Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mattopotamus

macrumors G5
Jun 12, 2012
14,738
6,109
Is this consistent. The problem I hear with the Nexus 5 is that the battery does not consistently perform well. It does so on occasion.

That's how it has been for me since the day I got it (launch day order)
 

thadoggfather

macrumors P6
Oct 1, 2007
16,134
17,049
Nexus 5 all day every day.

Especially with 4.4.1 onward, that camera is working MUCH better.

The dev community for Nexus devices is amazing. Got my smaller nav bars, volume mod for earphones, viper4android sound tweaking, Nexus one boot animation, and double tap 2 wake with saturated colors Franco kernel running on 4.4.2. Oh and ART rules.

It's bliss just reverting some things to stock, dirty OTA flashing, and putting them back on as opposed to starting fresh and restoring every time a jailbreak comes out for a new version, which mind you isn't often.

Of course if you're riding the jailbreak train you don't care about the wait, or maybe even iOS 7 all together (I'm not updating my iPad 3 past 6.1.2, jailbreak or not), but that bigger screen and open customization out of the box, custom recovery, and one simple procedure to unlock the bootloader. Oh and perhaps the sweetest of all is the reasonable and amazing deal of the unsubsidized price that this phone is for having the same S800 in Note 3 and LG G2. I'm not sure what else a tinkerer could want. Moto X is nice, but Nexus 5 hardware is undeniably superior.

And LightFlow with this phone, so chill.
 

JH-

macrumors 6502
Feb 25, 2009
392
2
Nexus 5 all day every day.

Especially with 4.4.1 onward, that camera is working MUCH better.

The dev community for Nexus devices is amazing. Got my smaller nav bars, volume mod for earphones, viper4android sound tweaking, Nexus one boot animation, and double tap 2 wake with saturated colors Franco kernel running on 4.4.2. Oh and ART rules.

It's bliss just reverting some things to stock, dirty OTA flashing, and putting them back on as opposed to starting fresh and restoring every time a jailbreak comes out for a new version, which mind you isn't often.

Of course if you're riding the jailbreak train you don't care about the wait, or maybe even iOS 7 all together (I'm not updating my iPad 3 past 6.1.2, jailbreak or not), but that bigger screen and open customization out of the box, custom recovery, and one simple procedure to unlock the bootloader. Oh and perhaps the sweetest of all is the reasonable and amazing deal of the unsubsidized price that this phone is for having the same S800 in Note 3 and LG G2. I'm not sure what else a tinkerer could want. Moto X is nice, but Nexus 5 hardware is undeniably superior.

And LightFlow with this phone, so chill.

And if you're not a tinkerer?
 

mattopotamus

macrumors G5
Jun 12, 2012
14,738
6,109
And if you're not a tinkerer?

I don't really tinker and liked the n5 better. I actually think it is better b.c it is pretty great even without a launcher. On the moto I still had to use a launcher to delete unwanted home screens.
 

hashholly

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 13, 2008
436
119
The Nexus 5 won. After a day or so using both, i just shipped back the Moto X this morning.

While activate notifications are cool, along with touch less control, the bigger screen of the Nexus 5 won out. The Nexus 5 is noticeably faster, and i can see myself using the Wireless charging ability everyday.

I will say the build quality on the Moto X is great, and I highly recommend it for someone that is coming from an iPhone 5/5S/5C and like that size as it isn't much bigger.

I will note that LG/Google must have worked out their kinks because My screen looks great, gps works, the speakers are loud (not near Moto X loud, but loud enough, and the signal strength was about the same as the Moto X in test on Tmobile.
 

JH-

macrumors 6502
Feb 25, 2009
392
2
The Nexus 5 won. After a day or so using both, i just shipped back the Moto X this morning.

While activate notifications are cool, along with touch less control, the bigger screen of the Nexus 5 won out. The Nexus 5 is noticeably faster, and i can see myself using the Wireless charging ability everyday.

I will say the build quality on the Moto X is great, and I highly recommend it for someone that is coming from an iPhone 5/5S/5C and like that size as it isn't much bigger.

