Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
For some reason Carrot does not give me the same forecast as the direct source. For example if I choose Accuweather, and then check the Accuweather app, the Carrot reading is actually incorrect.
From what I understand, only the Premium Ultra gives the most actual info. The other subscription types lag a bit behind the original source.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blaine
In the past years I found out that the accuracy of a weather source strongly depends on your location. There is no source that is accurate worldwide. The same goes for weather apps, unless an app supports multiple sources.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Agile55
In addition to the already mentioned Windy and Ventusky (both interesting for weather enthusiasts) I suggest Yr (by the Norwegian Meteorological Institute).

Granted, all these weather apps can't satisfy all users in every corner of the world. YMMV: better to try them and check which one suits your needs.
 


Dark Sky was one of the most popular weather apps for iPhone, but after being bought by Apple, the app has officially shut down. With Dark Sky now no longer working, it has left many of its loyal users wondering what weather app they should now use.

dark-sky-hand.jpg

Users loved Dark Sky thanks to its UI, rich and insightful weather information, and real-time alerts and notifications. Apple bought Dark Sky in 2020 and ported over many of its features into the stock weather app on iPhone. Below, we've listed five popular weather apps for iPhone, according to the App Store. All of the apps are free, but some of them have subscriptions to unlock additional in-app features.

1. Apple Weather

weather-app-ios-16-modules-1.jpg

The Apple Weather app comes pre-installed on every iPhone. The app uses data from multiple sources and has seen a major facelift in the last year with richer weather information, thanks to Apple's purchase of Dark Sky. Apple Weather includes real-time alerts, notifications, and warnings for heavy rain, hurricanes, and more in select areas. Apple Weather is entirely free to use. [Direct Link]

2. CARROT Weather

carrot-weather-2.jpg

CARROT Weather is one of the most popular weather apps on iPhone, thanks to its unique design and personality. Unlike most weather apps, CARROT Weather has a sense of personality with snarky and sometimes "overkill" comments and commentary about the weather. On top of its unique character, the app has insightful and rich weather information, with an in-app subscription unlocking additional features such as notifications, widgets, and more. [Direct Link]

3. AccuWeather

accuweather-1.jpeg

AccuWeather is one of the oldest weather apps on iPhone, built on the data provided by AccuWeather. AccuWeather has rich and advanced weather data, supported by satellite imagery and its trademarked "Superior Accuracy" approach to weather. AccuWeather is free on the App Store but does have an in-app subscription that unlocks additional features. [Direct Link]

4. Weather Channel

weather-channel-1.jpeg

The #1 App Store weather app for iPhone, the Weather Channel is one of the most common and mainstream weather apps people use. With all the typical weather features, Weather Channel provides a free, ad-supported experience on iPhone, with a subscription to enable an ad-free experience, up to 15-minute forecasts, 72-hour future-looking radar predictions, and more. [Direct Link]

5. NOAA Radar & Weather Forecast

NOAA-app-1.jpeg

For users in the United States, an appealing app may be NOAA Radar & Weather Forecast. The app uses rich weather data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which helps the app provide timely and real-time information on storms, wildfires, hurricanes, drought, and more. The free app comes with a subscription that unlocks more detailed forecasts, an ad-free experience, customization features, and more. [Direct Link]

Article Link: Miss Dark Sky? Here Are 5 Top Weather Apps for iPhone
The NOAA app is not free.
 
I believe longer-term forecasts are generally straight-up source weather data. The short term forecasts (say < 1 hr) are based on custom modeling from things like realtime radar sources and local weather stations.

I suspect there will be model tuning over time, with companies like Apple either suggestion changes to the upstream weather models or doing longer-term forecasting themselves.
I also wonder - what other job can you keep your job when you are wrong the majority of the time?
 
Anybody from the UK reading this? A big issue with a lot of these apps is that they use third-rate weather services that don't have the accuracy, knowledge or reputation of the Met Office. Are there any weather apps (aside from the Met Office's own) that use Met Office data? Even the BBC doesn't nowadays.
The Apple Weather app seems to have improved considerably - not sure exactly when, or how much has been from changes to the app itself, and how much to the data delivered?

