well like with all things, it's subjective right? as a photographer, i kno that photos can be very unflattering if not taken properly...
that said, i've see her a couple times in real life without makeup and still find her super pretty but, that's just me.... we're all entitled to our opinions =)
Oh yeah, not taking away your right to an opinion. I guess I'm just used to it because I'm Korean and see Korean girls without makeup all the time and don't think it's anything special.