Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Except when the original bendgate with the iPhone 6. The reactions were the same as yours. But the truth came out, internal Apple documents confirmed that they knew it had a higher probability of bending and even made design changes to the 6S to strengthen the weak points.

Did the iPhone 6 have 45ish% of it's surface area compromised (glass shattered) before bending? Facts matter.

Yes if your glass is shattered AND you are even further careless enough to sit on it aluminum will bend. Shocker there.

I bet if shattered the display of a XPS laptop and then sat on the thin aluminum lid it would bend/break too. Physics.

Giving this clickbait clown any credence keeps him in business making thousands off suckers clicking his videos.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Never mind
Except when the original bendgate with the iPhone 6. The reactions were the same as yours. But the truth came out, internal Apple documents confirmed that they knew it had a higher probability of bending and even made design changes to the 6S to strengthen the weak points.
I was one of those who had an iPhone 6 for 3 years that didn’t bend, most likely because I didn’t sit on it.

Did you own an iPhone 6 that bent?
 
I was one of those who had an iPhone 6 for 3 years that didn’t bend, most likely because I didn’t sit on it.

Did you own an iPhone 6 that bent?

I did, and had an Authorized Repair Shop deny warranty on it with with a straight face because it was not flush. I do not put my phone in my back pockets EVER. Later the Apple Store itself exchanged my phone with no issues, but I think they took some time to acknowledge that Bendgate was real. FWIW none of my iPhones since then have bent and my pockets haven't changed.
 
I did, and had an Authorized Repair Shop deny warranty on it with with a straight face because it was not flush. I do not put my phone in my back pockets EVER. Later the Apple Store itself exchanged my phone with no issues, but I think they took some time to acknowledge that Bendgate was real. FWIW none of my iPhones since then have bent and my pockets haven't changed.
I can imagine being annoyed if that happened to me. I guess my wife and I were lucky both our phone lasted 3 years without bending.
 
What if you wait...and Apple just makes the next iPad Pro even THINNER! Heh heh heh
Then it will be the new iPad wafer ;)
[doublepost=1541925480][/doublepost]
No, it still provides rigidity when it's a complete and unbroken piece of glass. Just like it does in any other tablet or smartphone. It may be big and thin, but it's not flexible. The glass, in combination with the chassis, of any of these devices plays an important part in the overall structural integrity.
Try bending an LG OLED or a Sony AF8 TV and see how much a wafer thin piece of glass helps provide rigidity, it doesn't. Thickness has to increase over surface area to provide rigidity and unless the iPad is using a really tough glass it wont.

Example being toughened glass is five times stronger than annealed glass of the same thickness. The iPad Pro 2018 seems to have a much thinner glass which unless super tough will reduce the strength and integrity of that glass as the surface increases. Also its a first generation product of a new design and already new units have arrived warped. A iPad should not crumple if dropped. Its a tool and should be strong enough for a few drops in its life, and to be able to arrive new and not warped in the box.

My old Air 2 has had a few drops, I'm disabled and due to high levels of Morphine for pain I tend to loose my coordination now and then. My iPad Air 2 has never once buckled on impact in over 4 years, but the fact that the new one seems so easily bent is a a big concern. The iPhone 6 plus was weak and some bent, the 6s plus had points in its chassis that were made more substantial like around the volume buttons were it bent easily and was also made out of a higher grade Aluminium to try to resist the whole bending issue in the first place. I love the look of the new iPads but it has to much empty space around the edges for magnets by the looks of it which may weaken it possibly and it seems to bend and crumple far to easily too. I guess we will have to wait and see how durable they are.
 
A cracked screen is a very common issue, a cracked screen will also mess with the structural integrity, that’s my concern of the weakness of the frame. Not everyone will run out to replace a cracked screen, especially if it’s off to the side.
Then don’t buy one, simple fix...

I have had all giant iPhones that gets far more pressure put on them and they haven’t had any issues, does that mean it’ll never happen? No. But if you’re so worried about it then skip the iPad and get something else or an older model. No one can stop physics, and no matter what anyone says here, you won’t be comforted or convinced, so just do what will make you the least stressed... imagine that would be that you don’t buy one. :)


Kallum.
 
Then don’t buy one, simple fix...

I have had all giant iPhones that gets far more pressure put on them and they haven’t had any issues, does that mean it’ll never happen? No. But if you’re so worried about it then skip the iPad and get something else or an older model. No one can stop physics, and no matter what anyone says here, you won’t be comforted or convinced, so just do what will make you the least stressed... imagine that would be that you don’t buy one. :)


Kallum.

When I look at the chamfered edges at my 12.9 gen 2 my feeling tells me that this construction is sturdier than the flat edges from the new one. Maybe someone explain that physically. It never came to my mind that I can bend my previous iPads. What worries me also was the ripples that the guy with the drop test video produces. Ones upon a time Apple was famous for their sturdy cases when they are introducing the Unibody design....
 
