Maybe the solution would be to bifurcate the OS - adding the option to select "Simple" or "Advanced" at setup?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is iOS becoming too complicated?
- Thread starter MartyCan
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It's an interesting question. One of the reasons that upgrading to the 6S isn't appealing to me is that I'm pretty sure I wouldn't really use the 3D touch feature.
At which point someone who thinks they are good with iOS picks Advanced, realises they arent as good as they think and then cant find the option to turn it back to Simple!
[QUOTE="leon44, post: 22053449, member: 445481"
In its current implementation I just know 12 months down the line people are going to tell me that 3D Touch is 'pointless', because they never use it. If Apple can find a way of encouraging people to us it it will take off.
What frustrates me is that I can see this coming. Maybe I'm wrong, I hope I am.[/QUOTE]
That is what "concerns" me most. I have yet to find a decent use for 3D Touch however I do see the potential it has. What is missing is something telling me that this app/function has a 3D Touch usable feature. By the time something I find routinely useful rolls out, 3D Touch will have been back-burnered like a lot of the gestures.
OSOM
In its current implementation I just know 12 months down the line people are going to tell me that 3D Touch is 'pointless', because they never use it. If Apple can find a way of encouraging people to us it it will take off.
What frustrates me is that I can see this coming. Maybe I'm wrong, I hope I am.[/QUOTE]
That is what "concerns" me most. I have yet to find a decent use for 3D Touch however I do see the potential it has. What is missing is something telling me that this app/function has a 3D Touch usable feature. By the time something I find routinely useful rolls out, 3D Touch will have been back-burnered like a lot of the gestures.
OSOM
What visual clues are you discussing? I've been with iOS since iOS 5 and no version has been intuitive and iOS 6 was pinnacle of skeuomorphism gone wild.
In a sense that's already there just by its nature--people who don't know about different things will use the phone as they know it in a "simple" way, while those who do know about additional features and settings will use those as they see fit in an "advanced" manner. The point is that it's all usable either way.
Considering two-thirds of my family/friends/peers don't use iOS devices, we have found alternatives to Facetime.
and other things too
A huge percentage of our friends/family/associates use iPhones and/or have an iPad. We make heavy use of FaceTime, iMessage and iCloud photo sharing without having to install third party apps to do what is built into iOS.Considering two-thirds of my family/friends/peers don't use iOS devices, we have found alternatives to Facetime.
and other things too
Personally I might like the concept however I feel I would seriously dislike the solution.
We seem to live in an age of "opt out" instead of "opt in". What would "Simple" opt me into that I don't know about? Or know to know about?
Last edited:
I have just gotten my grubby little mitts on an iPhone 13. What a device!!!!!!!!
I can pull menus from all four sides, all four corners, I have 49 gesture options, straight gestures, curved gestures, pocket gestures, sit my ass on my device gestures, I can light touch, moderate touch, heavy touch, touch with multiple fingers with varying degrees of pressure, I can speak, bark, whistle, shake, turn, spin, and do all of these things allowing my iPhone to do different things!!!! And that is before I even go into an App!!!! It comes with a free, yes FREE (via postal mail) users guide (reminds me of the old phone book) and a special enhanced 1.2GB digital edition via iBooks!
Man!! I love this device!!!!
/s
I can pull menus from all four sides, all four corners, I have 49 gesture options, straight gestures, curved gestures, pocket gestures, sit my ass on my device gestures, I can light touch, moderate touch, heavy touch, touch with multiple fingers with varying degrees of pressure, I can speak, bark, whistle, shake, turn, spin, and do all of these things allowing my iPhone to do different things!!!! And that is before I even go into an App!!!! It comes with a free, yes FREE (via postal mail) users guide (reminds me of the old phone book) and a special enhanced 1.2GB digital edition via iBooks!
Man!! I love this device!!!!
/s
Last edited:
A huge percentage of our friends/family/associates use iPhones and/or have an iPad. We make heavy use of FaceTime, iMessage and iCloud photo sharing without having to install third party apps to do what is built into iOS.
Facetime was one feature I was hoping that Apple would allow on other platforms.
