I guess either the costs involved to break out production lines into discrete hues once again; the ability to source enough of dyes for the polycarbonate/ABS for the several assembly factories making these; and/or a reluctance to run into production shortages for model variant hues being exceptionally popular, is what ultimately led them to go with a generic clear shell.
We may speculate forever about the reasons why such decisions were made. I can't imagine it was cost or shortage of supply, since probably 90% of the dye was used for the bulbous iMac, rather than the keyboard/mouse, but perhaps it would cost a lot to ramp up the colours for the mice/keyboard production lines too. I'm no expert.
I think the most likely reason was the urgent need to shift tastes. When Apple announced the fruit iMacs in Jan '99, it was a revolutionary design choice for personal computers. But by 2000, it had been copied so much that it had become kitsch. Besides, as we previously discussed, the first Graphite iMac SE sold really, really well, and Apple used that as market research that people wanted more subdued colours. Were they right? Well actually, probably not – Apple suffered its first revenue loss at the end of 2000 – we can blame the G4 Cube or the lackluster Gigabit Ethernet G4s, or the lack of CD-RWs in the Mac lineup – so perhaps we'll never know if the subtler colours were more appealing or not. Would've been nice if colour had stuck around in the consumer market permanently, just like the iPods started to do.
Also, by 2000 Apple was promoting their products as having revolutionary technologies within, even in their consumer Macs. In 1998-99, the iMac marketing was mostly about ease of use and internet access. By late 99-2000, the emphasis was on awesome features: DVD-Rom, firewire, harmon/kardon speakers, Airport. And of course, the 'Pro' Mouse doesn't sound like same company that made the kid-friendly tray-load iMacs. It was revolutionary too, optical – so even in jewel tones, it doesn't really make sense to ship it in colour anymore - it's too 'pro' for that. And naturally, the keyboard has to do the same.
I suppose it's really about minimalism, too, which was always Apple's aesthetic. The first iMacs were the exception to the rule. Perhaps Jony Ive was craving to focus on the exploration of fine materials, rather than kitschy plastics and colours. ABS->Polycarbonate->Acrylic->Titanium->Aluminium. You can't go back.
It’s a shame, really, and one I lamented ever since the day these were announced to replace the “fruit five” — as Ruby, Sage, and Indigo, along with Snow and Graphite extended keyboards, would have been magnificent to see and use.
Me too. Really was a watershed moment. There's a
brilliant article written at the time of the Summer 2000 event on Ars Technica, which seems to perfectly analyse what those colour changes would mean for the future. It's a long read but well worth it. Here's a bit:
"The new iMacs are still multi-colored, however, even if their keyboards and mice aren't. The colors are too important from a branding perspective for Apple to give them up. But the days of the garish, candy-colored iMacs seem to be over. The new colors are more muted and mature. This seemingly trivial fact highlights a major facet of Apple's strategy.
Many people dismiss Apple's recent hardware as a silly reaction against boring beige: "They're bland and we're garish, hip, and exciting!" But that's not what Apple is doing. Their innovation is the championing of the very concept of style and fashion in the computer industry. Style
changes. Apple's strategy is not tied to "bright colors" or "shiny objects" any more than a fashion designer's strategy is tied to wide lapels, skinny ties, or platform shoes."
It, and the clear mouse replacement with black (and later, white) insert, never really hit home for me, even as I’d come to buy one of the black extended keyboards to replace the graphite keyboard on my Yikes! G4.
Same. There's something a little, idk, impersonal about the acrylic mouse and keyboard? They do look like they're meant to sit behind glass in a modern art museum.
My need for more expressive, colourful accessories is what's driven me to collect 3rd party stuff. As far as I can tell, no one ever made a keyboard to match Apple's jewel tones, but Macally did make optical mice in those colours. I've got one in Indigo. It's much nicer.