It does seem to reliably get genuine Met Office alerts.

The local info. has sometimes managed to report the current rain shower will stop in 23 minutes (or some such prediction) with incredible accuracy. Indeed, as I typed thta, it was raining quite hard then faded to almost no rain. Apple Weather changed almost on the dot. Met Office still sums up the whole hour as Light Rain - not accurate at either end of the hour.

And the worst mistake was the other day when it said no rain all day - only to get quite heavy hail/rain around lunch-time. But the lack of rain in the forecast was shown identically by the Met Office.

I prefer the Apple Weather's use of numbers 0 to 11 for UV - with the names added - rather than Met Office's names-only.

But I do agree that all other weather apps/sources seem not as good as Met Office and, now, Apple Weather.
 
  • Like
Reactions: woolypants
There's also the ridiculously overpriced Not Boring Weather. I just use Apple Weather which is plenty enough.
 
AccuWeather IS strikingly accurate, esp. for short-term (e.g., just a few hours) forecasts. But best overall (IMHO) is Weatherunderground. Excellent visualizations and detailed, accurate forecasts.
 
Anybody from the UK reading this? A big issue with a lot of these apps is that they use third-rate weather services that don't have the accuracy, knowledge or reputation of the Met Office. Are there any weather apps (aside from the Met Office's own) that use Met Office data? Even the BBC doesn't nowadays.
I’m in the UK. I just look out the window if I want to see what the weather is doing. It’s much more accurate.
 
From what I understand, only the Premium Ultra gives the most actual info. The other subscription types lag a bit behind the original source.

This is actually with premium ultra. I had it for a while but canceled this year because the Apple Weather app worked just as well and the watch complication updates more frequently.
 
This is actually with premium ultra. I had it for a while but canceled this year because the Apple Weather app worked just as well and the watch complication updates more frequently.

Hm, that‘s a pity. I also canceled my subscription (had Premium), because too many things only were available in USA and GB. I also had discrepancies between Carrot with the Meteogroup source and the weather app of Meteogroup (WeatherPro).
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarAnalogy
My go-to app for years now has been WeatherMate. I moved to it when Intellicast shut down.

WeatherMate

It's by far the best layout and has radar imagery that's useful. Dark Sky's -- and now Apple's -- radar imagery simply sucks.

I did use Dark Sky side by side with WeatherMate. I liked the alerts Dark Sky had, but the latest app just isn't as functional, efficient, and informative as WeatherMate.
 
I really like Hello Weather! Been using it for a few years. They have a LOT of widget support!

Simplest app left available and my preferred. It’s all about data AT A GLANCE. I want to be able to open a weather app and see humidity, rain chances, forecast, dew point, all those simple things FAST and without scrolling or clicking through interface options. Of the dozens of apps that I have trialed, only Hello Weather or Carrot even come close.
 
I find WeatherPro really good in the UK

WeatherPro (source Meteogroup) is also good here in The Netherlands. But the app hasn’t been seriously updated for years. The maps are looking old now and have low resolution. That’s the reason I cancelled my subscription 2 years ago (I have been using this app for like 8 years).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bydandie
I am going to try out Foreca. That is the default source that CARROT uses.

To remove the adds on Foreca, it is $2.99/year USD. You can customize it a lot.

Yes, Foreca is a very nice app with good weather predictions. Alas for my region it was too pessimistic about its rain predictions. A bit pessimistic is OK (better than too optimistic), but Foreca predicted too often rain that never came.
 
I paid for DarkSky. I presume that Apple monetized this app to the tune of 30%. And then Apple took it away. If I buy another one of these, will Apple take it away? Do I get a refund?
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: SilverRubicon
Many people are saying they love the 🥕 Carrot App. I'm sure it serves a good purpose and it's an amazing app but they need to come up with a better name.

It has won an Apple Design Award and App Store Award with that name. It's doing fine.

I agree. It is because he has to pay for all the weather services.

This right here. There's people upset by subscriptions for weather apps but getting that weather data isn't free (after a certain number of requests are reached in the case of WeatherKit).
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.