I have seen no indication that either the antireflective coating on the MBAs' screens or the matte screens on MBPs have any negative impact on brightness and contrast. I have seen the claim that glass covered glossy screens somehow have better brightness and contrast but I haven't seen it. Part of that is no doubt owed to my admitted hostility toward the highly reflective nature of glass covered displays. If a display with an antireflective coating does have slightly reduced brightness and contrast, it seems to me that it is a small price to pay to avoid the highly distracting reflections caused by all glass covered displays.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
MBA screen quality
- Thread starter tim100
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
funny. I took my air in to the apple store today. End of story... im getting a new replacement since my 13" had 3 pressure points on the screen. Hopefully i can get a speed bump or ssd bump for my problem.
supposedly i was the first one to bring in a new air at my apple store.
supposedly i was the first one to bring in a new air at my apple store.
I come from a 13" MBP last gen and now have the 13" MBA.
Displays are really close !
I'd say MBP's just a little better, I mean, more comfortable in terms of contrast / brightness... But the MBA's black is a little darker. It's really no big deal...
Btw, this profile made my MBA's screen look much better : http://att.macrumors.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=258155&d=1288551402
Displays are really close !
I'd say MBP's just a little better, I mean, more comfortable in terms of contrast / brightness... But the MBA's black is a little darker. It's really no big deal...
Btw, this profile made my MBA's screen look much better : http://att.macrumors.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=258155&d=1288551402
Yes, it's too much to ask.
I did look for the answer prior to posting, and I somehow missed it. I guess I was skimming too fast. I beg your forgiveness. After I posted my question, I saw the answer and I tried to delete my post unsuccessfully. I really do try to be careful with my questions, but there's always someone ready to pounce if you mess up.
But it is also nice to know (have read) that there is at least one nice person who simply gave you the answer without the insult.
(thanks to gwsat!)
You are welcome! I decided a long tome ago to do what I could to help the recipient of a gratuitous "Gotcha!" post take the sting out of it. In fairness to the "Gotcha!" poster, I should remind everybody that once he saw he had offended Pipper99, he posted a gracious apology. Thus, all's well that ends well, so we are all once again one big happy family.But it is also nice to know (have read) that there is at least one nice person who simply gave you the answer without the insult.
(thanks to gwsat!)
You are welcome! I decided a long tome ago to do what I could to help the recipient of a gratuitous "Gotcha!" post take the sting out of it. In fairness to the "Gotcha!" poster, I should remind everybody that once he saw he had offended Pipper99, he posted a gracious apology. Thus, all's well that ends well, so we are all once again one big happy family.
I saw the apology and I thought that was great!
We have one white MB and it's display is absolutely horrid! It will be bye-bye as soon as the MBA arrives.
Where do you find the display # on the new MBA?
JohnG
I'm loving the sharpness of the MacBook Air screen.
Truly better looking than the MBP because of more screen resolution and the small screen.
The text is condensed with the high resolution on a small screen so everything looks amazing!
Truly better looking than the MBP because of more screen resolution and the small screen.
The text is condensed with the high resolution on a small screen so everything looks amazing!
I thought it was good, until I went back to my iPad. The MBA display just totally sucks in comparison. Putting it up next to the iPad or my IPS desktop it just sucks. The colors are not as saturated nor as accurate as the other displays, and the difference side by side is pretty startling.
It does the job, and it is pretty nice in that it isn't overly glossy and has good contrast and pixel density, but I would never use it for photo editing. It just isn't anywhere near as good as an IPS display, or the MBP displays.
It does the job, and it is pretty nice in that it isn't overly glossy and has good contrast and pixel density, but I would never use it for photo editing. It just isn't anywhere near as good as an IPS display, or the MBP displays.
I apologize for coming across bitchy...
Did it work out for you, i.e. did you get the information you wanted (hope I didn't miss your post telling us your model...
Thank you so much! That's very gracious of you. My apologies for getting so miffed.
