power instead of checking the health of the battery that way you could use a battery pack or just leave your phone plugged in if you'd rather not get your battery swapped out.
 
Does it apply to 5s?
No
[doublepost=1514506100][/doublepost]
Maybe apple can make an update to check to see if the power resource can consistently draw a specific amount of power instead of checking the health of the battery that way you could use a battery pack or just leave your phone plugged in if you'd rather not get your battery swapped out.
Nah, I want a new battery. I can't stand battery cases or plugs
 
  • Like
Reactions: fitcious
Is that a fact?

At the risk of sounding like a complete apple fanboy, I think other phone brands just aren't under a microscope or have the expectations apple has but also are in the same situation.

You think Samsung isn't under a microscope with regards to battery issues? It's been a few days now since news of throttlegate, I'm sure some Apple super fan would have found evidence of other brands having sudden shutdowns with old batteries if it existed
 
  • Like
Reactions: dk001 and eyoungren
You think Samsung isn't under a microscope with regards to battery issues? It's been a few days now since news of throttlegate, I'm sure some Apple super fan would have found evidence of other brands having sudden shutdowns with old batteries if it existed

I honestly was under the impression that the older an android phone gets it generally gets buggier and a poor user experience. This is based on comments from anti iphone/android users I'm around.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eitherone
Isn't throttling to prolong the stability of your phone, at the cost of speed, a solution to the battery issue that all phones suffer from?

Or are you suggesting they throttle iphone out of the box so it requires less from the CPU from the beginning? You won't have to throttle when the battery degrades if it's already throttled the moment you get it.
All I am suggesting is that Apple should have been up front about it.

Throttling your CPU is not what people think when someone says "We fixed the battery issues".
[doublepost=1514506882][/doublepost]
What would you rather your phone shuts down when your battery can’t handle it or you your phone being throttled?
I would prefer to know what their proposed solution was to begin with so I could make a choice.

Not find out afterwards that throttling the CPU was the choice they made for me.
 
That is not that point. They should have TOLD us about the issue. Hiding it makes them look guilty. The throttling was done to drive sales.

Stop it. The biggest company in the world doesn't need deceptive practices to be successful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: artfossil
It fixes nothing—I bought a new iphone ONLY because I thought that my iphone 6 was dead. Had they been upfront about the updates' relation to battery performance I would have known that all I needed was an $80 battery change instead of buying a new phone! It's not like they will reimburse me $600 price difference. Apple is shady.
 
It fixes nothing—I bought a new iphone ONLY because I thought that my iphone 6 was dead. Had they been upfront about the updates' relation to battery performance I would have known that all I needed was an $80 battery change instead of buying a new phone! It's not like they will reimburse me $600 price difference. Apple is shady.

That definitely sucks.

Question, if you were able to get a full refund for your phone would you go back to your 6 and just upgrade the battery? Would you have to think about it?
 
I feel sorry for the independent phone repair guys. There goes half their business if not more.
Is apple going to replace it at that price IF they test the battery and they state that its not below 80%? Independent repair guy will replace no matter what
 
Yet they do it anyway.

No, they don’t. That’s the point you’re missing.

Conspiracy theories work when discussing small to medium companies in desperate trouble. Not the world’s biggest company that is healthy as can be. None of the top executives at Apple would risk doing hard time in a federal prison for the type of crime you are accusing them of.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arran and artfossil
No, they don’t. That’s the point you’re missing.

Conspiracy theories work when discussing small to medium companies in desperate trouble. Not the world’s biggest company that is healthy as can be. None of the top executives at Apple would risk doing hard time in a federal prison for the type of crime you are accusing them of.
If there is nothing there as you suggest, why has any lawsuit against Apple proceeeded at all?

Maybe their shadiness does not rise to a penalty of incarceration but it certainly rises to levels of justified financial compensation.

It's not shady unless it puts someone in jail?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Geert76
It fixes nothing—I bought a new iphone ONLY because I thought that my iphone 6 was dead. Had they been upfront about the updates' relation to battery performance I would have known that all I needed was an $80 battery change instead of buying a new phone! It's not like they will reimburse me $600 price difference. Apple is shady.

First, if you walk into an Apple Store tomorrow I am positive they will reimburse you for the phone you bought under these circumstances that apparently confused you, get you back in an iPhone 6 by lunchtime.

Second, I have no idea why you think a tiny battery for a product used heavily every day and charged multiple times per day would last you more than two years before losing capability. There are thousands of mall kiosks across the country providing battery replacement services for millions of people each month. You didn’t notice?
 
I feel sorry for the independent phone repair guys. There goes half their business if not more.

Apple gets its way again. Putting 3rd party repair shops out of business was always a goal.
[doublepost=1514511092][/doublepost]
That definitely sucks.

Question, if you were able to get a full refund for your phone would you go back to your 6 and just upgrade the battery? Would you have to think about it?

Not that simple. Gotta go through the backup and restore process which for some could take forever. Quite a hassle.
 
Not that simple. Gotta go through the backup and restore process which for some could take forever. Quite a hassle.

umm it's maybe 3 hours max and that's if something goes wrong. People do it all the time.

Wait is this a serious comment?
 
If there is nothing there as you suggest, why has any lawsuit against Apple proceeeded at all?

Frivolous class-action lawsuits get filed every day, my company got hit with six of them a year for absolutely no reason other than to extort a quick settlement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.