Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Overkill buying 14” mbp for college student premed?
- Thread starter Truefan31
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Here, fixed it for you:
Ceci n'est pas un message ridicule.
I have a base MacBook Pro 14 inch for basic office work.
Why did I buy an MBP for that when an Air would suffice?
A few reasons
1. I have a lot of disposable income
2. I like having the latest design
3. The bezels look dated on the MBA and older MBP
4. I wanted 120hz
5. I wanted Mini LED
Do I need the power? Absolutely not. But this will last me for years and I intend on keeping it for at least 5 years.
Why did I buy an MBP for that when an Air would suffice?
A few reasons
1. I have a lot of disposable income
2. I like having the latest design
3. The bezels look dated on the MBA and older MBP
4. I wanted 120hz
5. I wanted Mini LED
Do I need the power? Absolutely not. But this will last me for years and I intend on keeping it for at least 5 years.
If portability is important definitely go for the air. Ideally if you can wait a few months for the next air. It really is much more portable, go to an apple store and feel the difference. Portability was by far the biggest reason I chose the MBA over the 14 inch. The difference in screen size is small, and the screen brightness is basically the same, it's only significantly better in HDR mode, i.e. when watching movies.
Speed wise the air is ridiculously fast, and the pro is not much faster, unless you're doing video editing you won't be able to tell.
Me I dislike the bezels on the new design. I would liked to have 120Hz, but I have been living in 60Hz land for laptops for a long time, so no loss. Also, I hardly see any online platforms with faster than 60 fps media.
Fair enough on the bezels. The 120 hz display is amazing, once you use it you can't go back. Even just basic scrolling is buttery smooth. I'd say its my favourite thing about the new MacBooks.
The power of those laptops for just about any college level work is just fine. The screen is large enough without being a pain in the rear end to carry. I suggest biting the bullet and paying for AppleCare (not sure if your original post discussed that). Just do it. Things happen in college. Damaging type things (at least MagSafe is back).
While I agree with 120Hz being better, since I haven't experienced it, I do not miss it nor want it... yet.
Then don't experience it, because it will make what you're used to seem weird and laggy. It ruined 60 Hz for me.
Yes. I'd rather use my 16 inch screen than my Pro Display XDR.
I do have 120Hz on my iPad Pro, but don't really notice much difference when I switch to my 60Hz MBP or MBA. It's a pretty mild effect.
Yeah there’s basically no updating on this now. Hopefully the cpu/ram/storage hold up over time.
Yeah getting at least 4-5 years would be nice, if not more. The display is so nice.
Yeah maybe wwdc will reveal what to expect with the m2 mba. I’ve got 90 days and counting…….lol
A lot can change in four years..... It might be better to focus on the college years right now, get something which will be good for your daughter to use over the next four years. Then maybe at that point you will want to give her a new machine as a graduation gift and to use in medical school if indeed that is still what she wants and she is accepted somewhere.....
Yeah that’s a plan I thought about. Just because the laptops 4-5 years from now will be even better.
Although I do appreciate the sarcasm, I was referring exclusively to laptop screens. Obviously you are not going to prefer your smaller screen to your professional studio display regardless of the refresh rate, although it would be nice if those were high refresh rate as well.
Last edited:
Your kid will graduate with a degree in fine arts, 6 years from now after getting burnt out and taking a year or two off backpacking around Asia to find themselves...
The amount of people who graduate in the program they thought they were going into when they started is probably less than 10. Who gives a rip, buy the MacBook Pro and have a good day, this is such a worthless worry.
The amount of people who graduate in the program they thought they were going into when they started is probably less than 10. Who gives a rip, buy the MacBook Pro and have a good day, this is such a worthless worry.
Likely that will be the case when I upgrade.
Again, I wanted to experience it, but the 13" made more sense to me and given that I haven't experienced 120Hz, it made no difference to me. Also the 14" would have costed me $400 more. I found it hard to justify such price hike given that I would not use any of the hardware acceleration features for video encoding. Furthermore, I have a subtle dislike for the new form factor. Brings vibes of the old plastic white/black MacBooks or Power
Agreed, it's a tough sell to have to shell out around $2k every 4-5 years knowing I shelled $2k for a MacBook that ended up lasting 14 years. Adding the upgrades I ended up spending an extra $500. So total $2.5k for 14 years yields a nice $178.58 per year; that's value.