Criticism mentioned seems valid to me:
Too expensive - Subjective, its no more expensive than the SE was when launched for the same storage size.
No MagSafe - SE never had it, most won't use it, even more so if they never had it previously.
Very average camera quality - Plenty of proof on this forum that the quality is excellent.
No ultra-wide angle - The least used lens on any phone and even on the 15 it should have been a telephoto zoom rather than a wide angle lens, I have never bothered with it myself however you can use the panoramic function to overcome this if really needed.
No UWB chip - How often is this used in daily usage? Rarely.
USB 2 without display output - No one buying this device needs anything more.
Apple Intellige nce (beta) still mediocre - Same AI as any iPhone 16 or 15 Pro model, anything older isn't going to get anything.
Average outdoor brightness - Plenty bright enough to use even in sunlight.
You cannot complain about price, and want the same features as a more expensive device for less money?!
That site may well be well known in the french speaking world, that's not a world the majority on this forum live in, hence it's not called Macrumeurs.