Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
MBA screen quality
- Thread starter tim100
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
any one have any comments on the macbook air 13 inch versus the macbook pro 15 inch screen, as far as quality, real estate, which you would prefer, etc..
Anandtech's review has a comparison with, like, you know, data n' stuff
http://www.anandtech.com/show/3991/apples-2010-macbook-air-11-13inch-reviewed/5
Unfortunately without data on which display models their MBA's had!
To me, contrast and black/white levels are the most important and the thing most noticeable to casual viewers. Color gamut, on the other hand, is imperceptible to an untrained eye and only noticeable when viewing colorful images.
Out of all the MacBooks, the new 13" MBA has the highest contrast and the lowest black level.
I disagree. The MacBook Air (both first and second generation) has a far more superior screen than the white MacBook, to the point where it's not even comparable.
Open Display Preferences. Click on Color, highlight the top Display Profile, Color LCD, and click Open Profile. Scroll to the last item on the list, Apple display make and model information. Look at the information displayed below the list and you will see the model number of your display.
You can not generalize this unless you have looked at all different displays used in the new Air's. For example, 9CF0 and 9CDF in the 13.3" seem to be very different. Also, we don't know and will never know which one Anandtech tested, as their review is incomplete in this regard. The black level on my 9CF0 is not very good, definitely not as good as my 2009 17" MBP.
I have the 9CF0 model, and it's much better than my 15" MacBook Pro. Easily comparable (in quality, not resolution obviously) to an ASUS 24" and an HP 24" monitor, both of which are high dollar high contrast monitors hooked up to my Mac Pro with a Radeon HD4870 (1GB VRAM) card. Nothing like "looking through a thick fog"
What screen do you have? Where did you buy your MBA?
Thanks!
I have a 9CF2 in my 11"... I got it exchanged from the Apple Store
hmm good question, today i made a comparison video on boot up time and i saw both screens of my 2010 mbp and 2010 mba, i for one didnt notice any difference. They both look beautiful in my opinion.
Is it too much to ask to go back three posts in the thread before posting a question that has already been answered?
In an attempt to dispel the notion that too many posters would rather criticize than answer a simple question with a simple answer let me answer yours: See Post #33.
Sorry, but putting MBA's display in front of any MBP AntiGlare, especially 15" HR/AG is straight up laughable.
How is the terrible contrast on MBA working for ya so far? Seriously, and be honest, of course if you've ever seen HR/AG MBP before.
How is the terrible contrast on MBA working for ya so far? Seriously, and be honest, of course if you've ever seen HR/AG MBP before.
Yes, it's too much to ask.
I did look for the answer prior to posting, and I somehow missed it. I guess I was skimming too fast. I beg your forgiveness. After I posted my question, I saw the answer and I tried to delete my post unsuccessfully. I really do try to be careful with my questions, but there's always someone ready to pounce if you mess up.
Last edited:
Yes, it's too much to ask.
I did look for the answer prior to posting, and I somehow missed it. I guess I was skimming too fast. I beg your forgiveness. After I posted my question, I saw the answer and I tried to delete my post unsuccessfully. I really do try to be careful with my questions, but there's always someone ready to pounce if you mess up.
I apologize for coming across bitchy...
Did it work out for you, i.e. did you get the information you wanted (hope I didn't miss your post telling us your model...
)
Compared to my RevB 13/3" Air with 1200x800 screen, my 11.6 is just plain amazing. Very, very crisp. I write on it for hours at a time and I truly love it.
Admittedly, I don't do much of anything with photos other than change my desktop every couple days, but when I do it looks very crisp and nice!
So compared to my old Air and most any PC laptop I have worked on...
11.6 Screen is best so far!
Admittedly, I don't do much of anything with photos other than change my desktop every couple days, but when I do it looks very crisp and nice!
So compared to my old Air and most any PC laptop I have worked on...
11.6 Screen is best so far!
The PPI on MBA is looking gorgeous, but I believe the panel on MBP glossy is still superior. For some reason MBA's contrast doesn't impress me at all. Everything looks a bit dimmer and not nearly as color rich as MBPs glossy. It is definitely a different panel, coating, as well as the process of putting the display together.
I detest all of the MBP's glass covered displays because they all have horrible reflection problems. Although the MBAs are not as immune to reflection difficulties as the premium matte screens, they are far better in this regard than any glass covered display I have used, especially my iPad's, whose reflections make me crazy.
The semi glossy coating that's been applied on MBA's could be the reason why they look a bit dimmer and lower in contrast than MBP's. I catch myself pressing brightness button on the keyboard all the time when on MBA.