Sorry for an old thread revival, but I got a carried away upgrading a whole load of Mac mini 1,1 / 2,1 with a variety of socket M CPU (some not on the OP list), so thought Id put my findings here for anyone else to use. As well as testing out which non OEM fitted CPU would work, I also did a bit of benchmarking.
Non OEM CPU installed:
C2D: T7400, T7600
CD: T2300E, T2250, T2450
Celeron: 410, 440, 520, 530
Pentium Dual Core: T2080, T2130
All worked other than the Celeron 5*0 CPU.
I used Xbench 1.3 and Geekbench 2.2.7 on a fresh install of SL 10.6.8. 2GB RAM, 128GB SSD and included the OEM fit CPU data also so you can see how they compare.
XBench:
Geekbench:
Observations:
Core Duo and Pentium DC perform better in Geekbench than they do Xbench.
Celeron 5*0 CPU wouldn't boot. (I tried a 520 and 530). If buying 5*0 be cautious, most are Socket P.
2,1 firmware is not required to run C2D CPU, all CPU worked regardless of 1,1 or 2,1 firmware. (2,1 allows 4GB mem).
Pentium DC are reported as Core Duo in system profiler. CPU-X and bench sw does a better job of recognising CPU.
Celeron's are reported as Core Solo in system profiler. CPU-X and bench sw does a better job of recognising CPU
One of the Celeron 440 used reports as running at 2.13ghz in Sys Profiler.
On 533FSB CPU, you could use PC2-4200 Ram, but the fitted PC2-5300 667 ram was fine.
Data:
Album link with screenshots of each CPU working
Thanks to all the previous posters; I had to refer to this thread a couple of times when I was getting a list of CPU to try.