I will note that LG/Google must have worked out their kinks because My screen looks great, gps works, the speakers are loud (not near Moto X loud, but loud enough, and the signal strength was about the same as the Moto X in test on Tmobile.

You're not helping me stick to my decision buying the X. The only thing I dislike about the Nexus was the weak volume and vibration.
 

hashholly

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 13, 2008
436
119
You're not helping me stick to my decision buying the X. The only thing I dislike about the Nexus was the weak volume and vibration.

Personally, I'm glad i tried out both at the same time, and waited as long as i did to get on the Nexus 5 train, because most of the launch day issues seem to be fixed.

What issues did you have with vibration?
 

mattopotamus

macrumors G5
Jun 12, 2012
14,738
6,109
The Nexus 5 won. After a day or so using both, i just shipped back the Moto X this morning.

While activate notifications are cool, along with touch less control, the bigger screen of the Nexus 5 won out. The Nexus 5 is noticeably faster, and i can see myself using the Wireless charging ability everyday.

I will say the build quality on the Moto X is great, and I highly recommend it for someone that is coming from an iPhone 5/5S/5C and like that size as it isn't much bigger.

I will note that LG/Google must have worked out their kinks because My screen looks great, gps works, the speakers are loud (not near Moto X loud, but loud enough, and the signal strength was about the same as the Moto X in test on Tmobile.

very similar to my experience. "Nexus 5 is noticeably faster." I felt the exact same way and think most reviews do not do side by side comparisons....they must not be. The moto is smooth, but like you mentioned the n5 is clearly much smoother to the point I got frustrated with the moto x.
 

mKTank

macrumors 68000
Jul 2, 2010
1,537
3
it could have a lot to do with kitkat...something the note 3 does not have.

KitKat does improve things a lot yes. But when I was on 4.2.2 I used to still get around 8 hours. Now I assume...9 or 10 perhaps? I'll be testing it today and I guess we'll see.
 

WilliamBateman

macrumors regular
Nov 7, 2013
207
0
Um I can get near 8 hours of screen on time easily with my Moto X and will prove it tonight. You're doing something wrong indeed.

LOL! Who are you trying to fool? I have the Moto X, its battery is sub par at best. Maybe if the screen is on while you are on a call you can get MAYBE 4 hours but using it normally, no way. I can literally watch my battery percentage drop about 1% for every 5-6 minutes I am browsing the web or playing a game. 8 hours screen time LOL! This is under normal usage here. Facebook, Instagram, emails and web browsing. I was asleep and not touching the phone for 9 of these 18 hours...
 

Attachments

  • Moto1.png
    Moto1.png
    142.2 KB · Views: 120
  • Moto2.png
    Moto2.png
    94.1 KB · Views: 106

JC17

macrumors member
Oct 8, 2013
70
0
That look's like something's wrong to be honest.
This is my G2 right now.
Standard games and twitter and a few videos
And lots of work on Google drive .

meperu8a.jpg


eby3u7ep.jpg
 

mKTank

macrumors 68000
Jul 2, 2010
1,537
3
Yeah I have no idea what this guy's doing but I've been browsing the web for about an hour now (50% brightness minimum auto brightness) while streaming from Songza with 2 bars of wifi and one or two bars of LTE signal (downstairs in my house doesn't get much of a signal). Will post pics in a second.
 

JH-

macrumors 6502
Feb 25, 2009
392
2
Personally, I'm glad i tried out both at the same time, and waited as long as i did to get on the Nexus 5 train, because most of the launch day issues seem to be fixed.

What issues did you have with vibration?

Just couldn't feel it. It was very weak to me.
 

vikingjunior

Cancelled
Aug 17, 2011
1,319
590
Did anyone by chance get an extra $150 off promo code for the Moto X or not going to use theirs? They sold out in 12 minutes. Thanks.
 

mKTank

macrumors 68000
Jul 2, 2010
1,537
3
ZNFYilu.jpg


yjLbkRX.jpg


HaeSBIt.jpg


Your picture had nearly 20 hours on the phone without charging. Surely you must know that the active display and the touchless control takes some battery in standby...

But hey, all the reviews are wrong and this guy's historically proven bias against the Moto X is surely the one to trust, right?
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.