It's not about skeuomorphism other than buttons which you can enable in iOS 9. Take Messages for example, managing them in iOS 6 was a no brainer.
iOS 6: Looking at a conversation you had an Edit button. Press it and you had more buttons with appropriate colors (Clear All, Cancel, Delete, Forward - Red on scary buttons and green on good buttons). No thinking required.
iOS 9: In iOS 9 you have, well, messages. What to do? Tap it? Nothing. Tap and hold? Works if you hit the message but if you are off by a few pixels then nothing happens, but... If the message has a link vs and address vs just text it behaves differently for each tap and hold. It's a mess try and figure out what to do. Try to forward a message that is nothing but a link: Good luck!
Anyway, I consider this less intuitive. Others may not agree with me.
Actually I'd prefer the recent apps/contacts be in the notification center so you can access it from anywhere.
I think iOS is starting to get a little complicated. Not a big deal for me and I love getting new features that are useful, but when I have to Google to figure out how to do picture in picture on iOS 9, that's pretty telling.
personally, i think the more iOS tries to be like android the more complex it gets.
There is no way you can honestly believe that cars electronics are simpler to use over time. It is just like every other piece of technology, it appears simpler to use because you have the added benefit of compounded knowledge. To really test you have to take 2 non-tech people, and introduce them to the 2 pieces of tech at the same time. See which takes longer to get a full grasp of all available features. For example, my father has 2 Mercedes, a 1986 500sel and a 2005 S500. My parents are 73 years old. Which do you think is easier for them to use? Which would take longer to learn all available features from scratch? There was a long period of time, they were using their portable GPS, when the S500 had a fully integrated GPS.
Having the benefit of previous versions, makes things seem easier, but in reality, you have had an incremental learning over a long period of time, which makes new versions seem simpler. But if you were starting from scratch, you have to learn all the old tech in the new product PLUS the new tech.
Is iOS becoming too complicated?
Yes.
Finding the prefs you want in settings is a real crapshoot.
There are so many now that the list of categories, followed by subcategories, followed by God only knows how many more levels of subcategories is simply to clunky to comprehend.
Apple needs to research a better way of doing it. Then implement the results of that research.
Clunky as they are, even my Android devices are not as Byzantine in the settings department as Apple devices.
Yes.
Finding the prefs you want in settings is a real crapshoot.
There are so many now that the list of categories, followed by subcategories, followed by God only knows how many more levels of subcategories is simply to clunky to comprehend.
Apple needs to research a better way of doing it. Then implement the results of that research.
Clunky as they are, even my Android devices are not as Byzantine in the settings department as Apple devices.
It is frustrating that most of the 3D Touch features are 'hidden'. It seems to take someone messing around to stumble upon a new way of using it.
Last edited:
That is what "concerns" me most. I have yet to find a decent use for 3D Touch however I do see the potential it has. What is missing is something telling me that this app/function has a 3D Touch usable feature. By the time something I find routinely useful rolls out, 3D Touch will have been back-burnered like a lot of the gestures.
OSOM
It is frustrating that most of the 3D Touch features are 'hidden'. It seems to take someone messing around to stumble upon a new way of using it.[/QUOTE]
With limited screen real estate on an iPhone and no right click, a lot of the interface is hidden. Long press, short press, hard press, soft press, multi-gesture. This applies to other phone manufacturers as well. As an example look at the convoluted way all mail is deleted. (I don't know if that is iOS or lack of a keyboard) but 3D Touch is here to stay. I'm sure Apple has a roadmap for the technology.
What's so hard about figuring out 3D Touch?
3D Touch the app icon. If it does something then it will inside the app as well. If the haptic just double taps you, then the app doesn't support it inside or out. Reading update notes for apps would also tell you if you can use it or not as well.
Are people too busy to explore and figure things out on their own now? Does everything need to be told to you?
Pressing the homescreen icons and being able to select, for instance, 'video' or 'selfie' with the camera app is easy but the quick app switch feature and pressing the keyboard to move the cursor, who would have known about those unless someone else stumbled upon it?