Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

New iPad Pro's Actual Design Kinda Sucks

I don't hate the design but it's kinda boring. I was hoping for a matte black color or maybe fun colors like the iPhone XR.

Either that or replicating the shiny stainless steel on some of the iPhones or Apple Watch.
 
DNichter said:
I think its so you can still attach the pencil. I generally take really good care anyway so not too worried, plus I think it looks cool.
[doublepost=1540926094][/doublepost]

The smart folio?
Click to expand...
That would be correct. The new pencil charges by attaching to the side of the iPad so it needs to be open. I mean, new modern rounded design of the current iPhones would've looked nice on the iPad, but the current design choice brings back the classic look with a modern take of slim profile + slim bezels -- I think it's perfect. It's a professional and clean look.
 
Sumter said:
That would be correct. The new pencil charges by attaching to the side of the iPad so it needs to be open. I mean, new modern rounded design of the current iPhones would've looked nice on the iPad, but the current design choice brings back the classic look with a modern take of slim profile + slim bezels -- I think it's perfect. It's a professional and clean look.
Click to expand...

I agree, very professional and industrial look. I like it a lot.
 
I'm probably on my own here, but I would have preferred something that was literally a larger iPhone X/XS. I like the rounded edges of the X/XS, I prefer the OLED screen (yes, I know it's expensive - an option would have been nice), and I like the glass back. I've never dropped an iphone or an iPad, and I think it would have negated the need for the really ugly cellular lines on the back.

I don't hate the new design, but I think it could have been nicer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: loybond
in the presentation it did look somewhat dull/ bland, but i expect it will probably look sleeker and shinier in person!
 
The functionality is great with the pencil. They basically got the inspiration* from Microsoft.
Most people will scuff at us but not everyone who is a "pro" loves gray and dark gray finishes... I prefer the aesthetics of the previous versions. It was a lot more feminine too. I am sure this is a non issue for most people......
 
Tapiture said:
I think it's basically a compromise for being able to decrease the bezels and keep battery life up at the same time. I would have rather had it be a few millimeters thicker with better battery and pill shaped edges, but Apple still seems obsessed with making things ridiculously thin, even if it seems to cause compromises on other design aspects (why?)
Click to expand...
That's simply not true. Look at the latest iPhones, many of which are thicker and heavier than their predecessors. A portable device like a tablet that's already unwieldy size, needs to be thin and light. When they reduced the weight from the iPad 4 to the iPad Air. it became a much more comfortable form factor to hold and use.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexJoda
Tapiture said:
I tend to agree. I was actually a bit disappointed with how large the bezels were, too. I like the chamfered edges, but they were also a fragile pain in the ass that got very noticeable nicks at the drop of a hat. Overall, the design to me just doesn't look like something I'd pay $800 for.
Click to expand...
Couldn’t agree more, the bezels could be loads smaller than what they are!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tapiture
The flat edges are probably for the pencil to have enough surface area to have a good magnetic bond without it easily falling off when you set the iPad down or brush it against something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rui no onna, Rogifan and frou
bpeeps said:
That's simply not true. Look at the latest iPhones, many of which are thicker and heavier than their predecessors. A portable device like a tablet that's already unwieldy size, needs to be thin and light. When they reduced the weight from the iPad 4 to the iPad Air. it became a much more comfortable form factor to hold and use.
Click to expand...
Whether or not they do it with the phones is not a concern of mine in this context. They do it with laptops to a fault, causing thermal issues. They’ve been making iPads thinner which up to this point I’ve been okay with. But when they start making compromises in the name of making it thin, they’ve reached the point of diminishing returns.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rui no onna
Yeah a blown up xs would have been beautiful.

ninethirty said:
I'm probably on my own here, but I would have preferred something that was literally a larger iPhone X/XS. I like the rounded edges of the X/XS, I prefer the OLED screen (yes, I know it's expensive - an option would have been nice), and I like the glass back. I've never dropped an iphone or an iPad, and I think it would have negated the need for the really ugly cellular lines on the back.

I don't hate the new design, but I think it could have been nicer.
Click to expand...
[doublepost=1540931714][/doublepost]I was a bit disappointed with the bezels too

BenjaminRF said:
Couldn’t agree more, the bezels could be loads smaller than what they are!
Click to expand...
[doublepost=1540931804][/doublepost]Can you imagine a gold stainless steel colourway?!

concernedone said:
The functionality is great with the pencil. They basically got the inspiration* from Microsoft.
Most people will scuff at us but not everyone who is a "pro" loves gray and dark gray finishes... I prefer the aesthetics of the previous versions. It was a lot more feminine too. I am sure this is a non issue for most people......
Click to expand...
 