I'll try to read the posts more carefully before I rush a question. I did find the model: 9CF0. I went to the Apple store and looked at every MBA 13", and it seemed to be an even split between the two models. I couldn't detect a color or quality difference between either model, but that's not saying much considering my tired eyes. At least, I won't notice.
But it is also nice to know (have read) that there is at least one nice person who simply gave you the answer without the insult.
(thanks to gwsat!)
Yes, and I do appreciate it.
ipad? are u joking?
the mba 13 screen is the best laptop screen i've ever seen. it's strikes that perfect balance between glossy and matte. it's a semi-glossy or hyper-matte.
i had the mbp 13 new... pales in comparison to the tightness of the mba 13.
unreal. but hey it's your opinion.
I would say my MBP 13" screen is like a genius at a state school.
But seriously, I prefer my MBP 13" screen over my MBA 11.6" screen. The MBP screen seems crisper, (sorry this is not technical, rather, just an opinion).
I'm taking my 13" MBA into Apple tommorow to have the display looked at.
The display appears to have a gradient, the top half of the display has nice warm colours, while the colours appear washed out on the bottom half of the display. The difference is subtle, but definately annoying. Especially with skin tones, on the top part of the display, skin tones appear slightly warmer (reddish), while on the bottom part, skin tones appear yellow.
I guess I'll see what Apple has to say tommorow.
The display appears to have a gradient, the top half of the display has nice warm colours, while the colours appear washed out on the bottom half of the display. The difference is subtle, but definately annoying. Especially with skin tones, on the top part of the display, skin tones appear slightly warmer (reddish), while on the bottom part, skin tones appear yellow.
I guess I'll see what Apple has to say tommorow.
This has seriously been answered like 5 times in this thread alone:
gwsat said:
It's also been said a bunch of times in the thread that the 9CF0 model doesn't seem to be as good as the 9CDF models.
my bad man and thx, though i'm not reading where i'm reading the bunch of times that the 9cf0 isn't as good as the 9cdf in this thread. in fact, i read none?
what's the diff?
ipad? are u joking?
the mba 13 screen is the best laptop screen i've ever seen. it's strikes that perfect balance between glossy and matte. it's a semi-glossy or hyper-matte.
i had the mbp 13 new... pales in comparison to the tightness of the mba 13.
unreal. but hey it's your opinion.
It's not just my opinion, I actually know what I'm talking about. The iPad looks very similar to my desktop monitor, which is an IPS display with excellent color accuracy and 100% color gamut. The MBA 13 looks noticeably worse than both of them.
It actually looks pretty decent when just using it, but put the MBA up next to a good display and it really seems horrible. Also, there is a significant amount of backlight bleed coming from the bottom of the panel, so I have to keep the dock on the bottom to hide it.
The MBA display is one of the better laptop displays out there, but it is pretty disappointing that Steve Jobs couldn't have learned One More Thing from the iPad: put an amazing display on it.
Also, the MBA displays glossiness is about the same as what I used to have with my Dell Inspiron 9300 It isn't anything particularly special, it only seems that way when you compare it to trash from companies like Asus and Toshiba, as well as the really nice but also super reflective MBP displays.
You could always contact them and ask them to update the review with this information if it's that important to you.
I've really scrutinized the 13 inch 9CF0 screen, and it sure triumphs the MBP 13 in terms of brightness, sharpness and glare, but the colors are not as good.
Considering the MBA is a secondary laptop for road warriors, they made a good tradeoff. I'm sure the extra brigthness, work space and less glare will be super useful for people sitting in airports and other bright places.
Personally, I prefer richer colors because I take alot of pictures. I hope they find screens for the next MBPs that improve on all fronts - time for IPS?
Considering the MBA is a secondary laptop for road warriors, they made a good tradeoff. I'm sure the extra brigthness, work space and less glare will be super useful for people sitting in airports and other bright places.
Personally, I prefer richer colors because I take alot of pictures. I hope they find screens for the next MBPs that improve on all fronts - time for IPS?