I was one of those who had an iPhone 6 for 3 years that didn’t bend, most likely because I didn’t sit on it.

Did you own an iPhone 6 that bent?

I had the 6 for over a year with perfectly normal usage and didn’t have any problem with any kind of bending
 
it certainly sounds the folio is a necessity.

Which is sad because it makes it thick, heavy and ugly. You need it a least to work on a flat table because of the camera bump. The one-sided Smart Cover from the previous iPads was a better better concept in my eyes....
 
TBH, the 2018 iPP feels more sturdy than when I had the first 2 iPPs, I don’t know why though.



Kallum.
Yeah I don’t know why either. Did you just hold it or actually try to bend it? There’s your answer
 
This just in: metal bends, in fact anything will bend if you try hard enough. These videos and threads are so stupid.
I heard the same, in fact I just was playing around wth a thin steel bar and was able to bend it using my hand, I also took one of those steel frame iPhone Xs’ and bent it with my thumb... but I think it’s because I have super srength, it couldn’t possibly be Physics... no way.


Kallum.
 
Except when the original bendgate with the iPhone 6. The reactions were the same as yours. But the truth came out, internal Apple documents confirmed that they knew it had a higher probability of bending and even made design changes to the 6S to strengthen the weak points.

Wasn't it mainly the 6 Plus? The 6 is small enough to avoid this I think. Looking at my 6 in front of me and it has a perfect shape. This problem becomes bigger with bigger devices at the same thickness. The new iPad 12.9 is thinner than an iPhone 6 which was the thinnest iPhone ever....
 
Then it will be the new iPad wafer

[doublepost=1541925480][/doublepost]

Try bending an LG OLED or a Sony AF8 TV and see how much a wafer thin piece of glass helps provide rigidity, it doesn't. Thickness has to increase over surface area to provide rigidity and unless the iPad is using a really tough glass it wont.


Example being toughened glass is five times stronger than annealed glass of the same thickness. The iPad Pro 2018 seems to have a much thinner glass which unless super tough will reduce the strength and integrity of that glass as the surface increases. Also its a first generation product of a new design and already new units have arrived warped. A iPad should not crumple if dropped. Its a tool and should be strong enough for a few drops in its life, and to be able to arrive new and not warped in the box.


My old Air 2 has had a few drops, I'm disabled and due to high levels of Morphine for pain I tend to loose my coordination now and then. My iPad Air 2 has never once buckled on impact in over 4 years, but the fact that the new one seems so easily bent is a a big concern. The iPhone 6 plus was weak and some bent, the 6s plus had points in its chassis that were made more substantial like around the volume buttons were it bent easily and was also made out of a higher grade Aluminium to try to resist the whole bending issue in the first place. I love the look of the new iPads but it has to much empty space around the edges for magnets by the looks of it which may weaken it possibly and it seems to bend and crumple far to easily too. I guess we will have to wait and see how durable they are.


I’m not saying these iPads won’t bend, they will, of course they will, given enough force. If you look around you’ll find bent iPad reports for the iPad Air, Mini, Air 2, all of the iPad Pro’s and all iPhones from the iPhone 4 onward.



The thing we’re debating here is the fact that the first video posted is showing a structurally compromised iPad being bent. There’s a world of difference between that and one that isn’t.


As for the difference between a 55” OLED and an iPad, that’s another thing altogether, aside from the very significant size difference. Apple has long been rumoured to use aluminosilicate glass in its iPads for a number of years now, I’d put pound to penny my OLED TV doesn’t.


I’m sure many folk on these forums will know by now that I have severe nerve damage. I take a massive amount of morphine and other pills all day every day. Dropping things is de rigueur for me.


My first generation iPad Pro has been dropped more times than I can count, as was my 10.5”, with no consequences whatsoever. So maybe one of those would be better for you if you’re worried.


For what it’s worth, my 2018 12.9” iPad Pro has been dropped three times so far, which made me draw breath as I’ve not yet taken delivery of its back skin (I always fit a skin because I like to use them without a case, but protect them from scratching due to inevitable drops.) So far though, not so much as a scratch. Maybe I’m just lucky.
 
Wasn't it mainly the 6 Plus? The 6 is small enough to avoid this I think. Looking at my 6 in front of me and it has a perfect shape. This problem becomes bigger with bigger devices at the same thickness. The new iPad 12.9 is thinner than an iPhone 6 which was the thinnest iPhone ever....
My mom had the 6+ for 3 years, and my wife and I both had 6 normals for 3 years (we all got the iPhone X at the same time).

Guess what? No bending of any phone.

Did you have a 6+ that bent?
[doublepost=1541942018][/doublepost]
Stop bending your stuff. There problem solved.
Also, stop claiming things bend if you didn't own one that bent.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: George Dawes
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.