  • Like
Reactions: frou
Tapiture said:
Whether or not they do it with the phones is not a concern of mine in this context. They do it with laptops to a fault, causing thermal issues. They’ve been making iPads thinner which up to this point I’ve been okay with. But when they start making compromises in the name of making it thin, they’ve reached the point of diminishing returns.
Click to expand...
Whether or not? The new iPhones are some of the heaviest and thickest phones Apple has ever made. This is not a subjective opinion up for debate, it is a fact. The iPhones have been increasing in size and weight since the iPhone 7 in accordance with the stats posted directly on the Apple site.

OLED screens with a glass back on an iPad would be priced astronomically to both buy and fix. Not to mention, I'd wager a strong bet that the majority of iPad's purchased are the non-LTE models. Especially in a day and age when phone tethering is extremely easy and inexpensive. That's the compromise made to keep the cost margins down. It has nothing to do with diminishing returns for thinness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cornerexit
bpeeps said:
Whether or not? The new iPhones are some of the heaviest and thickest phones Apple has ever made. This is not a subjective opinion up for debate, it is a fact.

OLED screens with a glass back on an iPad would be priced astronomically to both buy and fix. Not to mention, I'd wager a strong bet that the majority of iPad's purchased are the non-LTE models. Especially in a day and age when phone tethering is extremely easy and inexpensive. That's the compromise made to keep the cost margins down. It has nothing to do with diminishing returns for thinness.
Click to expand...
You lost me in the second paragraph. Apple isn’t required to make every device thinner and thinner unless they add OLED/glass back. They COULD keep it the same thickness and tack on some battery life and keep some nice curved edges whilst keeping the aluminum body and LCD screen.
 
Tapiture said:
You lost me in the second paragraph. Apple isn’t required to make every device thinner and thinner unless they add OLED/glass back. They COULD keep it the same thickness and tack on some battery life and keep some nice curved edges whilst keeping the aluminum body and LCD screen.
Click to expand...
No one said they were required to make devices thinner. You invented that.

I still don't see where they've compromised on functionality of the iPad to make it thinner, save for maybe the audio jack. The iPad will never have a glass back, much in the same way a notebook never will either. OLED is only a matter of time. Your personal design wishes don't necessarily make the iPad a better product for the whole.
 
bpeeps said:
No one said they were required to make devices thinner. You invented that.

I still don't see where they've compromised on functionality of the iPad to make it thinner, save for maybe the audio jack. The iPad will never have a glass back, much in the same way a notebook never will either. OLED is only a matter of time. Your personal design wishes don't necessarily make the iPad a better product for the whole.
Click to expand...
I was saying they shouldn’t be required to make them thinner. I’m saying they should be allowed to make things thicker or remain the same thickness in order to improve battery life. Up to now they’ve never done that. They’ve only allowed themselves to make a device thicker if it is adding OLED and glass body.

Basically I disagree with their priorities. I prioritize 3 hours more battery life over 2mm thinner. And as they get thinner and thinner, I feel like they make more compromises for each millimeter lost.
 
gorkt said:
The flat edges are probably for the pencil to have enough surface area to have a good magnetic bond without it easily falling off when you set the iPad down or brush it against something.
Click to expand...

Yeah . . the two things that make me go Hmmm about the new design is that pencil attachment design and the full coverage smart cover/keyboard designs. In concept they look great but the moment one reaches for their 3rd gen IPP and realizes their $130 pencil is missing because it fell off is going to be horrific. Similarly, the traditional soft touch finishes of smart covers/keyboards are prone to wear/discoloration and yet now we're looking at even more expensive covers with the same type of finish.
 
Why do people think OLED would be that expensive? Samsung has multiple tablets with OLED screens (and glass backs) at lower prices, and would be the likely supplier for such a screen. At the numbers Apple needs, cost should not be prohibitive. Even a 55" OLED TV isn't much more expensive than these devices, and that has far higher shipping, storage and fulfilment costs.

They're just holding back so they have a planned road ahead for updates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jamesrick80
Well one negative for me is that I don't think I can use my Logitech charging stand anymore due to the change in the smart connector.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SidBoggle
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back