Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

3247

macrumors regular
Feb 9, 2008
237
4
Germany
That's what I don't understand (but probably should know). Is it piracy to trade a product that is not being sold anymore? I guess it is, otherwise the previous poster wouldn't have said that I'm advocating piracy.
If you don't want to sell me your Mac, is it theft if I just take it?
Copyright violations are copyright violations, regardless of whether the software is currently available for purchase. It's even illegal to pirate old Commodore 64 games without the copyright holder's permission.
Well… whoever sues would have a hard time proving that they hold the copyright.
 

manu chao

macrumors 604
Jul 30, 2003
7,224
3,031
That's what I don't understand (but probably should know). Is it piracy to trade a product that is not being sold anymore? I guess it is, otherwise the previous poster wouldn't have said that I'm advocating piracy.
Is it piracy to copy music that was released on a limited edition CD?

Unless the original creator has allowed others to create copies, it is not legal.
 

Fofer

macrumors 6502a
Oct 24, 2002
688
123
Well if you have a copy of BoxOffice (as recommended by Gizmodo) you can give it a try yourself as Apple pulled it.

As a matter of fact, I do have BoxOffice... I downloaded all 4 "movie time" apps available, even paid for OneTap, but ended up keeping BoxOffice... because it was the best of the bunch.

So, my first question is... why was it pulled? :confused: :eek: :(
I really, really hope it's not gone for good.
And why hasn't there been more coverage of this bad news?
I've exchanged emails with the developer over the last week, sending him suggestions, accolades and whatnot, and he'd let me know he had some good stuff planned ahead... so I'm going to write him and ask what happened to his app.


As far as seeing if I, as a previous downloader, can re-download, the answer is no... because there's not even a page for it on the App Store anymore. It doesn't show up in searches. And if I click a link to get there I am told that it's no longer available for sale in the U.S. There's no way for me to click "download" because I can't even reach the product page.

One hopes that (a) Box Office comes back, (b) it continues to work.

In the meantime, I've gotta be careful not to delete it, because it seems I wouldn't be able to get it back from Apple...
:mad:
 

Eraserhead

macrumors G4
Nov 3, 2005
10,434
12,250
UK
As a matter of fact, I do have BoxOffice... I downloaded all 4 "movie time" apps available, even paid for OneTap, but ended up keeping BoxOffice... because it was the best of the bunch.

So, my first question is... why was it pulled? :confused: :eek: :(

Because Apple likes pulling applications for no reason I guess.

And why hasn't there been more coverage of this bad news?

I don't know.
 

Fofer

macrumors 6502a
Oct 24, 2002
688
123
Because Apple likes pulling applications for no reason I guess.
I'm sure there's a better reason that that. I'll pass along what I hear from the developer.

I suppose one fear could be that Apple identified something "wrong" with the app... some security breach perhaps? If that were the case, I'd hope they'd find it appropriate to email everyone who downloaded it.



Strange things are afoot...
 

phannon666

macrumors regular
Feb 1, 2008
185
0
Bucks, UK
Methinks if this app was removed because it shouldn't have actually been allowed in the first place, wouldn't there be some kind of "update" or other way to prevent anyone who did manage to get it from running it? This makes me think there may have been something more urgently wrong, and it may be back in a few days.
 

slate1

macrumors regular
Sep 12, 2006
202
0
I'm sure there's a better reason that that. I'll pass along what I hear from the developer.

I suppose one fear could be that Apple identified something "wrong" with the app... some security breach perhaps? If that were the case, I'd hope they'd find it appropriate to email everyone who downloaded it.



Strange things are afoot...

I'm wondering if some of the sites that these applications are culling their information from are starting to whine? The BoxOffice application is one of my favorites - however, it grabs data and graphics from Rotten Tomatoes, Fandango, Yahoo, and What's Showing. I can't help but think that one of these sites complained...
 

ViViDboarder

macrumors 68040
Jun 25, 2008
3,447
2
USA
I find this amusing more than disapointing. There was no way this was going to stay in the app store, it's just HILARIOUS that it ever made it there to begin with!!! It had to host a proxy server or something and utilize the same method used on jailbroken phones but from within the "sandbox". It's classic.
 

urrl78

macrumors member
Oct 26, 2006
89
0
Thanks for the tease Apple. I'll keep my jailbroken, tethering iPhone 3G thanks, still working well enough for me. I can use both my Powerbook and MBP at the same time, and if I keep the network signal alive with the Powerbook I can get into Bootcamp XP on my MBP and get on in Windows. Not too shabby.
 

termina3

macrumors 65816
Jul 16, 2007
1,078
1
TX
I'm surprised someone hasn't mentioned this (maybe I just missed it)…

Did it occur to anyone that someone from AT&T made a phone call to have Apple take it down? Perhaps this wasn't just Apple going crazy?
 

chrisblaze

macrumors member
Mar 12, 2008
60
1
http://www.speedtest.net/result/303336412.png

303336412.png

thanks, thats not too shabby!
 

buymeaniphone

macrumors 6502
Feb 8, 2007
303
0
San Antonio, Texas
Video Demonstration

That's funny, I just did a video demonstration of this on my MacBook. It works great and is actually pretty fast. I've heard that some people have been either fined or have received letters from AT&T stating that their data plan has been dropped due to high usage. It's funny how unlimited data really doesn't mean unlimited. I really don't see how a few hundred people using their iPhones to tether their laptops will bring down AT&T's data servers and cause a lot of havoc for AT&T
 

imacgeek

macrumors newbie
Jun 25, 2007
20
0
Any Store

Has anyone found any store in the world that still has this app? that would be a great help to everyone.
 

leukotriene

macrumors regular
Aug 1, 2008
148
0
distribute the source code instead?

STUPID QUESTION:
Would it be possible for an enterprising developer to write an app that tethers 3G to a laptop (i.e. an open source recreation of NetShare) and instead of putting it on the App Store, just distribute the source code as tarball for people to compile and load onto their iPhones (at least those with Apple dev accounts)?

Surely the mere distribution of Obj-C code is not illegal or breaking any EULA?
 

smook

macrumors newbie
Jul 21, 2008
5
0
Toronto
you can't make yourself from another country. Only if you have another credit card from a country that itunes supports and have a billing address in that country. I've tried it to get albums overseas that were released before they were here in the US.


NOT SO !!!

Here's the trick. But it's not really a trick at all.

I'm in Canada. I buy a US itunes gift card in the US or eBay. (hehe!)

Redeem the gift card. (use different email address, from canadian store, since it's the login for itunes).

Then change user name to usname@domain.com while in iTunes and it transfers me from the Canadian Store to the US store. Sync iphone. It now thinks it's a US iphone. Go to appstore on iphone. BUY whatever I like. Then proceed to change cdnname@domain.com back to Canadian Store.. etc etc.

Works for AppleTV too... since it's an iTunes too.

Any questions just ask.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.